Chicago Save A Lot Closures Follow $26M Taxpayer Deal
Seven subsidized grocery stores closed in a weekend. Chicago blames Washington. The receipts say something else.
Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.
The Chicago Save A Lot closures took out seven stores across the South and West Sides, and they did it less than two years after taxpayers put roughly $26 million behind an operator that promised to stay for ten. The official explanation is federal food assistance cuts. The explanation does not survive contact with the numbers.
Key Takeaways
- Seven Save A Lot stores went dark across Chicago’s South and West Sides over a single weekend.
- The operator, Ohio-based Yellow Banana, took city financing and agreed to keep the stores open for a decade.
- Save A Lot points to SNAP cuts and a 26 percent year-over-year decline in SNAP and EBT tender at these locations.
- New York City is preparing to spend upward of $70 million on five city-owned supermarkets.
What happened to the seven stores
The city backed the operator with $13.5 million in taxpayer financing as part of a roughly $26 million deal to buy and rebuild six stores on the South and West Sides. Yellow Banana, the Ohio company running them, agreed to keep those locations open for 10 years. They did not make it two.
There were ribbon cuttings. There were grand reopening ceremonies. The closures came about four years after the city announced the financing, and less than two years after the investment actually landed in the stores. City officials said their priority was for the stores to remain open, right up until they weren’t.
A food desert is a neighborhood with no nearby grocery store, and the honest question is never whether one exists. It is why every operator keeps leaving.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
Why did the Chicago Save A Lot closures happen so fast?
Because the stores were not viable to begin with, and a subsidy does not change unit economics. It just delays the day someone has to admit them.
Think about what $13.5 million was supposed to buy. Renovated buildings, working refrigeration, restocked shelves, and a decade of runway. If a store cannot clear its own costs with that much public money underneath it, the problem is not the storefront. The problem is everything happening inside and outside the store on an average Tuesday.
Food costs have climbed and these operators cannot raise prices enough to cover it in these neighborhoods. Layer on losses that never show up in a press release, and the corporate math becomes simple. Somebody in a regional office looks at the incident log and the shrink number and closes seven stores at once.
Does the SNAP explanation hold up?
Save A Lot and Mayor Brandon Johnson both blamed the closures on federal funding cuts and changes to programs like SNAP. The company said the stores experienced a 26 percent decline in SNAP and EBT tender types compared with last year.
Take that seriously for a second. A 26 percent drop in one payment type only sinks a store if that payment type is nearly the whole business. And if federal SNAP changes were the actual cause, the effect would be national, because SNAP rules are a federal overlay. Every store in the country takes the same card under the same restrictions. Seven closing in one city on one weekend is not a federal pattern. It is a local one.
The federal changes were aimed at fraud, at work requirements, and at what the benefit can buy. Millions of people have come off the rolls. That is a real story with real effects. It is not a story that explains why a store rebuilt with $13.5 million in public money folds inside 24 months while stores in other parts of the country stay open.
The two words nobody said out loud
Shoplifting and safety. Those are the two factors that run through nearly every one of these closures, and they are the two that never make the podium.
Hope is abstract. Action is key.
That was a South Side resident, not a politician, and it lands harder than anything said at the ribbon cuttings. Another longtime resident said the closures were no surprise at all, that it is the same old story, and not just in Chicago.
The pattern repeats everywhere the conditions repeat. A Whole Foods near San Francisco’s Tenderloin lasted roughly 18 months amid overdoses, drug use, and constant theft. In the Seattle area, a Fred Meyer on Lake City Way closed after being robbed relentlessly, and the response was to blame corporate abandonment rather than ask why the store bled out. A local independent journalist has filmed people stealing from a Bellevue grocery store and reselling the goods at an open-air drug market at 12th and Jackson in Seattle. It is a short walk from a stolen cart to a street corner, and that walk is what closes stores.
This is the same dynamic behind a Portland grocery closure after a stabbing and behind Target shuttering stores nationwide. Cities keep treating the symptom and calling the diagnosis unfair.
What this means for New York’s city-owned grocery stores
New York is about to run the Chicago experiment with more money and fewer excuses. Mayor Zohran Mamdani campaigned on one city-owned grocery store in each borough, using the power of government to lower prices and make it easier for New Yorkers to put food on the table.
