Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

Seattle

Columbia Tower Club Closing: What Seattle’s Loss Signals

Seattle's most storied business club closed after 41 years — a quiet but telling sign of a hollowing-out downtown.

Share:

Columbia Tower Club Closing: What Seattle's Loss Signals

Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.

Prefer audio? Listen to the podcast version:

The Columbia Tower Club closing after 41 years barely made the news, but it’s one of the clearer signals that Seattle’s business core is in trouble. If deals were booming, the city’s most prestigious club — perched near the top of its tallest building — would be expanding, not consolidating out of downtown.

Key Takeaways

  • The Columbia Tower Club permanently closed on April 30th, a year after its 40th anniversary.
  • Downtown Seattle office vacancy is trending upward — a 2025 CBRE report put it above 34%.
  • Membership fell from a peak of 2,200–2,500 down to about 1,795, and the club declined to share current totals.
  • Members are being routed to The Collective at 400 Dexter Avenue North in South Lake Union.

Why did the Columbia Tower Club close?

The short answer: not enough demand and rent that stopped penciling out in one of the priciest addresses in the city. The club sat near the top of the Columbia Tower, a roughly 76-floor building that has commanded premium rents for decades. When the businesses that filled downtown thin out, an expensive top-of-the-tower club is one of the first things to go.

A business club is a private membership spot where a city’s professionals meet, hold lunches, and do deals. When one that survived 41 years quietly folds, it’s a read on the health of the market around it.

What does the closure say about downtown Seattle?

It says the go-go business years are over. Downtown office vacancy has climbed from a little over 22% in a 2022 CBRE report to just above 34% in 2025 — among the highest in the Western U.S. and near the top nationally. One estimate cited in the coverage puts downtown vacancy somewhere in the 35–37% range.

Free weekly email

The Friday Reasonable Brief

A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.

Subscription Form

We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.

That’s not an abstraction. Fewer occupied offices means fewer members, fewer lunches, fewer reasons to keep a marquee club open. This tracks the same trajectory as Seattle’s rising vacancy rate and the broader West Coast market decline.

Seattle is the worst office market in the country. Their solution is a bookstore.

Where are the club members going?

To South Lake Union. Members are being directed to The Collective at 400 Dexter Avenue North, part of the same Invited/City Club portfolio. Of that portfolio’s 150-plus properties across the U.S. and Mexico, three are in Washington: the Columbia Tower Club, The Collective, and Canterwood Golf and Country Club in Gig Harbor.

The consolidation isn’t random. South Lake Union sits in the Amazon footprint, where armed private security has kept the streets noticeably cleaner than the rougher stretches of downtown. It doesn’t have the views, but it’s the safer bet — which itself says something about downtown.

Why safety is part of the business story

Because street conditions drive where businesses want to be. The coverage points to a 77-year-old man beaten on 3rd Avenue, with the suspect identified thanks to city cameras — the same cameras the mayor reportedly wants dark during the FIFA World Cup out of concern the footage could be used by ICE. Cleaner, guarded areas like South Lake Union thrive; the rougher downtown core doesn’t.

Is this just about one club?

No. It’s a proxy for the upper end of Seattle’s business market getting quashed. Starbucks has begun shifting jobs to Tennessee, Microsoft closed some Seattle offices, and Amazon shut down expansion in Washington. The mayor’s dismissive “bye” to departing millionaires only underlines the direction of travel.

Layer on the pressures — a payroll tax, a high minimum wage in food service, and a looming state income tax via the millionaire tax — and the incentives to stay keep shrinking. It’s the same squeeze behind Seattle’s payroll tax disaster and the region’s business exodus.

The bigger signal for Seattle

If there were a real business upswing on the horizon, a club in arguably the best location in Seattle wouldn’t be closing. It would be the hottest ticket in town. Instead, the market forced it out, and the members shifted to a cheaper, safer address on the edge of the Amazon zone.

That’s the tell. Quietly closing the best seat in the house isn’t a footnote — it’s a status report on where Seattle’s business economy actually is.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did the Columbia Tower Club close?

It permanently closed on April 30th, roughly a year after celebrating its 40th anniversary, having opened in 1985.

How high is Seattle’s office vacancy rate?

A 2025 CBRE report put downtown office vacancy just above 34%, up from a little over 22% in 2022, with some estimates in the 35–37% range — among the highest in the country.

What happens to Columbia Tower Club members?

They’re being directed to The Collective at 400 Dexter Avenue North in South Lake Union, a newer building in a cleaner, more secure part of the city.

Do you read a 41-year-old club quietly closing as an economic warning sign, or just a lease that finally stopped making sense? Tell me where you land in the comments.

