Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

California

California Insurance Crisis EXPOSED: Why Low-Risk Homes Are Forced onto the Failing Fair Plan

Share:

california insurance crisis exposed why low risk homes are forced onto the failing fair plan

Why are low-risk homes losing insurance and being forced onto the Fair Plan? That’s both a question and a statement. I get stories from you all the time, saying, ‘Hey, my house is miles and miles away from a high-risk area, and we just got our insurance shut down. We can’t renew. We have to find somebody else or go into the state plan.’ And it’s not just California.

The Truth Behind California’s Insurance Exodus

California’s insurance of last resort is supposed to be for homes with high wildfire risk, but a CBS News California data analysis finds the vast majority of homes on the Fair Plan are in zip codes that insurance companies classify as low risk. Anyone can be forced onto the Fair Plan, and the numbers are increasing.

Take Ken and Lisa, for example. When Lisa called to transfer their insurance to their new house (just three minutes from their old one), the company told her, “I’m sorry, you’re denied.” Her reaction? “I was in shock. I thought, ‘Are you kidding me?’ He’s been on their insurance for 30 years, and we’ve never had problems. We’ve never had any claims.”

The most revealing part? Their neighborhood has no trees, no wildfire brush, no nothing—just housing after housing. This is not the foothills of the mountains. This is suburban, low-risk territory.

Free weekly email

The Friday Reasonable Brief

A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.

Subscription Form

We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.

Why Insurance Coverage Matters (Even If You Don’t Think It Does)

Most homeowners have mortgages, so they have to have insurance. That’s a super important point. You might think, ‘Well, I just won’t get insurance.’ Do you want to have a million-dollar asset with no insurance on it? Probably not.

Plus, it’s not negotiable. If you have a mortgage, you must provide a policy to your lender. You have to insure their asset because it’s their asset until you pay it off. You just own it with massive leverage. With a 20% down payment, they own 80%, and you own 20%. So, it’s not a negotiable deal. You have to have it, period.

The Fair Plan Reality: Expensive Coverage That Barely Covers Anything

The only options left for many California homeowners are:

  • A risky, unregulated out-of-state insurer
  • The California Fair Plan (the state’s insurance of last resort)

The Fair Plan was intended for homes with high wildfire risk, but CBS News California’s data analysis found something shocking: most of the homes on the Fair Plan are in the lowest-risk zip codes, according to the insurers’ own fire risk classification.

Let’s break down the numbers:

  • 160,000 homes in “negligible” risk areas on the Fair Plan
  • About a third in moderate risk areas
  • Only a small fraction in truly high-risk areas

These numbers tell you everything you need to know. We’re not talking risk here; we’re talking about the ability to make money in California’s insurance environment. And the insurance companies are saying, ‘Yeah, we don’t care. It’s not worth it now. We’re out.’

The Absurdity: Same Risk, Different Treatment

The unfairness reaches absurd levels. Take Helen’s situation: her Palisades duplex survived a fire, but weeks before, she was forced onto the Fair Plan. Meanwhile, State Farm renewed her neighbor’s fire policy but not Helen’s. They literally share a wall!

That is the poster child for these insurance companies just deciding, ‘No, I guess we’ll keep you going. You have those other policies with us that were making a lot, so we’ll keep you. But you, you just have the one homeowner’s insurance policy, and your car insurance is with somebody else, so screw you.’

The Real Reason Behind the Crisis: It’s Not About Risk

Rex Frasier, who represents the insurance industry, states the truth plainly: ‘They should be asking why in the world the Fair Plan has half a million policies in it. Because insurers are non-renewing policies. Why are they non-renewing policies? Because we have a system in California that has not allowed companies to earn enough money to do business everywhere.’

Insurers argue that California’s policies have restricted their ability to raise rates, making the process so onerous that for decades, companies have avoided going through the state’s process with the insurance commission to get rate increases approved.

And what’s happening to consumers as a result?

  • Policies are being canceled
  • Coverage is becoming more expensive
  • Homeowners are getting less coverage
  • Even low-risk homes can’t find insurance

The Affordability Paradox

Here’s the kicker: Californians spend on average less for homeowners insurance than people in 19 other states, even though our home values and rebuilding costs are much higher.

Number 20 on the list! What does that tell you? And California has some of the highest overall risk in the country. So, you’re not paying much compared to other states, but good luck getting that policy renewed. Good luck getting that new policy. Because you’re paying so little, the insurance companies are saying, ‘Go screw yourself. We’re not playing ball. It’s just business, right? Capitalism. If you can’t make a profit, you’re out.’

The Profitability Problem

Home insurers are still profitable in California. But a CBS News California data analysis reveals profitability has declined, and insurers rely on profits to replenish their reserves, which are also dwindling. They need reserves to cover claims after big events like wildfires.