The details that have emerged are not encouraging:
- Five stores expected to cost taxpayers upward of $70 million.
- No hot food counters and no butchers.
- No discount on soda, after officials studied what people actually buy.
- Nearly eight months into the term, only two of the five have finalized locations, and the first will not open until at least 2027.
The promise was that eggs will be cheaper, bread will be cheaper, and grocery shopping will no longer be an unsolvable equation. The mechanism for that is a discounted core basket of goods with everything else sold at market price. In other words, taxpayers eat the difference on a handful of items, which is exactly what Chicago did before the shelves went dark.
Can a subsidized store ever be a real store?
Only if someone is honest about what the subsidy is covering. If it is covering a temporary gap while a neighborhood stabilizes, that can work. If it is covering theft, security costs, and structurally unprofitable pricing forever, then it is not a grocery store. It is a permanent appropriation with a produce section.
The tell came when a supporter of the New York plan was asked what happens to the bodega next door. The answer: if one publicly owned grocery store that brings prices down is enough to put someone out of business, maybe they shouldn’t have been in that business in the first place.
That is a remarkable thing to say out loud. The private grocer is not losing on merit. He is losing to a competitor whose prices are underwritten by his own tax bill. Chicago has already shown where that road ends, and San Francisco has floated a new tax to solve a theft problem rather than the theft.
Nobody should be glad about this. Seven stores closing means older residents on the South Side now travel much farther for groceries, and communities do not recover from that quickly. The question worth asking is the practical one: what would it actually take to make these stores profitable, and why does nobody in charge want to answer it?
Frequently Asked Questions
How much public money went into the Chicago stores?
The city provided $13.5 million in taxpayer financing to Yellow Banana as part of a roughly $26 million deal to buy and renovate six stores on the South and West Sides.
Was the operator supposed to stay longer?
Yes. Yellow Banana agreed to keep the stores open for 10 years, and the locations closed less than two years after the investment.
What has Illinois done about grocery access?
Governor J.B. Pritzker cited the Illinois Grocery Initiative, which he described as a program that helps people start grocery stores, while these seven locations were closing.
If you live near one of these stores, where are you shopping now, and how much farther is it? Tell us in the comments, because the distance is the part that never makes the press conference.
Full Episode Transcript
Read the full transcript of this episode
We’ve got seven Save-A-Lot stores shut down across Chicago’s south and west sides. These were heavily propped up stores, meaning they had financing, with 26 million bucks in financing. They were supposed to stay in business for 10 years. They made it less than two. These stores are primarily on the south side of Chicago. What’s the deal, Leo? Let’s get into it. Here we go. You know what? Let’s watch a little Let’s watch a video. We got We got J.B. Pritzker in this video. Who doesn’t want that in their life? Take a quick peek. >> Should have access to grocery store, just like everybody should have access to a doctor.
Uh and having a grocery store nearby really changes your entire life, your family’s life. >> Frustration from Governor Pritzker after a number of Save-A-Lot grocery stores are slated to close for good tonight, unless a last-minute deal can be reached. Good evening, everyone. I’m Jackie Bange. Bryant McCray is live with the latest. Bryant? >> Yeah, good evening. Those closures taking place in in areas called food deserts, primarily in low-income areas or far away from fresh food or supermarkets. Tonight, people in the >> Food desert desert is just where all the grocery closed stores have closed down because they’ve been robbed blind and they can’t make it go of it.
That’s where this is. It’s in one of those areas. And you don’t hear anything about the two common factors where they shut these stores down, which are shoplifting and safety concerns, meaning you got a bunch of weird stuff going on, whether it’s in the parking lot, inside the store. You’ve got people doing wacky stuff, and stores don’t want to take the liability on of continuing to stay open. Plus, they’re already bleeding out so much money. But, listen to some of the excuses people are coming up with so they don’t have to address those issues. >> Communities say they’re not surprised by these closures.
