Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

California

Kaiser Tower Oakland Default Wipes 75% Off Its Value

Kaiser Permanente's national headquarters tower is in maturity default after its owner declined to put more money into a building down 75%.

Share:

Kaiser Tower Oakland Default Wipes 75% Off Its Value

Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.

Prefer audio? Listen to the podcast version:

One Kaiser Plaza, the Ordway building that serves as Kaiser Permanente’s national headquarters, is in maturity default. The Kaiser Tower Oakland default landed when the owner did not repay a $97.1 million mortgage that came due on July 1, and local reporting puts the drop in the tower’s market value at roughly 75%.

Key Takeaways

  • Owner Creative Media and Community Trust disclosed the default in a Form 8-K filed with the SEC.
  • The $97.1 million mortgage hit maturity on July 1, and the servicer for the securitized trust has demanded immediate payment in full.
  • The owner is current on monthly interest but elected not to invest the additional capital a refinance would have required.
  • Kaiser, Oakland’s third largest private employer, told downtown workers to stay in their buildings for work and lunch after street robberies.

What actually happened at One Kaiser Plaza?

The mortgage on 1 Kaiser Plaza reached its July 1 maturity with $97.1 million still outstanding. The owner did not pay it off and was not able to refinance it. The servicer for the securitized trust responded by demanding immediate payment in full.

A maturity default is not a missed monthly payment — it is what happens when a loan reaches the end of its term and the borrower cannot, or will not, retire the balance. That distinction matters here, because the filing notes the owner is current on monthly interest. This is not a borrower who ran out of cash. This is a borrower who ran the math.

We know any of this because the owner, Creative Media and Community Trust, is publicly traded. When something material happens at a public company, it files a Form 8-K with the SEC — essentially a heads-up that there is an issue. People ask for transparency in commercial real estate and almost never get it. A public owner is the rare case where you get a look at the books.

Free weekly email

The Friday Reasonable Brief

A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.

Subscription Form

We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.

Why the owner chose not to refinance

Local reporting found the building’s valuation had fallen about 75%. Lose three-quarters of your value and the loan-to-value math stops working entirely. There is no cushion left for the lender and no equity left for the owner.

To refinance, somebody would have to write a very large check purely to close the gap between what the building is worth and what is owed on it. Nobody does that on a depreciating asset. It is the same call homeowners made in the Great Recession when a million-dollar house bought with almost nothing down reset to $600,000. You do not wire in a quarter million dollars to refinance something on its way down.

So the filing says it plainly: the owner elected not to invest additional capital that would have been needed to refinance. The company is now in talks with the special servicer about a longer-term solution and possible extensions. Under the loan documents, the default notice puts rents and profits in trust for the lender. Standard stuff — and the beginning of a transfer.

What the Kaiser Tower Oakland default signals for lenders

This is the part that deserves more attention than the building. Mid-size and small commercial banks are local lenders by design. That is their book. They know the borrower, they know the block, they write the deal.

Now picture a portfolio of those deals repricing at a 75% markdown. That kind of exposure does not stay contained to one tower, and these resets are not rare anymore. Older Bay Area office towers keep taking steep markdowns as tenants give back space and buyers insist on deeper discounts for anything they read as riskier and harder to lease.

Call it what it is: a commercial reset, running nationally. It looks like foreclosures, deeds in lieu, credit swaps — whatever mechanism moves the keys. We have watched the same math play out in Denver’s skyscraper markdowns and in a Portland tower selling below 2010 prices.

Why did Kaiser tell its workers to stay inside?

Because employees who stepped out to grab lunch were getting robbed on the street. In a memo obtained by KTVU in January 2024, Kaiser directed workers in downtown Oakland to stay in their buildings for work and lunch in response to street robberies of workers who went out to eat. Staff were told to bring their own food or have it delivered.

If you can work at home, work at home.

