City-Run Grocery Stores: Why Mamdani’s NYC Plan Will Fail
Mamdani plans city-run grocery stores across New York's five boroughs.
Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.
Prefer audio? Listen to the podcast version:
Mayor Zohran Mamdani has unveiled plans for New York City’s first city-run grocery stores, starting in East Harlem, with a goal of one in each of the five boroughs by the end of his term in 2029. It is a costly public gamble that has failed everywhere it has been tried, because a city government cannot beat straight-up capitalism at a razor-thin-margin business.
Key Takeaways
- Mamdani proposed $70 million in capital funding, which requires city council approval.
- The first store is slated for La Marqueta in East Harlem, opening by the end of 2027.
- Grocery stores run on 1% to 3% margins — barely enough to survive theft and spoilage.
- A Kansas City store closed in 2025 despite nearly $18 million in taxpayer investment.
What exactly is Mamdani proposing?
The plan is a publicly run supermarket built on city-owned land, starting at La Marqueta in East Harlem. A city-run grocery store is a supermarket owned by the municipality and operated on the public dime, meant to undercut private prices through subsidy rather than through competition.
The city would contract a private vendor to run the stores, require union wages as part of that contract, and mandate that any subsidy be passed directly to consumers as savings on a basket of essential goods. Mamdani says the East Harlem neighborhood saw nearly 40% of households receive public assistance or SNAP benefits in the past year.
Don’t New Yorkers already have grocery stores?
Yes — the city is covered in them. New York has bodegas on nearly every corner acting as mini grocery stores, and by one count there are already a thousand grocery stores in the city. This is not a food desert.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
Prices are high not because there is nowhere to shop, but because taxes, rent, and regulation in New York City are through the roof. Layering a subsidized government store on top of that undercuts the private businesses already serving those neighborhoods.
Why do city-run grocery stores fail?
They fail because groceries are one of the thinnest-margin businesses there is — roughly 1% to 3% — and government cannot run them efficiently. Add high spoilage, inventory complexity, energy-intensive refrigeration, union labor costs, and shrinkage from theft, and the math collapses.
The record is long: the former Soviet Union, Venezuela, Cuba, Hungary, and Poland all tried state-run grocery models and got long lines, persistent shortages, poor service, limited variety, corruption, and black markets. Domestic experiments in Baldwin, Florida, and towns across Kansas closed the same way.
Government can’t run an efficient grocery store. That’s bottom line. It’s too thin of a margin business.
What happened in Kansas City?
Kansas City is the cautionary tale. A troubled Sunfresh grocery store at 31st and Prospect closed in August 2025 despite nearly $18 million in city investment and a decade of taxpayer money to renovate and prop it up.
The store’s customer count fell from 14,000 when it was acquired to about 2,000, and the Kansas City Council pumped in another $750,000 in May — much of it for security — before it closed anyway. That is what happens when a store gets robbed blind, a problem also driving Chicago’s own taxpayer-owned grocery push.
Why is New York City going down this road?
Because it sells. This plays out as a PR move rooted in a belief that the city “must intervene where the market has failed,” but the savings Mamdani promises East Harlem residents are largely what they already receive through SNAP. Subsidizing an inefficient store just throws more tax dollars at the problem.
The politics are telling too — the contract requires union standards, and unions are among the mayor’s biggest backers. It echoes the same affordability promises that have gone nowhere in Seattle, and it has already triggered a bodega owner revolt from the small businesses this would compete against.
Can these city-run grocery stores actually compete?
No. Walmart, Costco, and Kroger survive on economies of scale that a handful of city stores cannot match. Five stores for a population in the millions — one per borough — is not a serious answer to affordability; it is virtue signaling.
The council members backing this will eventually have to face the bodega and grocery owners in their own districts and explain why the city is subsidizing a competitor. That is a hard sell, and it should be, especially with a private-sector fight already brewing, as one billionaire CEO threatening mass closures shows.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much will the city-run grocery stores cost?
