NYC City-Owned Grocery Stores: $70M, No Butchers
Mamdani's five city-owned markets carry a $70 million price tag and likely no butchers or hot food.
Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s plan for NYC city-owned grocery stores now carries a $70 million price tag, and city officials have conceded the five stores likely will not have butchers or hot food. Chicago ran a smaller version of this experiment with taxpayer money and closed seven subsidized stores over the weekend. That is the comparison worth holding onto.
Key Takeaways
- Five city-owned markets, one per borough, expected to cost upwards of $70 million in taxpayer money.
- The stores likely will not include hot food or butchers, and city-run grocers will not sell hot food, alcohol, or cigarettes, the categories corner stores make most of their money on.
- A core basket of goods gets priced 30% below typical retail and reset monthly. Soda is explicitly not discounted.
- Eight months into Mamdani’s tenure, only two of the five promised supermarkets have identified locations. None are built.
What will NYC city-owned grocery stores actually sell?
A city-owned grocery store is a retail operation the municipal government builds, stocks, and prices, funded by taxpayers rather than by the margin on what it sells. That distinction is the entire ballgame, and it shows up immediately in what these stores are allowed to carry.
The pitch is a core basket of goods. Once a month, the five city-run stores set prices on that basket at 30% below typical retail. In the mayor’s framing: no exceptions, no gimmicks, the savings last for the entire month, no weekly fluctuations and no sticker shock at the checkout line.
Now the fine print. Economic Development Corporation officials revealed at a board meeting Thursday that the five stores, expected to cost upwards of $70 million, will likely not include hot food items or butchers. The city is attempting to offset some of that cost by not allowing government-run grocers to sell hot food, alcohol, and cigarettes. And soda, one of the highest-volume items in any store, is deliberately excluded from the discount. As one EDC official put it, they did a lot of analysis of what people buy, and even though a lot of people buy soda, they are not discounting soda.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
So it is a grocery store, except for the bakery, the butcher, the hot food, the beer, and the soda. Officials still say it will be like a typical supermarket. Remove all of that and what is left is not typical anything.
Why does one store cost $30 million and take three years?
That is the number that should stop people cold. Other chains build a grocery store for about $3 million to $5 million, and some of them go up in as little as six weeks. The government-run store, on land the city already owns, is projected at $30 million and a minimum of three years.
Same product. Same square footage. Six to ten times the cost and roughly twenty-five times the timeline. If that ratio does not tell you something is broken before a single carton of eggs gets stocked, nothing will.
The timing makes it sharper. Mamdani announced the second city-owned store shortly after announcing the city is broke, that it has to raid the rainy day fund, and that taxes are going up.
What happens to the bodegas?
They are already organizing. Operators of bodegas, grocers, and convenience stores gathered at City Hall against the plan. Frank Garcia, who chairs the Multicultural Business Coalition at the Greater New York Chamber of Commerce, is considering a lawsuit to stop it. His line is the cleanest summary anyone has offered: they are using our tax dollars against our members.
One store owner, Luna, expects to lose 30% of his customers once a city store opens near him, because he cannot compete with a nationalized grocer that does not pay property taxes or utilities and has access to his own tax dollars. His words: no way, there is no way we can be open, if I lose 30% I am in trouble.
The categories the city stores are skipping are exactly the categories corner stores make most of their money on. That sounds like mercy until you remember the subsidized competitor is undercutting the staples those same stores use to get people in the door. It is not a carve-out. It is a squeeze from a different angle. This fight has been building since the campaign, from the bodega owners’ revolt to a grocery CEO firing back at the whole premise.
If one publicly owned grocery store that brings prices down in the neighborhood is enough to put someone out of business, maybe they shouldn’t have been in that business in the first place.
That is Gustavo Gordillo, asked by Martha MacCallum what a bodega should do if the government opens a big grocery store next door. Read it twice. The store he is describing is subsidized with the bodega owner’s own tax money. There is no version of that competition an unsubsidized store wins.
Chicago already ran this experiment
Seven Save-A-Lot stores shut down across Chicago’s South and West Sides on Saturday. Just gone. The closures come four years after the city of Chicago announced it would put $13.5 million in taxpayer financing into Yellow Banana as part of a roughly $26 million deal to buy and renovate six stores in those neighborhoods.