Kaiser later said in part that those recommendations remain in place for now, and that the company is committed to ensuring the safety and security of its employees and physicians across all of its locations. Another downtown worker called the policy atrocious and said it amounted to a policy that would destroy Oakland.

Run that objection down, though. What is the alternative for an employer whose people get mugged on a lunch break? The building is secured. The street is not. A company that ignores that difference is not defending the city, it is exposing its staff.

The ripple effect on everything around the tower

Kaiser is Oakland’s third largest private employer, and its downtown footprint has been shrinking steadily. Every step down takes a layer of the neighborhood economy with it.

  • Lunch counters and sandwich shops that live entirely on weekday foot traffic
  • Laundromats people used during the workday or right after it
  • Minimarts, coffee shops and small ground-floor retail
  • Service providers who count on Kaiser workers and visitors to keep the lights on

Layer that on top of remote work, which never fully reversed, and a commercial real estate market that is constricting on its own. Then add the reason nobody wants to be downtown after five. Oakland has had a real run of violent crime — bullets in the exterior wall of an In-N-Out that eventually closed, an airport where the working assumption is that your car may get stolen out of the garage.

The city has fought over how to respond right down to whether a neighborhood can even put up its own anti-crime barriers.

Who buys an office tower in downtown Oakland?

Somebody will, eventually, at the right price. That is what a reset is for. A new owner comes in at a massive discount, spends a little to fix the place up, gets some cheap rents in there and fills it.

The harder question is who leases it. A large company signing a 10-year lease on downtown Oakland office space is betting on the streets outside, not the finishes inside. Recovery for older, largely single-tenant office buildings is still fragile, and the decisions of the bigger occupiers — Kaiser above all — keep steering the local office market.

Whether the danger is real or perceived barely matters to that decision. In Oakland it is real, but the optics alone would be enough. The same dynamic has parked Portland dead last for investment appeal, and it is no coincidence that the cities with the worst public safety reputations carry the deepest office discounts.

The honest surprise is that it took this long

Seventy-five percent sounds catastrophic, and it is. For a downtown Oakland office tower in this market, it is also not a shock. The shock would have been a clean refinance.

What comes next is procedural. The lender moves to seize more control over the rents or ultimately forces a sale. Creative Media and Community Trust weighs its options while the special servicer evaluates its next move. And the merchants at the base of the building wait to find out whether anyone is coming back at all.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a maturity default?

It is a default triggered when a loan reaches the end of its term and the balance is not repaid. Here the $97.1 million mortgage on 1 Kaiser Plaza came due July 1 and went unpaid, and the servicer demanded payment in full.

Is Kaiser Permanente still in downtown Oakland?

The Ordway building still serves as Kaiser’s national headquarters, but the reporting describes a steadily shrinking downtown footprint, and Kaiser said its recommendations that workers stay inside remain in place for now.

Why did this default become public so fast?

The owner is a publicly traded company, so it disclosed the event in a Form 8-K filed with the SEC rather than handling it quietly with the lender.

If your employer told you to eat lunch at your desk for your own safety, would you still be commuting downtown? Tell us what your city’s core looks like right now in the comments.

Full Episode Transcript

Read the full transcript of this episode

the counter to grab the cash register. Sanchez fights back by pulling out a hammer. He says he was prepared >> Eazy’s Lounge on 14th Street. Oakland Police Officers Association confirmed the incident. The Oakland Police Department also says one died at the scene who was later identified as a 33-year-old woman. >> left >> He tells me he was robbed at gunpoint in front of his store when it was located in downtown Oakland, and that store was broke >> project. Officials say about 30 feet of the pier sunk after 300 feet of shoreline crumbled this afternoon. >> surrounded the fenced-in Caltrans property at 34th Street and Mandela Parkway in West Oakland.