A parking lot on Chicago’s South Side slowly clears out as a grocery store called Save A Lot prepares to say goodbye. The closure coming at no surprise for South Side resident John Cally Emudji. >> It’s the same old story, to be honest with you. And it’s not just here, it’s nationally when it comes down to black communities. >> The Save A Lot shuttering its doors after the city backed the operator with 13 and a half million dollars in taxpayer financing. It was a part of a roughly $26 million deal to buy and rebuild six stores on the South and West Side. The operator, an Ohio company called Yellow Banana, agreed to keep them open for 10 years.
The stores didn’t make it two. Save A Lot cuts in federal food assistance. >> I heard that the federal government had a little hand in this >> I I do not buy this. I have looked at the numbers. This does not make sense. The federal cuts to the SNAP benefits and have ended just recently. It wouldn’t have been enough to put these stores under. That is that that is that is something out there. Let’s blame orange man bad Trump. Let’s blame him. Oh, yeah, federal government. Ugh. Closed them down. I’m not buying it. >> particular one, Save A Lot is unfortunately the first casualty.
>> At a WNBA event Saturday, Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker touting the work he’s done to keep grocery stores open. >> I put an initiative in several years ago called the Illinois Grocery Initiative. And what it does is literally help people start grocery stores. However, >> people who live in these areas >> How’s that going, J.B.? How’s that start the grocery stores initiative going when you got seven shutting down in the South Side of Chicago? Is that doing what it’s supposed to do? Is it right on track there? Notice it was a WNBA event, right? W and NBA so woke. >> Saying they believe it’s only a matter of time before another grocery store goes dark.
>> Hope is is is is abstract. Action is key. >> Okay. That’s all I need to see of that one. So, we’ll skim through this and we’ll look at some other stuff that’s going on in grocery store land because you are seeing a lot of closures right now. So, it goes on to talk about what we just saw there. Closures come 4 years after the city of Chicago announced it would give 13 and 1/2 million in taxpayer financing to Yellow Banana. Yellow Banana being the basically management company or going to make this grocery store thing go as part of a roughly $26 million deal to buy and renovate six stores on the South and West Sides.
And how much is Mondani spending? 70 million on five, one for each of the boroughs? Yeah, we’re going to we’re going to talk about Mondani as well. Yellow Banana agreed to keep the stores open for 10 years. The locations closed less than 2 years after the investment. Something just isn’t the This isn’t adding up. You should be able to keep the stores open for longer than that. You got There There’s something going on here. I mean, there there’s something like Yeah. Yeah. So, here’s your addresses. If you want to check those on a map, they’re on the South Side. Save-A-Lot and Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson are blaming the closures on federal funding cuts and changes to programs like SNAP benefits.
Well, SNAP benefits, funding cuts, yep. They’re cutting down fraud. They’re cutting down who should receive it. Hey, you might have to work a little bit to get all this free stuff. Oh good lord, can’t have that. And then, also, uh they’re not allowing you to purchase, you know, like sugary sodas and snacks that are basically not nutritious at all. So, are you telling me that enough people are saying, “Nope, I got to get sugary sodas with my SNAP card, otherwise I’m not shopping?” It wouldn’t be just these stores, it’d be every store, right? Cuz that’s a federal overlay. Hey, you can’t buy that with that with your SNAP card.
All right, the federal government had a little hand on this particular one. I’m not I don’t I don’t see that as a thing. And what’s he say? Save a lot is unfortunately the first casualty. No. No. I No. And then, J.B. Pritzker goes on to talk about his nonsense while he’s watching a shirt that that wearing a shirt that says, “Everybody watches women’s sports.” No, they only watch Caitlin Clark, and they’ll watch Sophie Cunningham a little bit. You know, there’s a handful of others, but by and large, if you watch some of the highlights from the WNBA All-Star game, ooh, they’re tough to watch. It’s just tough to watch.
Um it it’s not great basketball. Caitlin Clark, Sophie Cunningham, yeah, they’re they’re good. They’re fun to watch. They’re they’re personalities though, too. They’ve got more off the court as well. Um however, people who live in these areas say they believe it’s only a matter of time before another grocery store goes dark. Hope is abstract, action is key. All right. Okay. Here we go. Unfortunately, these stores have continued to face significant challenges, including dramatic cuts to SNAP benefits, which have severely impacted these stores. Compared to last year, the stores have experienced a 26% decline in SNAP/EBT tender types.