Full Episode Transcript

Read the full transcript of this episode

Seattle is the worst office market in the country. Their solution is a bookstore. This is all that’s left of the Columbia Tower Club. We’re here on the 75th floor of the Columbia Tower, the tallest building in Seattle. Recent reports show office vacancy rates in downtown Seattle are trending upward. A 2025 CBRE report put it at just higher than 34% as compared to a 2022 report from CBRE showing vacancy at a little more than 22%. A report from Commercial Cafe shows Seattle has the highest vacancy rate in the Western US market and nearly the country. It’s going to be tragic for for our economy and for our businesses, especially.

But the state income tax will give our business nowhere to escape, unfortunately. And so, they’re going to start most likely moving out of state. We’ve already seen Starbucks start moving to Tennessee. Microsoft has closed some of their Seattle offices. Amazon has shut down expansion in Washington. Um so, it’s yeah, it’s it’s very concerning for for my business perspective. Or seemed dismissive of wealthy people leaving the area during an onstage appearance at Seattle U last month. If, you know, the ones that leave, like, bye. Um so, I >> [laughter] >> Sometimes comments that somebody like the mayor makes can have real repercussions in terms of actual, you know, economics for the city, jobs, and the business climate.

One of Seattle’s oldest and most distinguished business clubs in the 76th floor of the Columbia Tower. It looks down on all of Seattle. Like it it is it is the tippy top for business deals being made. For people doing business lunch, that kind of thing. Having meetings, having conventions, that goes those functions within the business business community. It just shut down. Now, the the the the story is, “Well, we’re just shifting to another portion of Seattle. It’s in downtown, which is not great. And it’s being They’re They’re shifting those club members to another club in the South Lake Union Market, which has basically been run by private security via Amazon.

It’s clean. It’s nice. Not like the rest of downtown Seattle. So, why is this so significant? Well, if business was going well in the city of Seattle or the state of Washington, clubs like this wouldn’t be closing down. They would be expanding. Let’s get into it. Here we go. The Columbia Tower Club is located in the Columbia Tower, one of Seattle’s tallest buildings in downtown. It’s It’s been there for 40 years. They just celebrated their 40th year anniversary. A year later, closed. Like so many other businesses in downtown Seattle. You know what? It just doesn’t make any sense to be in Washington state.

And again, if things were going well and if we were still in those boom years, you wouldn’t have entities like this closing. But this Columbia Tower Club club closed. Nobody said hardly anything. They were just like, “Oh, another club.” But I think there’s some interesting interesting details here. Members will be eligible to transfer to the Collective Social Club in South Lake Union. So, let’s take a look. Here is where the Columbia Club is located right now, downtown. Rough. I mean, it’s it’s the rough area of downtown. It’s been cleaned up. You don’t have as many homeless there, but you got a bunch of nut jobs still running around.

You got just weirdos. They keep it fairly clean from people living down there, but there’s still a lot of drugs and machete chasing around and just wacky nut job stuff. This is all Amazon. And, there’s private security through here like there is down over here. But, this is much cleaner. I walk routinely from parking garage over in here, Amazon building over in here, to the Space Needle, which is where Climate Pledge Arena is. And, I walk to a lot of shows, meet my buddy at at his office in in South Lake Union at Amazon, and we’d walk to a show at a show at night, you know what I mean? And, it was fine.

It we never had issues. Because, you’re going through an area that is heavily heavily guarded by private guards that are armed. Amazon has kept it clean. Because, they understand you got to keep the streets clean if you want to have people come into your to your to your businesses, come into your offices. And, that’s part of the problem downtown. They’ve still got They’ve got private security there all over the place because it’s an absolute, you know what, show. Who wants to be there? So, year after celebrating its 40th anniversary, permanently closed its doors on April 30th. And, you didn’t hear much about this because it’s it’s a business club, right?

It’s a club. Uh you pay a few hundred bucks initiation fee, pay a couple hundred bucks a month in dues, you can go up there and, you know, get some overpriced food, have a meeting, do whatever. It offered a private social and business spot since its opening in 1985. Back in the day, there was a law firm called Sylvester uh Diamond Sylvester Petrie Rude and Cruzen. They were located in the Columbia Center. I may have been dating one of those lawyers’ daughters. Who knows? During that time period, where the young lady I was dating said, “You know, my dad’s company has moved to the Columbia Center.

It’s a massive building. 76 floors. I mean, it’s it’s enormous. So, they were paying really big rent. And the conversation was the law firm isn’t able to hand out any raises because we’re taking on this massive chunk of increase in rent to be in the Columbia Center to bring in that really high-end uh type clientele. And they were they were a premier law firm. They, you know, handled a lot of construction cases. And uh you know, ran a lot of what happened in downtown Seattle. Most of those uh principals, I believe, are now all deceased. So, you know, the law firm way back in the day and um you know, that’s that’s kind of what I remember is the Columbia Center so expensive that businesses who, you know, hung their shingle there had to make cuts in order to kind of get that business in the door before it paid off.