So the public put money in, there was a ribbon cutting, and inside a few years the stores are dark and the neighborhoods are food deserts again. Save-A-Lot and Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson are blaming federal funding cuts and changes to programs like SNAP benefits. The timeline does not support that. The SNAP changes are recent, and these stores had been struggling long before them.
What actually happened is the thing nobody in leadership wants to name out loud: shoplifting, safety incidents, and costs that went through the roof. Stores that bleed get closed. That is true of subsidized stores and unsubsidized ones alike.
Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker’s answer is an initiative that, in his words, literally helps people start grocery stores. Nobody has trouble opening grocery stores. The trouble is keeping them open. An initiative aimed at store security and shoplifting would do more for these neighborhoods than another ribbon.
Is a subsidized price actually a lower price?
At the city stores, eggs will be cheaper and bread will be cheaper. That claim will be true. It will also be true that they are cheaper because the shopper’s own tax money made them cheaper, which is not the same thing as a lower price. It is a price moved from the register to the tax bill.
Grocery runs on a few percent margin. That thin margin is the entire discipline of the business: it forces operators to buy right, staff right, waste nothing, and drop products that do not move. Take away the requirement to survive on it and you have removed the only mechanism that keeps the operation efficient.
What replaces it is a quarterly report that says the stores only lost $45 million this quarter, which is an improvement over the $55 million last quarter, so things are looking up. That is the trajectory, and it runs until taxpayers get loud enough to shut it down.
Does the Trader Joe’s comparison hold up?
On X, the reaction ran from this is destined to fail to this is basically Trader Joe’s. The second one sounds clever and falls apart on contact.
Trader Joe’s works because you can get enough of what you actually need in one trip. You cannot get everything there, but you can get enough. Their beer is warm because they run a small cooler instead of a giant one, and that efficiency is a choice a private operator makes because it shows up in the margin. I will take warm beer at two bucks cheaper and cool it down at home.
The city plan inverts that. You get roughly half a dozen discounted items on a basket that resets monthly, no hot food, no butcher, no cheap soda. So you save two dollars on eggs and then drive to a second store for everything else. Most people will not make that trip. I hate going to more than one store, and I am not unusual.
Where the plan actually stands
Eight months into his tenure, only two of the five promised supermarkets have locations. Not built. Identified. Meanwhile the city is raiding the rainy day fund and preparing to raise taxes, and money that can move is already moving, which is the story behind the $100 million Florida surge.
The subsidized grocery model has never worked anywhere it has been tried at scale, and Chicago’s version failed while New York was still drawing up plans. There is no reason to expect a different outcome in five boroughs with a bigger budget and a shorter product list.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much will New York’s city-owned grocery stores cost?
Upwards of $70 million in taxpayer money for five stores, one in each borough. A single store on city-owned land is projected at $30 million with a three-year minimum build time.
Will the city stores sell hot food or alcohol?
No. The city is offsetting cost by not allowing government-run grocers to sell hot food, alcohol, or cigarettes, and officials say the stores likely will not have butchers either.
What happened to Chicago’s subsidized grocery stores?
Seven Save-A-Lot stores across the South and West Sides closed on Saturday, four years after the city announced $13.5 million in taxpayer financing to Yellow Banana as part of a roughly $26 million deal covering six stores.
I will podcast it the day these stores shut down, and I think that day is coming. But I would rather be wrong. If you shop in one of the five boroughs, would a store with cheap eggs and bread and nothing else pull you away from your bodega? Tell me in the comments.
Full Episode Transcript
Read the full transcript of this episode
New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s a $70 million plan to open city-owned grocery stores is getting a lot of scrutiny. For example, >> we’re going to call him a Democratic Socialist. On Monday, stands up to announce New York City’s second city-owned grocery store. $70 million in taxpayer money, which is amazing, because Mamdani just announced that the city’s broke. And that they’re having to raid the rainy day fund, and they’re going to have to raise taxes. >> Other chains are about that 3 to 5 million is the most that I could find to be built in as little as 6 weeks. Again, these are grocery stores we’re talking about.
And yet, Mamdani’s government-run grocery store, built on land the city already owns, is going to cost $30 million and at a minimum take 3 years. Does that not tell you a problem right off the top? >> The city is attempting to offset some of that by not allowing government-run grocers to sell hot food, alcohol, and cigarettes, where smaller corner stores make most of their money. >> Operators of bodegas, grocers, and convenience stores uniting at City Hall against Mayor Mamdani’s plan to open city-owned markets that could undercut their prices on staples. Frank Garcia chairs the Multicultural Business Coalition at the Greater New York Chamber of Commerce.
