California High-Speed Rail Detour Adds $1 Billion in Cost
A reroute around the Cesar Chavez monument added roughly $1 billion to a rail project that's 18 years in without a single track laid.
Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.
The latest California high-speed rail detour — a reroute around the Cesar Chavez National Monument — added about $1 billion to a project that is already 18 years in and has not laid a single mile of track. It’s one more line item in what has become the most expensive infrastructure debacle in the state.
Key Takeaways
- The reroute added about $815 million in 2020 dollars — more than $1 billion today.
- The original 2008 estimate was roughly $33 billion; a revised figure cited reaches about $231 billion.
- The project is 18 years in with no track laid, and about $16–17 billion already spent.
- Federal funding of roughly $4 billion has already been pulled.
Why does the California high-speed rail detour cost $1 billion?
Because rerouting around the Cesar Chavez National Monument — a 187-acre compound and the leader’s final resting place — required more track, more tunneling, and design changes to limit noise near the site. The rail authority had wanted a second adjacent track through the pass, but objections from the National Chavez Center pushed the alignment into a costlier configuration.
High-speed rail here is a state project to connect Los Angeles and San Francisco by bullet train — a plan that, 18 years in, still exists mostly as lines and dots on draft paper. All told, those changes added about $815 million in 2020 dollars, north of a billion today.
How did a $33 billion plan become $231 billion?
By starting without the planning to back it up. The original 2008 estimate was around $33 billion, which leadership later described as “mostly theoretical.” The figure cited in the podcast reached roughly $231 billion, and when officials disputed that number, the safe bet is the higher one — because nothing on this project has come in accurate from the start.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
Difficult terrain didn’t help — the route has to cross the geologically challenging Tehachapi Mountains separating the San Joaquin Valley from the Mojave Desert. But the core failure was project management: they broke ground on a vibe and a deadline, not a plan. This is the same pattern flagged in the train’s earlier funding crisis.
A baby born today will never ride this train in their lifetime.
Will the train ever actually get built?
On the current trajectory, it’s hard to see how. Eighteen years and roughly $16–17 billion in, not a single track has been laid. The authority scaled its own ambitions down to a Merced-to-Bakersfield segment, which is a long way from the San Francisco-to-LA promise that sold the thing.
Federal funding of about $4 billion has already been pulled on the grounds that the state isn’t building anything with it. The pitch now is to attract private financiers — but private capital tends to want a credible payback, and the ridership math on a $200-billion-plus line doesn’t offer one.
How the Cesar Chavez legacy tangled the route
The monument sits on a key rail corridor that already carries about 36 freight trains a day. Ironically, objections centered on the noise a second passenger track would add — enough that the design once contemplated a roughly 1,700-foot dirt berm to conceal the train and blend it into the hills.
Complicating everything, a New York Times investigation surfaced allegations that Chavez abused women, prompting some officials to reconsider streets, schools, and institutions bearing his name. Two Republican senators — John Cornyn of Texas and Bill Cassidy of Louisiana — introduced a bill to defund the monument, which could change the calculus on that segment entirely.
Why this keeps happening in California
Because California is one of the hardest places in the country to build anything. Layers of regulation, multiple cities to satisfy, and constant threats of litigation warp a project until the timeline stretches past most people’s lifetimes. Every redesign — like a potential relocation of a future Merced stop — buys delay.
The state has poured billions into a plan with no consistent path to completion, and the political cost is real: it’s the kind of story that follows a governor with national ambitions. Compare it to the way California’s homeless billions vanished with little to show, and the theme is the same — enormous spending, minimal delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much did the Cesar Chavez detour add?
About $815 million in 2020 dollars — more than $1 billion in today’s dollars — driven by extra track, tunneling, and noise-mitigation design changes.
Has any track been laid?
No. The project is roughly 18 years in with about $16–17 billion spent and not a single mile of track completed.
Did the project lose federal funding?
Yes. Roughly $4 billion in federal funding was pulled, with the reasoning that the state wasn’t actually building anything with it.
Here’s the debate: do you cut the losses now and call it a lesson, or is there any version of this line worth finishing? Make your case in the comments.