All right, what percentage of their overall business is that though? I I mean, is it is it like 90%? Okay, that would have a very significant impact on a store like that, but I can’t believe that is, you know, that is the the the the major impact here. As a res- because that hasn’t I mean, these stores have barely been open, right? And all of a sudden, nope, got to close. Save-A-Lot made the difficult decision to enter arrangement with Yellow Banana. Yellow Banana’s exploring alternatives in order to keep the stores open. Okay, so we have that face possible closure this weekend. City officials say their priority is for the stores to remain open until they’re not, right?
Let’s get through here. Ribbon cuttings and grand reopening ceremonies took place after the city gave Yellow Banana 13 and a half million dollars. So, even with even with a massive subsidy, they can’t make these go. They they just Food costs have increased, yes, and they can’t increase the prices enough to basically make a profit. And then on top of that, you’ve got you’ve got shoplifting that is happening just in droves. And then you’ve got safety issues. You got nut jobs coming into the store. You got people on drugs. You got people high as a kite coming into the store, and when the chain looks at profitability and they just go, nope, nope, gone.
It’s a combination of all these factors. Cuz there’s no way it’s just snap. There’s just no way. That’s Yeah. They’d figure something out, right? They would figure something out. But bottom line is is they they basically can’t make a profit. They’re already not viable. They’ve been propped up financially. And they’re supposed to be there 10 years. I mean, wasn’t there a clause in the contract? Hey, if you guys jettison after, you know, short of 10, here’s the deal. I guess we’ll work that out in court. Why nearly 4.3 million are no longer receiving food stamps? Okay, a lot of that had to do with the SNAP beneficiaries are way, way down because they’ve cut the number of people who can access it.
They’ve made age changes, made changes in people needing to work to qualify for these benefits. And that to me doesn’t indicate enough folks enough folks are still going to be able to go in and shop, right? The percentages of people that this impacted the SNAP benefits impacted I don’t think is enough to shut good seven grocery stores down. I think they were they were not viable from the get-go. And you place on top of that a ton of shoplifting and some weird stuff going on and they just look at the overall thing and go, “Nope, got to close.” Three and a half million people have lost food stamp access as Trump’s big beautiful bill cuts take effect.
His cuts were to cut out fraud. His cuts were to cut out people who should otherwise be working from just getting a bunch of free food that they don’t really qualify for. So, if you look at if you take a hard look at what was actually in those cuts, it’s cutting the fluff. So, if these grocery stores only stay open because of fluff, well, then then you’ve got a real problem. So, how about this? Mom-and-Johnny officials admit New York City owned markets won’t have features like butchers, hot food, or even cheap food. As critics rail plan is destined for failure. So, this is this is essentially what Chicago stores have just closed down.
I mean, it’s it’s subsidized grocery store, right? Totally subsidized by the city. Or the county or whomever. It’s subsidized. And and they only made it 2 years. So, why would the grocery stores in New York City be any different? Why would they be any different? It’s a good question, right? You’re like, Well, because they are in boroughs and they’re not in the South Side of Chicago. Okay. All right. There’s some pretty interesting stuff in this. Five stores, which are expected to cost taxpayers upwards of $70 million uh dollars would not include hot food counters or butchers. It may not have all the items, but it’s going to be like a typical grocery store.
It’s going to be like a typical grocery store, but it won’t have a butcher. It won’t have all the cool stuff. Yeah, we’re not really going to have any cheap groceries. Um we’re not going to really have any brand names. Uh and we’re not going to have this. And we’re not going to Yeah, but it’s mainly going to be like a normal grocery store, right? A normal grocery store. We did a lot of analysis of what people buy in terms of their everyday goods. Even if there are a lot of people who buy soda, we’re not discounting soda. Okay. All right. Okay. Yeah, all right. You can’t buy that with EBT anymore, correct?