>> Not because the owners want to cash out, but because they defaulted on a $90 million loan, and the court took the keys away. The property is still open. Slot machines are still running. The hot dog stand at the entrance is still doing $3 deals. >> Downtown Oakland gut punch. Kaiser Tower tank 75% as a loan default hits. Buildings going back. Bunch of buildings in Oakland have gone back. Let’s get into it. Here we go. What I thought was interesting about this one is you got a publicly traded company. So, everything is actually, you know, when when people say, “Well, I want to see more transparency.” There’s just a scooch of transparency when you got a publicly owned company that has a mortgage out that you have things aren’t going all that well.

One of downtown Oakland’s most recognizable towers just landed in serious trouble. I mean, it’s a good-looking building, right? Oakland’s One Kaiser Plaza, the Ordway building that serves as Kaiser Permanente’s national headquarters, is now in maturity default after its owners did not repay a $97.1 million mortgage that came due on July 1st. Recent reporting says the tower’s market value has dropped by 75% putting one of the city’s marquee office property squarely in its lender’s sights. No, not their sights. It dumped it in their lap cuz now they’re going to have to do something with it. The default follows months of soft leasing.

Nobody’s leasing. And Kaiser steadily shrinking its downtown footprint. So, as Kaiser, which is a main employer in downtown Oakland, as they shrink, so do all the other accompanying businesses. You know, shops, restaurants, all the places, lunch places, laundromats so people can do their laundry, you know, during their work day or maybe right after. You know, all of those businesses, mini-marts, sandwich shops, you get the picture. They’re they’re gone, too. And it just creates this massive effect. And so, in a city like Oakland where you’ve got some major, major crime issues going on, and we’re going to look at that.

And then also, you’ve got the whole work-from-home deal. And then you’ve got a commercial real estate market that is constricting. It’s commercial real estate. I think you’ve got a bunch of bad banks not bags, banks on the ropes right now. I’ve already podcasted a couple, right? You’re going to see more and more that have a heavy portfolio of local commercial deals cuz that’s what a lot of the mid-size commercial banks, mid and small commercial banks, that’s what they do, local lending. Right? Friend of the family. Till they’re not. Yeah, we’re going to need you to do a deed in lieu of foreclosure.

Sorry there, Freddy. The default follows months of soft leasing. Kaiser steadily shrinking. Loan hits maturity, lender calls the shot. According to a form 8-K filed by Creative Media and Community Trust, all right. Let’s break that down. Creative Media and Community Trust is the owner of the building. They are the mortgagee. And a form 8-K is a form when something happens with the publicly traded company, you got to fill that out and send it into the SEC. It’s kind of like a heads-up, “Hey, we got this issue going on.” And it’s because they they didn’t make their July 1st maturity with the loan and they’re not able to refinance it.

The mortgage on 1 Kaiser Plaza reached its July 1st maturity with 97.1 million still outstanding. And the servicer for the securitized trust has now demanded immediate payment in full. Okay, see July 1st maturity, 97.1 million. So, was it worth, you know, a couple hundred million at one time and is it is it now down to is it is it 50 grand? You know, some some rough numbers like that, down 75 grand. Maybe maybe it’s down enough where they’ve kept the interest portion of the loan serviced, but in order to get a refinance, they’d have to bring in the difference between what it’s lost in value and create an equity equity position so that the lender has a position and they have a position.

But who’s going to want to bring in 50 million or whatever it is to to get your loan to value up to where it needs to be on a building that’s worth 50 million bucks? Who’s going to do that? Nobody. So, all these resets are happening. And by resets, I mean foreclosures or deed in lieu or credit swaps or whatever it is, right? However, the property gets transferred ultimately to a new buyer because then that buyer has a massive discount. They can reset. Maybe they can spend a little money to fix it up. Maybe they can get it rented out, you know, and get some cheap rents in there. It’s a reset. You’re seeing a commercial reset across the country.