Full Episode Transcript
Read the full transcript of this episode
California Governor Gavin Newsom finally declares his run for the presidency. full Los Angeles to San Francisco route. They say the approach could help build different sections at the same time, making the project more attractive to outside funding. That’s why we say can we unlock the private financiers ability to look at the schemes of San Francisco to San Jose to Gilroy and on the other end look at LA Union Station that is commercially viable and not only that I’m saying it. cost total the amount that’s already been spent is somewhere in the neighborhood of 16 17 billion dollars, but we’re now 18 years into this thing and not a single bit of track has been laid despite all of this massive spending and the New York Times has estimated that the project isn’t even on track to be finished this century.
Another example. >> I want to get it done and that’s that’s our commitment. >> But to their Republican Assembly member Ali Macedo argues the money would be better spent elsewhere. She’s calling on Newsom to shift 1 billion dollars per year from high-speed rail to water resources and fire prevention. >> How we So we’re just going to have to reflect on all of that and you know, reflect on a farm workers movement and a labor movement that was much bigger than one man. And celebrate that. It’s about the movement. It’s about farm workers. It’s about labor. >> [music] >> There’s been schools, there’s been all kinds of memorial stuff, just a whole bunch of stuff.
And most of that is just we’re throwing it out the window, toss it out the window because Cesar Chavez he did some stuff that wasn’t appropriate after his death got caught. Much of people women testified. Just horrible. Just I mean terrible. One minute you’re a living legend to the workers of the world, farmers unite, whatever that might have been. And then the next minute they’re demolishing you know, signs of school, Cesar Chavez school. Add one more twist to the complicated legacy of disgraced civil rights leader Cesar Chavez, a reroute around his graveside has inflated the cost of the California’s high-speed rail project by a billion dollars.
It’s going to take a billion dollars to go around. So you’re still going to go around? Or like I said earlier, right down the middle. What are you going to do? What are you going to do? The change, one of many to hobble high-speed rail over the years, stemmed from good intentions. Good intent I mean this thing has been going on for so long. How does it cost a billion dollars to reroute around? You know what I mean? A billion dollars, a thousand million. How do you get that? How do you get that kind of addition to something that cost what it the original cost but it was 33 billion dollars back in the day in 2008, right?
And now literally I recorded the podcast 231 billion is the revised estimate and then officials said, oh no that’s not accurate. Here’s why that’s not accurate and you’re left with probably going to go with the higher of the two if there’s an option because what has been accurate from the get-go on this project? Nothing. Nothing. Cuz leadership has said, well I mean the 33 billion dollar original estimate was mostly theoretical. Uh-huh, okay. All right. Policy makers from California high-speed rail authority had to get the train through the Tehachapi I don’t even know how to pronounce that mountains.
Tech uh Tehachapi Tehachapi. Is that right? I think so. Mountains. Important geologically challenging terrain separating the San Joaquin Valley from the Mojave Desert. One of the hardest words to pronounce in Washington state is Puyallup and it’s spelled p u y a l l u p. When you read it you’re like, what in the F is this the first time and you’re like, oh that’s Puyallup. That’s Puyallup. It’s Indian, right? Everything around here is Indian. They needed to cut a path without causing too much disruption to the Cesar Chavez National Monument, a 187 acre compound. They’re going to be cutting that down too?
I mean uh we gave the dude 187 acres but then you know found out about his extracurricular activities outside of his marriage vows. Mm. Former headquarters of the United Farm Workers and final resting place for the once celebrated leader. Boy, what a fall from grace, right? But now amid allegations that Chavez raped and abused women, not good. Californians have been forced to reconsider the streets, institutions and infrastructure that bears name. We’ve got a ton of them here in Seattle cuz you know, workers of the world unite, let’s boycott Starbucks. It’s going to go well. Including the high-speed rail detour.
It’s they’re going to call it Cesar Chavez. It’s got like this yeah, this long long ass name. Originally framed as an act of preservation and a concession to the farm workers movement rerouting has taken on a more fraught meaning. Uh-huh. It’s another stark example of how politics and threats of litigation have warped the state’s marquee transportation mega project. This project this project I mean just every single time I do a podcast on it it’s it’s something where you know, well the original intentions were good and yet here we are a billion dollars to reroute it. There have been all these opportunities for people to comment on the high-speed alignment and demand that things be mitigated.
Well, as you do when you’re building something in California. California one of the most difficult states to build anything in cuz you’ve just got all of these regulations and you’re dealing with a ton of different cities. The the kicker to me was, hey we know we can’t quite get from San Francisco to LA. We can’t make that happen. I mean not not short-term anyway. So let’s do Merced to Bakersfield. Cuz so many people want to you know, ride the rail between those two cities. Now that’s where I was like, well this thing one of the comments I read was that a baby born today will never ride this train in their lifetime.