An expert puts it bluntly: “If we were paying more right now for insurance, we wouldn’t be in this situation. I’ve been saying that for years. How can we simultaneously say we’re in a changing climate, we have really expensive homes built next to a lot of burnable things, and then act like, ‘Oh, there’s going to be no impact on rates’? That’s ridiculous.”

The Policy Failure Cycle

That’s California leadership for you: ignore reality and just keep going down the same pathway. ‘It’ll work out just fine.’ And then be shocked when you look back and go, ‘God, there are no insurance companies left. What happened?’

This doesn’t happen overnight. This has been going on for decades. All the policies that California is putting in place are layered on top of each other. And you’ve got so many mind-numbingly counterproductive policies that now you have an environment where it’s becoming difficult to get insurance.

It has to do with basic economics: insurance is all about calculating risk and pricing accordingly. If insurers can’t charge enough to cover their risk—California ranks 20th in insurance costs despite having some of the highest risks—why would they do business in your state? They wouldn’t. And that’s exactly what’s happening.

The “Solution” That Isn’t

New regulation will soon let insurers charge more in California. In exchange, insurers are supposed to write more policies for people on the Fair Plan. But here’s the catch: the regulation specifies only people on the Fair Plan whom the insurers classify as moderate to high wildfire risk.

Remember, according to the insurers’ own data, most people on the Fair Plan live in low-risk zip codes. So, the regulations may not help everyone stuck on the Fair Plan.

Consumer Watchdog Jamie Court puts it plainly: ‘When you crunch the numbers, it shows there is no incentive to get people off the Fair Plan.’

Who’s Really Protected?

The new regulations do incentivize insurers to write new policies across California, particularly in areas that the Department of Insurance has categorized as “distressed.” Looking at the map, that includes most of Northern California.

But notably, places like Palisades, Altadena, and most of Southern California are not considered distressed. As one observer noted, ‘It undermines the entire purpose of allowing them to raise rates based on these intangible factors.’

And there’s no telling who might be forced onto the Fair Plan next. ‘Everybody’s at risk. You don’t get comfortable with your insurance company right now because they can drop you like that.’

The False Hope of Cooperation

Some still hold out hope: ‘We need to figure out how all these leaders and insurance companies are going to come together and say, “Okay, this is what’s best.”‘

That is a pipe dream at best. We’ve seen example after example of California leadership picking the wrong route, even when the decision should be simple. There’s an absolute abandonment of reality: ‘We’re going to keep rates low. We’re going to force these companies to keep their rates low, and we’re going to force them to give us insurance.’ And then the companies respond: ‘No.’

So the state insurance steps in with the Fair Plan. And now the Fair Plan is essentially insolvent. You have to go to other insurance companies and say, ‘We need half a billion dollars.’ It’s a financial shell game that ultimately hurts consumers.

The Inevitable Outcome

This disaster has been predicted for decades. And now we’re here at the end result, with people saying, ‘Oh, we need to get the insurance folks together with our leaders and figure this thing out.’

That’s not going to happen. The insurance companies are going to say, ‘We need XYZ amount of money.’ And the state’s going to reply, ‘Oh, good lord, they’re going to triple their rates!’

Well, that’s what homeowners should have been paying all along, and that’s why companies left the market. There’s no easy answer. The bottom line? Everybody’s insurance rates are going up.

The Broader Pattern: California’s Energy Crisis

The insurance crisis isn’t happening in isolation. California is facing a similar situation with gasoline prices. Experts warn that gas could reach $8.43 a gallon as refineries close.

California has imposed such strict regulations on what kind of gas you can use in the state that refineries like Valero are considering closing facilities. Critics have warned for years that these policies would lead to much higher gasoline prices in California than in other states.

Now leadership is talking about “price gouging” when in reality, it’s simply market forces responding to California’s unique regulatory environment. There’s no conspiracy to “screw California”—companies are just pulling out because they can’t operate profitably under current conditions.

If you constrict the supply of gasoline while requiring a special California-only blend, is gas going to go down in price? Basic economics says no. With fewer refineries able to produce California’s special blend, gas prices will inevitably rise.

What This Means For California Homeowners

For homeowners caught in this crisis, the situation is dire. The Fair Plan covers very little as far as coverage on your property, and it’s extremely expensive. But it might be your only option if you can’t get a policy from a standard insurer like Allstate, State Farm, or Farmers Insurance.

Meanwhile, gas prices will continue to rise, and leadership will blame “Big Oil” instead of their own policies. The question to ask: What’s the price of gas in Florida? In Oklahoma? In Texas? Compare those prices to California’s, and the picture becomes crystal clear.

Have you been affected by insurance non-renewals or the Fair Plan? Share your experience in the comments—your story might help others navigating this complicated crisis.

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

California Voter Fraud Charges Hit 28 Foreign Nationals

California Voter Fraud Charges Hit 28 Foreign Nationals

Watch next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.