But at the top of that top of that building, this building, is this club. And I have been to the the Columbia Center Club. And it’s epic. It’s I mean, it’s got just absolutely knockout amazing views. When you are looking down on the Smith Tower, which at one time was, I think, the tallest building west of the Mississippi, when you’re looking down on that Smith Tower significantly, you’re like, “Wow.” And the views back to Bellevue to the east are just They were famous for having views out of the restrooms that were like the the women’s restroom was supposed to I never went in there cuz, you know, I’m a dude, and dudes don’t go in the women’s restroom.

Ever. And so, my understanding, some of the views from the women’s restroom were just holy let’s just stay in the restroom kind of deal, right? But I think what’s happened here is you’ve had um you’ve had enough businesses leave and we don’t have the go-go days of business in downtown Seattle more anymore. And this is just one of those kind of side stories that has happened that to me indicates hey, things are not going all that great cuz if they were they would have kept this location cuz this location is arguably the best location in Seattle to have that kind of energy. But the rent must have been absolutely astronomical and it it it stopped making sense after 41 years.

It stopped making sense. Here’s something. Seattle Times article from 2002. So 24 years ago, long time ago. Reported its membership range from 2200 to 2500 for a decade. So consistently they had 2200 to 2500 people that were members that support the you know, the activities and the the overall financial of this club. Later dropping to about 1795. All right, so we’ve got a pretty significant decline. The club declined to share its current membership total. Well, if it wasn’t a massive drop-off, they wouldn’t have declined. They would have said, “Oh yeah, our numbers are up, but hey, here’s the deal.

Here’s the deal. It’s it’s too expensive for us to run in the Columbia Tower because the rent there is just absolutely you know, top of the line, out of this world because it’s a one-of-a-kind location. But that’s not what they said. Yeah, we’re not Those numbers have dropped dramatically, guaranteed. Cuz how many businesses have left downtown Seattle? And nobody wants to go to this part of downtown Seattle and and go to the club. That those days are gone. That is just simply not happening. Now, there’s a certain element that does still operate in that area of downtown Seattle, but there’s also so many people that are like, “I don’t want to go there.” And I I personally don’t enjoy going to downtown Seattle other than to just see what kind of, you know, what show happens there.

Like, when you walk around downtown Seattle, it’s like like walking around downtown Portland. You don’t know what you’re going to get. And that it’s kind of exciting. For somebody like me, it’s like, “Oh, what’s going to happen? Who’s around that corner? Am I going to stumble into yet another podcast topic?” And sometimes you do. Sometimes you’re like, “Wow.” Cuz um what was I I was I was taking the ferry back from Bainbridge Island a few years ago, and what was the guy guy homeless dude absolutely cracked out of his mind like first or second avenue in downtown Seattle, kind of where we’re talking about here, just up from the ferries.

He was running around with a golf club chasing people, something like that, you know, just just shenanigans. Homeless shenanigans that city Seattle has decided, “Ah, we’ll just we’ll just let it go and see what happens.” And later years, the club became part of what’s known as the City Club, a national portfolio of private city clubs operated under the broader Invited umbrella. They’ve got these clubs bunch of different cities, different locations, and they’re all in you know, pretty epic settings. Now, Seattle’s has been kind of downgraded to South Lake Union area. Because it’s it’s not in a super tall building, but you know what it is?

It’s far safer location than downtown Seattle. And the whole the whole business development concept of downtown Seattle has really taken a hit. It’s been brutal. Brutal. Cuz you got high taxes, you got safety issues on your streets, you got a socialist for a mayor. I mean, let’s not I mean, recent activities by socialist for a mayor. You had a 77-year-old man get absolutely pummeled on 3rd Avenue in downtown Seattle. And the reason they were able to capture who did it was of cameras. City cameras that are installed. And the mayor doesn’t want to have these cameras going during the FIFA World Cup because she’s afraid that that footage is going to be used by ICE.

It’s absolutely backwards logic. Backwards logic. So, you’ve got that incident. You know, last week Jenny Wilson, mayor of Seattle, was was mentioning she didn’t think that many millionaires were were going to leave. She thought that the millionaire story is wildly overblown. And so, she basically said, >> [laughter] >> “And so, all the millionaires that leave Seattle, bye.” And and giggled. And the people in the in the room listening to her all laughed and clapped and yeah, F those millionaires. Not realizing that when the millionaires all leave, the ones left sitting in the room clapping for Jenny Wilson are going to be holding the entire tax burden for the city.

Cuz who else is going to be left? People with money are planning on leaving right now. And the Columbia Club is just one of those indications that the upper end of the Seattle business market is really getting quashed. You don’t have a demand for for a club like this anymore. Just it’s not there. And so, here’s what here here’s what the senior vice president of the city club division of Invited Clubs said, “After extensive review, we’ve decided to consolidate the City Club operations, Seattle City Club operations, into a single location that’s arguably better, and move but doesn’t have the views, doesn’t have any of that other stuff, but eh probably a little bit safer, and move forward with The Collective as our primary club in the market.” Meaning the South Lake Union market, said Vincent Morriello, senior vice president of the city division of club, whatever.