Cuz it ain’t happening. It’s not happening. That’s sad. What a waste of money. This is this has been the biggest debacle of of I think all projects. Cuz the the magnitude of it is so great and it was taken on it was taken on under the idea this could be a really cool thing, San Fran to LA. But they didn’t have anything really lined up. They didn’t have their planning. They didn’t they didn’t they didn’t take it the way you should the way that a typical construction company would project manage the operation. They just started, well it’s going to cost roughly 33 billion it should be done by tomorrow at the latest day after tomorrow.
You know, it’s supposed to be done in 2020. Haven’t laid a single track. Not a single track. I mean they got a bunch of the land lined up, done some of the eminent domain where the government comes in and takes it for the greater use of the you know, the folks. She’s watched people throughout So we’ve got Adriana Rizzo. She’s watched people throughout the state call for redesigns that wind up delaying the timeline for high-speed rail and preventing its construction. Ironically [snorts] Chavez monument already sits on a key rail corridor that carries about 36 freight trains each day. But they said with the the light rail to nowhere is going to be too loud.
Too loud. Can’t have that. A single track loops around the property creating a constant rumble for anyone walking among the mission style buildings and courtyards where Chavez lived and organized grape field workers. Okay. All right. And I know you know, labor movements back then were far different than they are today. Starbucks doing my neck my back my paycheck is whack little different than people who were you know, abused for their labor. But then it swung so far the other way that you’re like, okay, yeah, you know, give them that raise because giving them that raise it’s going to take their raise from here to zero, right?
Because minimum wage can always go to zero. You’re fired. High-speed rail authority envisioned building a second adjacent track to whisk bullet trains through the pass, north to Bakersfield or south towards LA. But lawyers of course, lawyers National Chavez Center said no go no go. Too loud. Too loud. >> [snorts] >> To build it the authority would need more track, more tunneling and on top of everything a massive dirt berm stretching about 1,700 feet to conceal the train and blend with the desert hills. Under the refined Cesar Chavez whatever whatever memorial design option impacts would be less than significant during construction and no impact would occur during operation except for that loud rumbling each time the train goes by.
Ah, we’re not doing that. Rizzo saw it differently. She created a curve that would allow the the train down and saw the wall as an unnecessary addition just so people would not have to witness new infrastructure. So you’ve got all this back and forth. Ah, it’s going to do this. Ah, not. It’s not going to do that. All those elements combined added 815 million to the project in 2020 dollars, more than a billion dollars today. So, are they going to they’re going to go around or they just going to ah, you know what? Cesar, we appreciate your efforts, but you know, the things you did to the ladies and girls, some of them were like 13.
Now, are they are they going to dig up his bones and move them somewhere else and just lay that track right down the middle? Don’t know. That’s what the debate is, right? That’s what the debate is. Yeah, it’s kind of this this is kind of just much ado about nothing, isn’t it? Cuz is is this part ever even going to get built? Is this thing ever going to get built? I don’t think so. I think I think at some point in time, you absolutely cut your losses and just go, yeah, you know what? It would have been a pretty cool thing to be able to ride the train from San Fran down to LA in uh what, 2 and 1/2 hours?
Something like that? A few hours, I think it is. Okay, that’s cool. That’s cool. That would be that would be epic. But 231 billion dollars when California doesn’t have the money. Epic, yet not obtainable. And that’s what we’ve all said is hey, this thing isn’t going anywhere. Not doing anywhere. You’re not going anywhere with this bad boy. >> [laughter] >> “We’re constantly reviewing decisions that we’ve made along with that alignment,” said board director Henry Perea, pointing to other potential revisions. Such as the relocation of a future train stop in Merced. Plans that are really lines and dots on draft paper always subject to change.
So, you’re talking about, okay, we can we can change this. Guaranteed on the down low, super quiet. They’ll just, yeah, we’re going to we’re going to we’re going to do a little changey change here. And they’ll have to be they’ll have to be quiet about it. It’ll be on the down low. You won’t hear anything about it. News news flashes will come later so that the politicians making this won’t won’t have to take the heat. But with what Cesar Chavez did, I mean, what he’s accused of doing, he’s not alive to be able to defend himself. Um but there was some pretty credible witness and some folks that came right out and said, hey, this happened to me and a bunch of other people, women, said the same thing that um yeah, last month after an explosive New York Times investigation revealed the allegations of Chavez’s past crimes, fate of his monument suddenly became uncertain.