He’s considering a lawsuit to stop it. >> They’re using our tax dollars against our members. >> Luna says that once it opens, he anticipates losing 30% of his customers because he cannot compete with a nationalized grocery store, which doesn’t have to pay property taxes or utilities and has access to his hard-earned tax dollars. >> No way. There’s no way we can be open. If if if if I lose 30%, I’m in trouble. >> [music] >> All right. So, Mamdani officials, they admit that New York City-owned markets, got five of them going in, one for each of the boroughs.
It’s going to cost $70 million all subsidized by the taxpayers of New York City. So, these five markets, they won’t have features like butchers, hot food, discounted soda, or really anything that people are going to want to go in and buy. And they’ve got this, what they call a core basket of goods. Are you really going to go in there and everything else is just kind of like, uh This is how they’re touting affordable groceries. As critics rail, plan is destined for failure. You mean like the seven subsidized grocery stores in Chicago, the South and West Side, that closed two days ago? You You mean like those?
>> will set prices for this core set of goods at 30% below typical retail prices. No exceptions, no gimmicks. The savings will last for the entire month. Here’s how it all work. Once a month, our five city-run grocery stores will set prices for this core set of goods at 30% below typical retail prices. No exceptions, no gimmicks. The savings will last for the entire month. That means no weekly fluctuations, no sticker shock at the checkout line. Here >> Okay. So, that that’s how That’s how I’m Donny says this is going to work. Subsidized until it’s not. 30% off. So, don’t you kind of need to know which which things you’re going to go get at the grocery store, especially when only four of them are discounted 30%?
Is Is this Does this make any sense at all? I am no I am no, you know, small business grocery store dude, but I talk to my guys at the minimart a lot. And I talk to the folks and managers at at Trader Joe’s a lot. And I used to talk to ones at QVC. I’d ask questions and just how’s this going? You know, why didn’t why wasn’t this product? Well, couldn’t make enough money off of it and it was iffy whether we’d get it in or not, so we cut it and we’re going with something else. People want consistency. They want to know that when they go into the store, they’re going to be getting what they want, whether it’s expensive or not.
Because you go into Whole Foods, whole paycheck. Yeah, it’s expensive. Everything is super expensive. Go into Trader Joe’s. All right. I know I can get this, this, this, and this all for a buck 99, right? 299. Whatever it might be. You know what you get. But in Mondaini’s world, it’s on a rotating basis and well, we don’t know, you know, from month to month, but we’ve got this core good of basket or a basket of goods, core basket of goods. >> [laughter] >> Mayor Eric L. Mondaini’s Economic Development Corporation admitted that his city-owned grocery stores might not have all the items you’d find in a typical supermarket.
And And people who were saying literally straight-up, “Ah, so it’s Trader Joe’s.” We’ll read about that in a second. Cuz Trader Joe’s doesn’t have I mean, you go to look for shaving cream. Well, right, they’ve actually got shaving cream, meaning you push it out. It’s not aerosol, right? Cuz that’s terrible for the environment. We don’t want that. So, you’ve got this kind of weird orange shaving cream. It actually works really good and I really like it. And I would have never used it before cuz I I I like that aerosol. I like that shh. Thing foams out. Put it on your face. Just, you know, makes you look like Santa.
It’s epic. Five stores, which are expected to cost upwards of 70 million, will likely not include hot food items or butchers, EDC officials revealed during a board meeting Thursday. It may not have all the items, but it’s going to be like a typical grocery store. >> Huh. Okay. But otherwise, it’s I mean, if it had if it had all the items if it had a bakery, if it had a butcher, if it had cheap soda, if it had then it would be a normal grocery store. It’s going to be just like a normal grocery store. >> [laughter] >> It’s laughable. These these are laughable comparisons to reality, right?
Cuz meanwhile, literally, and we’ll talk about it in a second, we’ll go through it, you got grocery stores closing down because they were city subsidized and now they’re not because they’re closed. Everybody shoplifted from them. They had enough safety events. They weren’t making any money. They were a loser. Closed. And that’s what Mom and Pop stores will be like, right? That’s exactly what they’ll be like. Bach also echoed at Mom and Pop’s assertion that only certain items in the stores would be discounted. We did a lot of analysis of what people buy in terms of their everyday goods. Even if there are a lot of people who buy soda, we’re not discounting soda.