Mamdani proposed $70 million in capital funding to build the stores, which requires approval from the city council.
When will the first store open?
The first store, at La Marqueta in East Harlem, is slated to open by the end of 2027, with all five planned by the end of Mamdani’s term in 2029.
Is New York City actually a food desert?
No. Most residents live within walking distance of a store that sells fresh food, with only a few outlying neighborhoods in Queens and Staten Island facing limited access.
If the same idea has failed from Kansas City to Cuba, why should New York taxpayers expect a different result this time? Sound off in the comments.
Full Episode Transcript
Read the full transcript of this episode
We are building a brand new store on city-owned land currently sitting empty in East Harlem. Stores where prices are fair, where workers are treated with dignity, and where New Yorkers can actually afford to shop. At our stores, eggs will be cheaper, bread will be cheaper, grocery shopping will no longer be an unsolvable equation. And now on to a major announcement from Mayor Zohran Mamdani unveiling plans for New York City’s first city-run grocery store in East Harlem with a goal of having them in all five boroughs by the end of his first term. The mayor made the announcement during a speech in Queens marking his first 100 days in office.
He then turned to a few new plans including one of his major camping promises, opening city-run grocery stores with lower prices. saying the first one will open next year at La Marqueta in El Barrio, which is in East Harlem, in a neighborhood where he says in the past year nearly 40% of households there received public assistance or SNAP benefits. Mamdani says his plan is to open all five stores by the end of his term in 2029. According to the New York Times, Mamdani proposed $70 million in capital funding to build the stores, which requires city council approval. >> We’re here at La Marqueta, which will soon be home to one of the five city-run grocery stores across New York City.
Today, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is announcing the first of five sites for his administration’s city-owned grocery stores. The food hall you see today is going to remain, but it’ll be expanded into a neighboring empty lot, which will be turned into a publicly run supermarket. How is this store going to run? So, the city will contract a private vendor that will run these grocery stores. As part of that contract, they will be required to pay union standards to their workers. That’s not a suggestion, it is a requirement. Also, another requirement as part of the contract will be to pass on any subsidy directly to consumers in the form of savings.
There will be a basket of goods, essential items that New Yorkers buy from their supermarkets, that these supermarkets will sell at reduced price. I haven’t covered a ton of the goings-on in New York City with Mayor Mamdani, just because most of us don’t a lot of hot air. It’s just a bunch of nonsense. Well, now it sounds like we’ve got actual plans for opening up first of five or six seven city-run grocery stores in New York City. Don’t they have bodegas on like every corner that essentially act as mini grocery stores? But anyway, you know, reality aside, let’s just go ahead and build a bunch of grocery stores, subsidize them with taxpayers’ money, have other businesses go out of business, and you know, you know, millions of dollars will be poured into this.
It won’t work. It’ll be a complete debacle because we’ve seen it elsewhere. Socialism works for those who don’t. Let’s get into it. Here we go. The whole concept of a food desert is usually it it’s not in urban areas. It’s not in urban centers because you’ve got multiple grocery stores or in New York City’s case, bodegas just about everywhere. But people are complaining because they’re too expensive. They’re too expensive because your taxes are through the roof. Everything is through the roof in New York City. And so if you bring in a city-run grocery store, you’re going to undercut essentially capitalism in New York City.
So, Mamdani’s talking about this, but he’s got to get past his city council, right? I mean, that’s that’s who’s really going to dictate, yeah, this makes sense. This plan will never make sense because you can’t you’re already dealing with a market that is getting millions and millions and millions and millions of dollars in SNAP benefits. They’re already getting free groceries. So then, we’re going to make cheaper grocery stores available that are not efficient. Grocery stores run on a super thin margin. It’s why they can’t make it when they have half their crap stolen like here in Seattle. They had a Kroger shut down in Lake City.