What’s going to happen? We don’t know. It did not seem appropriate for visitors to tour his office dwelling knowing that people had allegedly been abused there. Oof, not good. Two Republican senators introduced a bill to abolish and defund the monument. All right, that would seem fair, wouldn’t it? Maybe call it a monument to something else. Could that mean it could lose its federal designation and no longer be sustained by taxpayer money. Whether Democrats will join the effort sponsored by John Cornyn of Texas and Bill Cassidy of Louisiana remains unclear. It’s unknown. What a mess. What a mess.
I mean, the whole thing just receptionist answered the phone at the Cesar Chavez National Monument Center Tuesday morning and said it remained open for business 7 days a week. Matt, hey, you want to go there? No. No. No, you know what he did to those girls there? Oh, yeah. You want to still go there? Probably What would you be celebrating? His his efforts at uniting the farm workers? Yeah, but it kind of got marred, didn’t it? Kind of got a little bit overtaken by whatever it is that, you know, he did or didn’t do, allegedly. He’s dead. Enough people came forward and said, mm, yeah. If Congress to were to pass legislation abolishing the monument, it may prompt a different discussion about that specific segment of high-speed rail line.
I bet. I bet. This thing isn’t going anywhere. This thing gets shut down. It just does. I mean, it just does. This is one of those things that will impact Gavin Newsom’s ability to get the nomination for president of the US from the Democrat Party. Just the the the high-speed rail to nowhere because it’s going nowhere. Well, right now, it’s actually going to a cemetery, right? Cemetery plot. 170-something acre one. It’s going right there. Right down the middle. Now, the whole thing has just been an absolute debacle and this is just one more little blip in the overall picture. “Are we actively looking at it from that perspective?
I would say no,” he clarified. “I think the best answer is we’re always looking up and down the alignment for inefficiencies.” Don’t you love the corporate talk? Just the absolute nonsense. Yeah. It’s crazy, right? Now, this this thing isn’t this thing isn’t going anywhere. I don’t even know why we’re talking about it. I think we talk about it because it’s so absurd. It’s so ridiculous that all this time has gone by, billions of dollars have been spent, and now we recognize that it’s going to cost way north of 200 billion dollars. And there there’s I mean, in any of our lifetimes, it’s not going to be built.
It’s just not going to be built. So, why bother, you know? If there was a consistent plan, hey, I think we can do this, this, and this and we’re going to get somewhere. We’re really going to see some progress. But all I see happening is just billions and billions of dollars being spent on an absolute shenanigan of a plan from the get-go. Just like, what were you thinking there? Oh, you were thinking this would be, you know, really cool, but you know, what’s the what’s the payback on 231 billion with with with really aggressive numbers for ridership on this bad boy? What do those numbers look like?
I mean, a million dollars a passenger? And how long is that going to take at 231 billion? I’m obviously wildly over exaggerating. And I’m joking because that’s not going to happen either. Cuz you can’t charge that much, you know? Just what what’s it? You going to charge 100 bucks? Worth it? I don’t know. Somebody seems to think it is and they just keep going down these these uh greatest ride ever, greatest train to nowhere ever. So, how many more of these podcasts we’re going to have on this one? Probably a bunch. Cuz we’ve already had a bunch and there’s going to be a bunch coming cuz they’re not done building it and they’re also not quitting on building it.
At what point in time will they quit? They’ve already lost federal funding. Right? And 4 billion? No, we’re not going to give that to you cuz you guys aren’t doing anything with it. You’re not actually building anything. You’re just mucking everything up. Trump Trump is just all over this one. And he’s rightfully so. It’s a terrible idea to think that a government can build a rail line that far. It’s got to be done privately. Oh, and they’re also trying to get behind the idea of public sector or no, private funding funding this thing. Well, if we could just get some private funding, we think that, you know, there there’s going to be investors out there that are going to be more than happy to secure some money to make this happen.
It’ll never work. No, this isn’t going anywhere. But when the next story comes up, make sure you’re subscribed, hit that notification bell. I’ll catch up with you on that one. Thanks again for being here. Bye for now. >> [music] [music]
Up next

California High-Speed Rail Could Run Out of Money by 2027
Watch next


Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.