Okay. All right. So, you can get about half a dozen things at your store that are cheap. What about the rest? Is this enough of an incentive to go to Mom and Pop’s grocery stores? What if you got a store that’s like super close to you and it’s better? You know what I mean? You don’t have Okay. So, you got 30% off eggs. Eggs were six bucks. Now they’re four bucks. Are you going to go there for that $2 savings on five items or whatever it is? Probably not. You probably not cuz you need a whole bunch of stuff. And do you want to go to two stores? I don’t. I hate going to more than one store. I just And that’s literally the reason.
I could have walked from my Trader Joe’s next door into um Walgreens, I think it is. Which is They um they took over from somebody. I don’t even know. You know what I mean? All the good the the all the drugstores now are like They’re all big chains and you just you don’t know what you’re getting and you walk in and it’s just immediately a terrible experience. Big bright lights and you know, shoplifting cameras all over and you’re literally on camera the minute you walk in and they’ve got like two people for a 100,000 square foot store. You’re like, “Okay.” And then half the shelves are just empty and you’re like, “All right, are they they going to put some stuff in those shelves or what are we doing here?” Don’t know.
But in order for me to avoid that kind of thing, I’ll buy some kind of wonky product at Trader Joe’s and try it. That’s just me, to avoid going to Walgreens next door because you can’t get normal stuff at Trader Joe’s. You can’t get like your bathroom stuff and cleaning stuff. I’ve actually started buying cleaning product, you know, like a little green thing. It’s super handy. They’ve got general cleaning and this is a Trader Joe’s product and I use those on the boat. I’ve got a handful of those on the boat. They worked really well. And I don’t you know, they don’t have bleach in them, but yeah, you kind of like, “All right, this seems to clean pretty well.
Let’s go with this.” Let’s do this. Can’t get everything you want at Trader Joe’s, but you can get enough of what you need where you go there. “Oh my gosh, this is just destined to fail.” Said one user on X. “Anyone with experience with a grocery store there? This is such a bad idea.” Yeah, it seems like they’ve taken bits and pieces of what would be good in a grocery store and kind of Frankenstein them together and they they’ve got they’ve got this. They’ve got these bits and piece concepts that we have known won’t work because we’ve literally got stores closing down right now that are subsidized already.
And they’re gone out of business. Another Axe user liking the concept to another popular grocery store chain. This is Trader Joe’s basically. They wrote, You know, you know what I like about Trader Joe’s? They have a really great selection of beer, but it’s warm. And it’s because of efficiency. They don’t have a massive cooler to keep all this. They’ve got just a tiny little section. You know what? I’m okay with that. It’s like, all right. It’s two bucks cheaper than the mini mart across the street. And I don’t have to go to the mini mart across the street. It’s warm. All right, I’ll take it home.
I have a fridge. I can cool it down. You know, if if you need a cold beer that bad, mhm I mean, sometimes you do, right? But that means you just haven’t planned ahead. All right, you ran out. So, you got to do what? Oh, you can’t go to TJ’s. You got to go to Chevron and be charged more. On the campaign trail, Mondani had voted to open one city-owned grocery store in each borough, claiming that he would use the power of government to lower prices and make it easier for New Yorkers to put food on the table. All right. So, instead of saying use the power of government, how about you fleece the taxpayer to lower prices.
What about that? If if you would have said that, I believe that. I am going to take taxpayer money and subsidize this bad boy. Therefore, it’s going to be cheaper. Okay. All right. Yep. Yep, I can believe that. But this whole power of government, and that’s his thing, right? We need more government in our lives. Yeah, I don’t think so. I need less. Yeah, you need less regulation. Yeah, you need less oversight. Less is more. Living on less and liking it more. It was a book my mom was always reading in the 70s. Peter somebody. At our stores, eggs will be cheaper, bread will be cheaper, but nothing else.
I said that part. Grocery shopping will no longer be an unsolvable equation, he also claimed. I You know what? If nothing else is going to get discounted but a handful of things, it only does a tiny little bit to your equation. But, he can say what he’ll say is >> [snorts] >> we’ve got cheaper eggs. We’ve got cheaper bread. And that will be true. But, it’s only cheaper because your own tax money is making it cheaper. Is that really cheaper? No. No. Only capitalism gives enough incentive for competitors to figure out a way to make it cheaper. Government? What are What are the It’s like the eight words you hate to hear.
