Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

New York City

Mamdani’s Pied-à-Terre Tax Rollout Now Faces Two Lawsuits

A Staten Island judge has already forced one rewrite of Mayor Mamdani's luxury second-home tax, and a second lawsuit from a casino owner and a former Trump cabinet secretary is now testing it again.

Share:

Mamdani's Pied-à-Terre Tax Rollout Now Faces Two Lawsuits

Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.

The Mamdani pied-à-terre tax — a surcharge on luxury second homes meant to raise roughly $500 million a year for New York City — is now fighting on two legal fronts after a Staten Island judge invalidated notices the city had already mailed to property owners. The rollout has been contested in court since the city first sent notices in July, and the dispute shows no sign of resolving before the surcharge can be collected.

Key Takeaways

  • In July, the city issued notices to roughly 17,000 addresses, and the Department of Finance separately compiled a list of about a million properties considered in assessing the tax.
  • An August lawsuit led a judge to order the city to take down a list of more than 900,000 potentially affected properties and reissue notices.
  • A Staten Island judge has now invalidated a second round of mailed notices, prompting a new lawsuit from a billionaire casino owner and a former Trump cabinet secretary.
  • The surcharge applies to homes valued at $5 million or higher, or condos and co-ops worth at least $1 million.
  • City court filings show the Department of Finance had already exempted 4,000 to 17,000 homeowners from the tax before the latest ruling.

How the legal fight has unfolded, step by step

The timeline runs in three stages. First, in July, the city sent surcharge notices to roughly 17,000 addresses while the Department of Finance held a broader list of about a million properties under review. Second, an August lawsuit produced a court order requiring the city to take down a list of more than 900,000 potentially subject properties and issue new notices. Third, this week, a Staten Island judge invalidated that second round of notices, which is what opened the door to a fresh lawsuit from casino owner Stephen Wynn and former Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross. Each stage has forced the city to redo its paperwork rather than collect the tax.

Who is suing, and what they’re arguing

Wynn and Ross, joined by Ross’s wife, argue the surcharge discriminates against wealthy out-of-towners because it falls exclusively on non-residents of New York City who already pay property taxes, homeowners’ association dues, and transfer taxes on their second homes. Ross’s own filings put his additional liability at $83,000, with Wynn’s at $183,000 for a Manhattan property. The surcharge itself applies to homes valued at $5 million or higher, or condos and co-ops worth at least $1 million — the same threshold the city has used since the tax was written into the state budget in May. NFRP has tracked Mamdani’s broader fiscal fights in coverage like the mayor’s $12 billion deficit plan and the grocery-store lawsuit from immigrant grocers.

What’s still unresolved

The city says it will appeal the latest ruling and seek a stay so it can keep implementing the surcharge while litigation continues. Until that appeal is decided, the roughly $500 million in projected annual revenue the city is counting on remains tied up — the tax exists on paper, but the notices needed to actually collect it keep getting thrown out.

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

NYC Delivery Mandate Could Cost Households $664 a Year

NYC Delivery Mandate Could Cost Households $664 a Year

Watch next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.