Everybody went, “Oh, we’ve got a grocery desert.” Well, yeah, that’s because all the stores keep closing down because you allow shoplifting and there’s, you know, zero repercussions. And you’ve got safety issues. So, New York City gone down this road. This is a this is all a PR stunt cuz this will not work. It it just won’t work. It will never work. Mayor Zohran Mamdani has made his choice for the side of New York City’s first-run grocery store, East Harlem should work out fine. Right? Speaking at a rally, Mamdani said La Marqueta in East Harlem is owned by the city. Well then, we should develop it into a grocery store.
And corporations control every part of the food supply chain. You know what? They don’t. Tho- Those bodegas are not corporate-run often times. They are local business residents and consumers of New York City. So, every part of the when corporations own every part of the food supply, prices go up, wages stay flat, workers of the world unite, and customers both lose. Yeah. Okay. Well, they are losing in New York City, but it’s because you’ve layered how many how much in taxes, regulations? You’ve just absolutely stifled development. You’ve got a massive out-migration problem. You’ve got Kathy Hochul, your governor, saying, “I would like for the wealthy people to come back from Florida if you can.
Pay some of those taxes. Pay your fair share.” This is why these big blue cities are absolutely tanking because these ideas don’t make any sense. They don’t make sense from an economic standpoint. Because any savings that you’re passing on to people in the East Harlem community, they’re already getting from SNAP benefits. They’re already getting subsidies. So, you got to have a grocery store that gets subsidies. That’s just tax dollars being thrown in there. And you know, what what’s the statement that Reagan said? The the most frightening nine words or something like um I’m here from the government and I’m here to help.
You know, something along those lines. Um government can’t run an efficient grocery store. That’s bottom line. It’s too It’s too thin of a margin business. And in East Harlem, I’m sorry. I’m sorry. That is just going to get run over with shoplifting. That’s what’s going to happen. But hey, don’t listen to me. What would I know? This is why we are advancing a public option one rooted in the belief that our city can and must intervene where the market has failed. I’ve watched I’ve watched a fair number of documentaries on state-run grocery stores in Cuba. And they do not have a lot of food options.
Uh they trade in the black market. You you can’t get what you need. You got this just absolutely archaic system where you’ve got this logbook. I mean, it’s it’s just a bunch of nonsense that doesn’t work. And that is what Mamdani is promising. But people in New York City are thinking this this our guy. This is our guy that’s going to do it. Just like people in Seattle are thinking that Katie Wilson, she’s our gal. She’s going to do it. She’s going to make this happen. But actually making things more affordable, no. Ci- city government, whatever, state government, county government cannot cannot compete with business, with normal business, with capitalism-based business.
Can’t compete. Just No. You heard him throw in there, “Oh, we got to have unions involved.” Of course you do. That’s who’s your biggest backers, right? Going to the mayor’s office, the grocery store in La Marqueta is going to be open by the end of 2027, one of five planned city-run grocery stores, one in each borough. Okay. Today’s announcement by the mayor of New York City is just another example of government working for the people. That is a absolute misnomer in and of itself. Government working for the people doesn’t happen. Right? Doesn’t happen. The more you have government involved, the less it works for the people.
The more the people have to contribute towards said government program continuing to move forward. We’re going to look at Kansas City in just a sec here. About La Marqueta, don’t really care. Yeah, praise for Mamdani’s selection. This means accessible, affordable, healthy food. Really? Do you already have that? It’s just that it costs a ton because groceries cost a ton. That’s kind of everywhere. And especially in New York City where everything is just outrageously expensive. Rent is how much? How much is rent? So, you’re going to put five grocery stores throughout New York City with a population of how many million people?
And this is This is your answer to affordability? See why I don’t podcast on this because it’s just it’s so bad. It so terrible. It’s so mentally draining to think that people think this is an actual option. That this is what could really turn the tide on affordability. Katie Wilson here in in Seattle, she talks about affordability, but doesn’t really have any solutions. Doesn’t really have any solutions. Her biggest concern right now is the World Cup games are coming coming. And she’s got she’s got to clean up our homelessness here in Seattle. She’s got to clean it up cuz it is not looking good.