“Club members are being directed to the Collective, 400 Dexter Avenue North, that’s South Lake Union. Out of the portfolio’s more than 150 properties in the United States and Mexico, three are in Washington. We got the Columbia Tower Club, The Collective, and Canterwood Golf and Country Club in Gig Harbor, which is that’s that’s a that’s a great golf and country club. So, they’re epic epic like stand-alone clubs in, you know, various locations. And the fact that the one in the Columbia Tower just kind of quietly closed down, to me was super interesting. It’s it’s an indication that Seattle is not able to support the kinds of business development that it has in the past.

I think those days are over. And moving forward, when you’ve got a socialist mayor who literally says, “Bye.” to millionaires, to people who pay all the taxes, not all, but a good portion, to people who bring jobs into the community, and Katie Wilson also, she’s out there protesting against buying coffee from Starbucks, which was founded in Seattle. I mean, just all of these narratives go the wrong way. She’s out there saying, “I I’m not buying Starbucks coffee and you shouldn’t either because they they couldn’t get together a collective bargaining agreement with Starbucks. It And then on top of that, you’ve got things like the payroll tax in the city of Seattle.

You’ve got a minimum wage for Starbucks workers and all kinds of other workers in that industry that is outrageous and these businesses can no longer support it. So, you’ve got businesses closing down left, right, and center and what’s more important is you don’t have businesses coming to Seattle to basically enjoy what Washington State and Seattle has provided for decades and decades because now we’ve gone the other way. We’ve gone towards socialism, which is you know, kick all the rich people out cuz they don’t want to stay. And then you got a bunch of poor people and they all look around at each other and go, “Who the F’s going to pay the taxes now?

Who’s going to pay all the taxes for our generous social programs, right?” We heard Kathy Hochul, governor of New York, say we you know, we need to go back down to Florida and grab all those those millionaires and billionaires and have them come back up here to pay their fair share of our generous social welfare programs. Now, how about just cutting the generous social welfare programs? And then on top of all this, Washington State has got the millionaire tax. So, it’s clear that one of the advantages and benefits of of starting a business in Washington State, you don’t have a state income tax.

Well, that’s going to be going bye-bye. Just like the Columbia Club, right? So, all you put all these things together and things are not going the right direction at all. The Columbia Tower was the first of the trio as a recent addition for four decades Columbia Tower Club has been a place where Seattle leaders connected, collaborated, and built community. And that’s what it was. And the fact that it just kind of just kind of Yeah, we’re we’re we’re going to consolidate. We’re going to consolidate and we’re going to put our efforts into this other location over here, which is in a newer building.

It’s near where Amazon is. And Amazon, how many thousands of jobs has Amazon sent to Bellevue? It’s another storyline we didn’t even really talk about. But if you’re going to have to consolidate, you might as well go with that location versus something in downtown. So, close downtown, consolidate in South Lake Union, kind of keep the party going. But not too many people, you know, have hit upon this story because it kind of on the on the outside of it it’s like, “Ah, you know, it had a good run.” To me, it’s a matter of you don’t have as many I mean, the sheer number of vacancies, another storyline.

Number of vacancies in Seattle is in commercial is top of the country. We’re we’re number one. Somewhere 35, 36, 37% vacancy factor in downtown Seattle. So, number of businesses alone probably forced the Columbia Club to close. And then the rent and everything else, things things just went the wrong direction for a club like this. It’s no longer viable. Shift all those members to a nearby club where rent is cheaper, arguably it’s safer. You know, you’ve got the Amazon influence right there. Let’s go with that. Don’t have the whacked-out nut jobs chasing each other around with golf clubs or machetes or whatever.

And let’s call it good. We’ll cut our losses at the Columbia Tower Club and we’ll move on. And that’s what they’ve done. Kind of under the radar. Just, oh yeah. Club closed. But to me, it’s more of a significant indicator of where things have gotten to and where things are headed. Because if there was a big uptick in business development on the horizon in Seattle, you wouldn’t have a club like this closing. Cuz it would make sense. It would be, oh, this is the greatest thing ever. Which this club was for decades. Until it’s not in 2026. Wild stuff. And by wild, I mean, not exactly good for Seattle.

Make sure you’re subscribed. Hit that notification bell. I’ll see you in the next episode. Thanks for being here. Bye for now. >> [music] [music]

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

Seattle Office Tower Collapse: Sold for 16 Cents on the Dollar

Seattle Office Tower Collapse: Sold for 16 Cents on the Dollar

Watch next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.