So, July 1st maturity with 97.1 million still outstanding and the servicer for the securitized trust has now demanded immediate payment in full. That’s That’s just what happens. That’s just That’s how this sequence goes, right? The filing notes that the owner is current on monthly interest, but elected not to invest additional capital that would have been needed to refinance. So, I mean, it’s It’s It’s not unlike the Great Recession when all these people had 5% down or, you know, 0% down loans. And when those property values dropped 20, 25, 30%. So, now your million-dollar home is now worth 600, 700.

You’re not going to wait for it to turn around. You’re not going to You’re not going to You’re not going to chip in quarter million dollars and, you know, refinance it on its way down. You’re just not going to do that. And that’s what this commercial um uh owner basically said. Now, it would have needed to refinance and if the company is in talks with the special servicer about a longer-term solution. How can we help you take this property back? Local reporting found the building’s valuation had fallen about 75%. That’s what we’ve seen consistently. Lost about three-quarters of its value. And that’s why I say I think you’re right on the front end of a pretty major shift with commercial banks.

I I commercial banks going into default. There’s no way that they don’t have some pretty massive exposure out there. A plunge that badly strained the loan-to-value numbers and left lenders with almost no cushion. Almost no cushion. If you lose 75% of your value, what cushion would you possibly have? Yeah, no. No. That kind of steep markdown is becoming more common across older Bay Area office towers as tenants give back space space and buyers insist on deeper discounts for what they see as riskier, harder to lease properties. So, let’s take a look. Um Yeah, here we go. Kaiser to Oakland workers, stay inside for work and lunch.

Okay, this is downtown Oakland. So, not only did after the pandemic did we have the whole work from home, everybody’s working remotely, this going to be the greatest thing ever, and then it’s not. Um not only did we have that, but in areas like downtown Seattle that have been dangerous, um when you’ve got escorts of ca- of of city workers, county workers, federal workers to their individual buildings by you know, hired security, when you’ve literally got to escort people because your streets are so unsafe, it doesn’t exactly scream to prospective tenants, “Hey, come rent this building. Come get some space here.

This is This is great.” And Oakland is no exception. Oakland is kind of the poster child for uh Used to be cool, but Oakland’s third largest private employer, Kaiser, issued a memo directing workers in downtown Oakland to stay in their buildings for lunch and work in response to street robberies of workers who went out to grab something to eat. Imagine going to work. Well, I was work today. I mean, it was good, but you know, I got mugged. Like, what? Yeah. Workers are told to bring their own food or have it delivered. Yeah, but then you’re risking the Uber dude. He’s going to get mugged. He’s going to get robbed.

It’s just kind of scary in general, not even just to go to work, just kind of coming outside. Kaiser [snorts] parking garage, if you can work at home, work at home. If you have to come in, just be safe about it. That does not scream, “Hey, come to downtown Oakland. Let’s party.” in a commercial real estate manner, does it? No. It doesn’t. No. Memo issued last month and obtained by KTVU, this is from 2024, January 2024. So, it’s a while ago, but it’s relevant because that’s how Kaiser has they’ve moved employees out of the downtown, they’ve moved them to the suburbs. They’ve also moved out of California, big shocker, I know.

Um in a statement, Kaiser said in part, “Those recommendations remain in place for now. Kaiser is committed to ensuring the safety and security of our employees and physicians across all of our locations.” Well, yeah, and Oakland ain’t exactly It’s It’s not safe. It’s just not safe. Moe Ger- Gevert- Gevertz, who also works downtown, was aghast when told of Kaiser’s memo, saying it would be a policy to destroy Oakland. Well, I mean, Oakland’s kind of destroyed itself. To corporation tell them to stay in the building and bring lunch from home is atrocious. Is it? What if your employee goes outside and gets mugged or worse?