So she’s going to put 500 tiny homes together at a cost of 35,000 a pop and that is somehow miraculously going to dissipate all of the whacked-out drug addicts who already have housing but choose to live in tents cuz they just want to do their all-night drug orgies. That’s what they do. So you can tell me, oh yeah, we’re going to build the tiny Okay, it doesn’t really matter because the people on the streets they’re not going anywhere. So you’re going to have to sweep them out the minute the World Cup comes and just pretend that they don’t exist and no problem here. And then immediately after World Cup, just like we saw after the All-Star game and Taylor Swift homelessness comes back.
So wild stuff. Jumaane Williams is pushing for New York City run grocery stores. Here’s what he envisions. Okay, we’ve heard about that. Oh, it’s going to be like 60 million bucks. Yeah, the initiative 60 million bucks. Um put at least one city grocery store in each borough. One. One per borough. What’s the population? Millions. It’s it’s it’s pure insanity. Pure insanity. How about this? How about we talk about something realistic which is you know, reality. Let’s talk about that. A troubled Kansas City grocery store has closed. This is August of 2025. Despite nearly 18 million in city investments.
Couldn’t make it go of it. Couldn’t make it go. You know what their answer was? Uh this is outside of our control. Things outside of the realm of what we could deal with happened. Now, the numbers didn’t pan so and the government Kansas City understood, oh my god, this is terrible. We are bleeding out money on this bad boy. Now, we gave it a good shot. We gave it a try. Socialism works for those who don’t. And that’s what happens. So Sunfresh at 31st and Prospect, one of the only grocery stores for miles. This is where it’s an actual food desert. New York City? No, that’s not a thing. And has been struggling to fill show shelves recently despite 10 years of taxpayer money to renovate it and keep it in business.
So this is what Jumaane Williams’s plan will look like in like 5 years. They’ll be like, okay, we have losses into the hundreds of millions of dollars. We need to shut this down. This was a terrible idea before it began, terrible idea while it was running, and now we need to stop the bleeding. Because you know, New York City is is on the front end of a real decline because revenue. Most of these big cities have systemic budget deficits now built in. They’re not going to be able to close that gap. And this is not one of those programs that will help close that gap. This will just spend more money.
Despite almost 18 million of dollars in taxpayers, Sunfresh grocery store Linwood Shopping Center closed. Gone. Here you go. Unfortunately, due to unforeseen circumstances beyond our control, we are no longer at this time able to serve the residents of this important community. Boom, done. It’s the only grocery store for mile. And that sucks. I I I I I feel for people who the elderly um handicapped, people who can’t get around, who it’s hard to get to the grocery store and these stores closed. But I think you have to recognize that you know, there’s there’s a certain reality that when you continually rob your grocery store absolutely blind um there’s a real possibility that it’ll close, right?
That it’ll just boom, done. You don’t go from having 14,000 customers when we acquired the store down to now about 2,000 because of mismanagement. Yeah, interesting, right? Yeah. Yeah, the store couldn’t survive even though the Kansas City Council bumped 750 grand into the operation in May. Much of that to bolster security. Why do they need so much security? Hmm. That’s a question, isn’t it? That’s a real question. There were security at the shopping center Tuesday as a smattering of shoppers came to the Sunfresh stores closed. Closed. Just boom, done, gone. Problem with city run grocery stores.
This article’s got some It’s got some just great bullet points. Um these stores international lessons in public grocery store failures. Several countries have experienced experimented with state run grocery models including the former Soviet Union. Oh man, I was in Soviet Union before the fall, probably 1985. It was grim. Getting food there was grim. The whole thing was just grim. And just like you’re doing what? Oh, terrible. Black market everywhere. Just everything was just folding. You know, it was just come crashing down. We got Venezuela. Huh, how did the inflation work out in Venezuela? Not good.