Or or states give the the feds have given the states the right to to not sell that, is that my understanding? I don’t know much about the whole, you know, snap. Head-scratching statements around what exactly the city-owned stores would offer led some social media users to punk poke fun at the seemingly convoluted project. These projects are always convoluted. And if they are not And if they are not if their goal isn’t to make a profit, they’re not going to be well-run, and they’re just going to absolutely bleed out money. And that to me is exactly what happened with our seven stores here in the in Chicago.
They’re bleeding out so much money that they’re just they’re not viable any which way. And management and ownership basically said, “We got to cut We got to close these bad boys down. This was good while it lasted, but it didn’t last very long. And wasn’t it about 18 months that the Whole Foods in San Francisco closed down? Whole Foods near the Tenderloin closed down. I think it was like 18 months. They’re like, “Uh no, got to go.” You had a dude OD’ing in the bathroom. You had prostitutes bringing their clients in and, you know, doing their thing in the bathroom. People doing drugs in the bathroom.
People just absolutely having meltdowns inside the store. Shoplifting like there’s just no tomorrow because the drug community needs a little bit of money for drugs. You don’t have to have a lot. And say you just go and steal from the grocery store cuz everybody needs food, then you go to your open-air drug market and you sell it there. We’ve got people from my QFC. I call it my QFC cuz it’s QFC that’s closest to me. It’s on Northeast 8th and 156th. It’s here in Bellevue. It’s just a few miles to the south of me. And um Jonathan Cho goes there and videotapes people um stealing from the store, and then they take it over to Seattle, 12th and Jackson, and sell it on the street corner.
Open-air drug market. Get a little bit of money for that next hit. So, “Oh my gosh, this is just destined to fail,” said one user on X. “Anyone with experience with the grocery store there, this is such a bad idea.” Talking about Mom Donny’s grocery store. Another X user likened the concept to another popular grocery store chain. This is a Trader Joe’s, basically, they wrote. Kind of, but probably without the cool bags. Probably without the insulated mini bags. Probably without the pastel mini totes. I’m a big Trader Joe’s fan cuz I think that I think it’s so ridiculous how there’s such a demand for all of their bags.
But I must I must have 30 of their bags. Do I use them? I use some of them. They’re just cool. I mean, the little ones you can put a your lunch in or six-pack of beer, who knows? The big ones you can fit basically most of a grocery load in them. They’re big and insulated, right? On the campaign trail, Mom Donny had vowed to open one city-owned grocery store in each borough, claiming he would use the power of government to lower prices and make it easier for New Yorkers to put food on the table. So, what they’re going to do is they’re like going to discount certain products. They’re going to make like the staples cheaper.
Cuz they can’t discount everything, cuz then they’d be not viable. Which is what the stores in Chicago are. Literally not viable. They got closed down. I’m recording this for you on a Monday. They got closed down on Saturday. I was kind of hoping to see You don’t want to see a store close down. You just don’t. Even if you know it’s because it’s being robbed blind. Because you’ve got older folks in there who, you know, need to get their food. Now they got to go to Timbuktu to get it. That’s not cool, and it does it rocks a community. Every time grocery stores close, it rocks a community. This was seven in a row.
Just boom, gone. They’re gone. Nobody wants to see that. But you got to ask yourself, okay, what would it take for these stores to be profitable? What are the things that could be done to make these stores profitable? Cuz stores are open in other parts of the country, aren’t they? How come they’re open and these ones aren’t? Stores that we had closed here in the Seattle area, besides shootings and stabbings and the World Cup, I mean, we got a lot going on here. We had a grocery store close in Lake City Way, which is kind of to the north of downtown Seattle. Same deal. They said, “Well, this is causing a food desert.” You robbed it blind.
You robbed a Fred Meyer absolutely blind and you had a bunch of nut jobs in there just whacked out on drugs and crazy stuff was happening and then you blame Kroger, who is the owner of Fred Meyer, corporate owner, you blame them when when when the thing shuts down. Like, “Oh, corporate abandonment.” No. No, they they closed it down because it was not a viable business. And management said, “Well, we got all these stores across the United States. That one there, good lord, how many incidents has that had? How much shoplifting has that bad boy have? And it’s in Seattle, so you’ve got the minimum wage issues going on.