What if that happens because you can’t control your own crime situation? You got too many killers running around. You got too many rapists running around. You got too many thieves running around, just running the streets of Oakland. You got too much of that going on. So, responsible companies say, “Yeah, um yeah, uh building safe, we know that because we’ve got 45 different security security guards throughout. They’re all making sure you guys are good.” Um but yeah, you know, try and stay in and lunch, uh >> [sighs] >> DoorDash that bad boy. DoorDash that bad boy, right? So, downtown ripple effects.

Kaiser, one of the biggest employers in Oakland, just you know, pulling basically pulling out. The lender moves to seize more control over rent or ultimately forces a sale of the tower. That could deliver another jolt to merchants and service providers who count on Kaiser workers and visitors to keep the lights on. So, [snorts] what did loan documents, the K8? Default notice, rents, profits, they all go in trust for the lender. Standard stuff, right? What comes next for the tower in downtown? Creative Media and Community Trust or regulators, it’s weighing its options and discussing possible extensions with the lender while the special servicer evaluates its next move.

All right. >> [laughter] >> Uh that recovery for older, largely single-tenant office buildings is still fragile. The decisions of bigger occupiers, especially Kaiser, continue to steer the local office market. Well, you’ve got all your big boys pulling out of your downtowns if it’s unsafe. I mean, and let’s let’s let’s even take a step further back from there. California in general. California in general pulling back, Oakland in specific. Yeah, it’s not safe. Right? So, there’s multiple whammies. And then, Kaiser has a lot of these employees, they’re able to work from home.

So, they’re going to do that. And then at some point in time, Kaiser is going to scoop up all its employees and take them to Nashville, take them to Nevada, take them to wherever that’s lower taxes, safer. I mean, Oakland, yeah, poster child for not safe. Remember the In-N-Out Burger story where you you know, you had bullets going into the wall, exterior wall of the In-N-Out Burger in Oakland and they eventually closed it down. I mean, we had a real run of a violent violent crime happening in Oakland. Some of that’s tamped down, but you know, overall, not to the point where a big corporation’s going to take down a 10-year lease on office space in downtown Oakland.

So, cities like Oakland, cities like Seattle, cities like um Portland is a good example where you’ve got some real criminal behavior on the streets and and whether it’s real or perceived, it almost doesn’t matter. And we know it to be real in Oakland, but it’s the it’s the optics, right? It’s when I think of Oakland, do I think of, you know, picnics in the park? Not really. Not as much. Do I want to be in a park in downtown? The answer is no. And why is that? Well, cuz you might get mugged. Like New York City back in the day, right? Crazy. I mean, you you’ve got uh hotels closing down at the airport.

The airport in Oakland basically says, um you know, your car may get stolen. Yeah, you know, park in our garage, but your car likelihood is uh high, your car is going to get stolen. So, when you’ve got that kind of criminal element on top of a building losing 75% of its value, doesn’t look good, does it? No. It It’s got to have a big foreclosure, some kind of transfer sale, some kind of deal. And then even then, who’s going to want to come in and take down this office space? What big What big company’s going to Oh, let’s go to Oakland. I hear it’s nice there this time of year. And I I have a lot of folks I know that are you know, staunch staunch Oakland supporters.

Like hardcore. I mean, you know, tattoos of the Raiders kind of deal. You know what I mean? Seriously. People love Oakland cuz I think back in the day it used to be a really really cool city, town, whatever you want to call it. But it’s just it’s it’s it’s not gone the right direction and it’s commercial certainly not gone the right direction. I’m actually surprised that it’s only taken a 75% hit. Must not have been valued at all that much back in whenever this purchase was made. So 75% hit, yeah, not a shocker. Not a shocker. So, there you go. There’s Oakland for you. Huh, how’s that working out?

Not all that great. Make sure you hit the subscribe button. Hit the notification bell. I’ll see you in the next episode. Thanks again for joining. Bye for now. >> [music]

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

Seattle Office Tower Collapse: Sold for 16 Cents on the Dollar

Seattle Office Tower Collapse: Sold for 16 Cents on the Dollar

Watch next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.