Cuba. Yeah, oh yeah, Cuba. That’s a that’s a great place to point to and say socialism. Hungary, uh-huh, and Poland. Here’s what you get. You get long lines, persistent shortages, poor customer service, limited variety, and outdated products, corruption, theft, black markets, chronic inefficiency, and a lack of responsiveness to consumer needs. You got the other other places. You got Baldwin, Florida. Opened a had a city run grocery store in 2019. Closed down 2024. Erie, Kansas, one we just talked about. St. Paul, Kansas. Just boom, done. Can’t can’t make it go of it. Yeah, you got brain dead let’s go Brandon Johnson in Chicago talking about it because the legit stores there have closed down because they’re getting robbed blind.
Robbed blind. So you got the razor We talked about this. The razor thin margins, 1 to 3%. I almost did that. 3%, right? 1 to 3% margin. Maybe five. Maybe five. You’ve got high spoilage risk and inventory complexity. Just you got stuff coming and going. You know, it’s it’s a tough tough business. Labor intensive staffing and wage costs. Well, with union workers, I’m sure that’s not going to be a problem. Energy intensive operations, refrigeration, HVAC. There’s a ton that goes into anything to do with food. Shrinkage from theft and spoilage, intense competition, and narrow consumer loyalty. So article says Walmart, Costco, Kroger succeed because of scale.
Economies of scale. Small grocery store run by the city? That’s not going to do it. You can’t do it. It’s it’s not going to work. It’ll never work. You’ve got a thousand grocery stores already in New York City. A thousand. It’s not a food desert. This is what Jumaane Williams is pointing at and saying, oh it’s going to be great. Greatest thing ever, right? Most residents live within walking distance of a store that sells fresh food already. You don’t need these. This is virtue signaling at its best. Only a few outlying neighborhoods in Queens and Staten Island face limited access. Cuz you got them all over.
You got them all over. Segment I was looking wasn’t here. Can’t find it. Disappeared into the ether. It was stolen from me. It’s not my fault. Right? No. I just can’t find it. Can’t put my my hand on it. But what the what the segment was indicating is Jumaane Williams is going to have to go back to his city council members and they’re they’re going to have to answer to all the basically grocery store and bodega owners within their own districts, right? And within their own boroughs or whatever they’re called. And they’re going to have to say, hey, you know what? We the city, we think this is a good idea to run a, you know, a subsidized grocery store that’s directly going to compete with your bodega and we think this is a good idea.
They’re going to have to sell that to their constituency, right? How’s that going to go? Yeah, not that well. The whole thing is abso from from the beginning, the whole thing is just it doesn’t make sense. It’s a whole bunch of talking points and people who voted Jumaane in can be sold on talking points. Look at Seattle. You got a socialist mayor who ran on a platform of affordability. And of the dozen things that she pointed to I want I want I want I want I want not one of them will actually obtain attain affordability. This will not result in affordable groceries for New Yorkers. Everybody knows it.
But hey, let’s rob rob rob Jumaane because he’s really doing something. I mean, he is doing something. He’s doing something. It’s called costing the taxpayers more money, inefficiencies in business, and state run grocery store cannot compete with with straight-up capitalism. Can’t do it. And who’s going to end up losing? Taxpayers. Things will get more expensive. More people will leave because you’ve just got these failed experiments going on that that aren’t aren’t they’re not seated in reality. We we’ve seen what happens with the state-run grocery stores with the city-run grocery stores. They do not work.
Simple as that. I mean, it’s not that hard to figure it out. But, hey, let’s go ahead and try this again because, you know what? It might work this time. We’ll see. We’ll see. Oh, when when these stores fail and close down, I’m going to just podcast the heck out of that. All right. Thanks so much for joining. Love to have you subscribe. Hit that notification bell. I’ll see you in the next one. Bye for now.
Up next

Mamdani Grocery Stores Lawsuit: Immigrant Grocers Sue NYC
Watch next

Washington State
NYC Bond Downgrade Fears Rise as Mamdani Spending Grows

Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.