Minimum wage can always go to zero, can’t it? Zero. Zero. Zero. That’s what the comrades never quite figure out. They’re like, “Oh, we need a greater working wage. We need a living working wage.” Well, capitalism says you’re worth what you’re worth and if you’re not, you don’t get paid more. You got to figure it out. You got to figure things out. “At our stores, eggs will be cheaper, bread will be cheaper, grocery shopping will no longer be an unsolvable equation,” Mom Donny claimed. Okay, so how are your eggs going to be cheaper? You’re subsidizing them. How will your bread be cheaper? How will grocery stores store shopping in general be cheaper?
Now, essentially it won’t. And the only way that this can be cheaper is to undercut mainstream grocery stores or bodegas in New York City and have the taxpayers fund the difference, which is what we’ve already done in Chicago. And how’s that working out? Yeah. Closed. Gone. Nearly [snorts] 8 months into his tenure, only two of his five promised supermarkets have spec- specific locations finalized, and the first one won’t open until at least 2027. I give that I give that 3 or 4 years to run. Then, ah, due to significant losses, and we lost our lease. Yeah, we got to close this store down.
Grocery store owners and workers have sounded the alarm on the pricey project, expressing concern discounted goods may hurt privately owned markets near the city-owned shops. What effort has been made to help other stores in general? All right. How is the impact on competition? All these businesses are trying to do right. Get this. Get this. Somebody asked if the government opened a big grocery store next to your bodega with subsidized groceries, meaning the the reason they’re cheaper is because the government subsidizes them. And here’s here’s what the um Democrat commie said. If one publicly owned grocery store that brings prices down in the neighborhood is enough to put someone out of business, maybe they shouldn’t have been in that business in the first place.
That’s how a commie thinks. That is a straight-up communist right there. So, you you you brought a government store in, you undercut the other guys who are doing their best to make a profit because they don’t make a profit, it’s not worth them keeping the store open. And you’re telling me that because they can’t make money because you’ve undercut them with the taxpayer dollars footing the bill, that they shouldn’t have been in that business in the first place. Literally taking the means of production, right? That’s where we’re headed. Communism. That’s where this is going. Communism. New York City, based on capitalism, ish, right?
How’s that going to work out? Not well. Not well. These grocery stores will be an absolute boondoggle. They will just They will just be terrible. They’ll be terrible. And Adams has said previously the shops will focus on selling a discounted core basket of goods. Core basket of goods. But will contain a myriad of other items sold at market price. So literally, what are they selling? Well, bunch of groceries. Get some cheap bread in there. You got few things, vegetables that are cheap. No cheap soda, already covered that. Um yeah, we got we got some English muffins, discounted. Yeah, heavily. Eggs?
Oh, yeah. Eggs, they’re they’re 30% off. Okay, I >> [clears throat] >> This This whole thing is just it’s it’s something Adams can point to and say, “Look. Look what we did.” “This is what we did.” And it won’t work cuz this never works. Socialism never works. Communism never works. Ask people how the grocery shopping is going in Cuba. Yeah, how’s that working out? Even just look on Look on uh the YouTube machine. See all the videos about grocery shopping in in in Cuba. I mean, the lengths that they have to go to to get certain products cuz it’s Yeah, there’s so many countries have embargoes against them.
They just don’t have them. They don’t have enough stuff. And that’s why people put together makeshift rafts and try and float to the United States risking their lives all the time. They’re We’re always coming up with somebody that being intercepted, right? Oh, they’re trying to float into the country and it wasn’t going well and they were going down and a fishing boat rescued them and brought them back. Why would if if socialism was working out so well if communism was working out so well, why would all these people be escaping Cuba? They wouldn’t. They wouldn’t. But hey, let’s give this a run because why not?
I mean, we’re literally talking about city subsidized grocery stores in in Chicago closing down while Mom Donny is praising them, you know, opening up, trying to get them to open up. It makes no sense. It makes no sense whatsoever. But then neither did did socialism or communism for that matter. So Yeah. Well, comrades, thanks so much for being here. Love to have you subscribe, hit that notification bell. I’ll see you in the next episode. Thanks again. Bye for now. >> [music] [music]
Up next

Staged Robbery Visa Fraud Nets Only 2 Years in Chicago
Watch next


Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.