New York ICE Detainer Rejections Top 16,000, DHS Says
New DHS figures put New York's ICE detainer rejections above 16,000 cases, as sheriffs sue the state and Governor Hochul's office disputes the framing.
Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.
New York ICE detainer rejections have topped 16,000 cases since the Trump administration took office, according to Department of Homeland Security (DHS) data cited this week, with federal officials linking those declined detainers to more than 52,000 criminal charges or convictions. The fight escalated as 15 New York sheriffs sued the state over the law limiting their cooperation with ICE, and Governor Hochul’s office pushed back on DHS’s framing.
Key Takeaways
- DHS says New York jurisdictions have rejected more than 16,000 ICE detainer requests tied to over 52,000 alleged crimes.
- Fifteen New York county sheriffs are suing Governor Hochul and the state attorney general over the law that limits detainer cooperation.
- DHS’s released breakdown attributes specific categories to the rejected detainers, including 131 homicides, 132 kidnappings and 2,017 sexual-offense counts.
- Hochul’s office disputes the framing, saying the state already notifies ICE when a noncitizen is serving a state prison sentence.
- DHS estimates roughly 2,000 people held in New York facilities have been turned over to federal immigration enforcement under the Trump administration.
What Is an ICE Detainer, and Why Is New York Rejecting Them?
An ICE detainer is a request to a local or state jail asking it to hold a person suspected of being in the country illegally for up to 48 hours so federal agents can take custody. New York doesn’t require local agencies to honor those requests, and the Trump administration has formally labeled New York — along with Washington state — a sanctuary state over policies like it.
Governor Hochul signed a law in August placing further restrictions on statewide cooperation with ICE on civil immigration matters. That’s the backdrop for DHS’s count of more than 16,000 rejected detainers.
What Charges Are Tied to the Rejected Detainers?
DHS released a partial category breakdown of the alleged offenses connected to the detainers New York declined. Added together, the categories below come to roughly 14,700 — well short of the 52,000-charge total DHS cites, which suggests these are illustrative categories rather than a complete accounting. DHS’s public materials don’t explain the gap.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
| Category | Count cited by DHS |
|---|---|
| Homicides | 131 |
| Kidnappings | 132 |
| Sexual offenses | 2,017 |
| Driving under the influence | 1,561 |
| Burglaries | 1,631 |
| Robberies | 1,776 |
| Weapons infractions | 2,198 |
| Assaults | 952 |
| Dangerous-drug counts | 4,324 |
Sheriffs Sue Albany Over ICE Cooperation Limits
Fifteen sheriffs across New York are suing the governor and attorney general over the state law restricting how far they can go in helping ICE. One sheriff quoted in the segment framed it as a resource question:
We didn’t need any 287g agreements. In fact, I think they’re in the way of making progress because I want local police using local taxpayer dollars to focus on catching local criminals.
New York isn’t an isolated case. Sanctuary-cooperation fights have played out this year in other sanctuary city standoffs, in Texas’s decision to transport migrants to sanctuary cities, and in a separate Minneapolis sanctuary policy clash.
Hochul’s Office Pushes Back
A spokeswoman for Governor Hochul disputed DHS’s framing, telling the New York Post that the state already shares information with federal immigration authorities in at least one circumstance:
By law, New York State always notifies federal immigration enforcement of any noncitizen serving a state prison sentence.
She went further, calling DHS’s characterization inaccurate:
Any assertion otherwise is a blatant mischaracterization of the facts meant to distract from the cruelty and violence we saw from Secretary Mullen’s ICE agents earlier this week.
That statement points to a separate, still-unresolved incident: the Bronx shooting below.
The Bronx Shooting That Escalated the Standoff
Tensions between the Trump administration and New York boiled over when ICE agents shot a man identified in the segment as Oscar Belgal in the Bronx. ICE’s account says Belgal refused to exit his vehicle, struck two government cars, and accelerated toward federal agents before he was shot in the neck. A 5-year-old child was in the back seat during the confrontation. Belgal is now in federal custody, according to that account.
NFRP’s Take
Opinion: The math on DHS’s own numbers doesn’t close, and that’s worth flagging on its own. But the underlying dispute — over who is accountable when both ICE and the state decline to hold a suspect — is a genuine policy disagreement, not a settled fact. The sheriffs’ lawsuit suggests that disagreement runs deeper than politics in Albany.
Up next

New York Second Home Tax Targets $5M Empty Apartments
Watch next

Reasonable+ members-only story New York City
“I’m Muslim” Saved Him From Russian Woman’s NYC Syringe Attack On Jews
Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.