I’m from the government and I’m here to help, right? And you’re like, “Oh, no. Go away. Go away.” You know, they eight months into his tenure, only two out of the five promised supermarkets have locations. Not built, locations identified. And then we get into um we we get into this whole thing about where is that? If the government opened a big grocery store next to your bodega, what would you do? Host Martha MacCallum asked. And then uh Commie um co-chair Gustavo Gordillo replied, “If one publicly owned grocery store that brings prices down in the neighborhood is enough to put up someone out of business, maybe they shouldn’t have been in that business in the first place.” That is a statement by a true communist, is it not?
Because you’re basically subsidizing the one store with taxpayer money. There’s no way an un- un- subsidized store can compete. It’s a no-go. It’s a non-factor. But, you know, let’s pretend. Let’s pretend. Meanwhile, in Chicago seven Save-A-Lot stores shut down across Chicago’s South and West Sides. Heard. Seven Save-A-Lot stores across Chicago closed. It’s the same old story to be honest with you. It’s just not here nationally when it comes down to black communities. It does happen in black communities a lot. But it also happens in white communities. It happens here in Seattle. And you know what?
Leadership said uh corporate abandonment. This is These corporations, we need to hold them accountable. And the corporations are like, “Hey, you robbed us blind. You had a bunch of whacked-out drug addicts in the store, in the parking lot. It wasn’t safe. We weren’t making enough money. We just decided to close the bad boy.” And that’s what continually happens. And if they can’t make money, sorry. Sorry. And these stores were propped up with 13 Here it goes. Closures come 4 years after the city of Chicago announced it would give 13 and 1/2 million in taxpayer financing to Yellow Banana as part of a roughly $26 million deal to buy and renovate six stores in the South and West Sides.
So, you got 26 million to buy and renovate six stores in the South and West Sides, and they go out of business inside of 2 years. Mom Donny’s going to spend 70 on five. And he’s only going to discount a core basket of goods. I have a bridge in the desert to sell you. Here’s the stores. They’re on the South Side and West Side, which we know are Those are in real estate we call those affordable neighborhoods. They’re tougher areas. Let’s be honest. They’re tougher areas. Higher concentration of uh black population. Simply put. And so, for these to be closing down in these communities is it’s not good cuz you are leaving these folks without the ability to buy groceries, you know, at a normal grocery store.
Save-A-Lot and Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson are blaming the closures on federal funding cuts and changes to programs like SNAP benefits, which doesn’t make any sense because SNAP the changes in the SNAP benefits have just recently happened, the big beautiful bill, and these stores have been in business XYZ. It hasn’t been long enough for these to have an impact. I heard the federal government had a little hand in this particular one. Blame orange man bad, right? Blame Trump. Everything’s his fault. But, there’s no way. There is no way that is the case. These stores were all being robbed blind.
They had about a a bunch of whacked-out nut jobs in them. And basically, management said, “We’re not making money. You got all this stuff going on. We know we’re creating a food desert, but we were here because other stores couldn’t make a go of it. We were subsidized, but this isn’t going to work.” Closed. And and that’s what they did on Saturday. They literally just bam. Cuz you know what? The negative press from staying open and how much money they lost that the taxpayers would have had to basically admit to would have been horrific enough where the pushback was worse than closing the stores.
So, 2 days ago, on Saturday, they closed these seven stores. Just bam. Done. Gone. Gone. But, here we’ve got J.B. Pritzker, a billionaire, talking about, “I put an initiative in several years ago called the Illinois grocery initiative, and what it does is literally help people start grocery stores.” What about an initiative to keep people from stealing from them and have store security such that there’s very little shoplifting. What about that? What about an initiative for that? Cuz it doesn’t seem like they have a problem opening the grocery stores. It seems like they have a problem keeping them open.
And that’s what Mom Donny’s deal will be. Mom Donny’s deal will be so one-sided that it just won’t make any sense whatsoever. Let’s keep going. Seven grocery stores for face possible closure this weekend. City officials say their priorities is for the stores to remain open. Always is, but that’s not the case. So, SNAP cuts. Yet a ribbon’s cutting and grand opening reopening ceremony took place after the city gave Yellow Banana 13 and 1/2 million. And then they just they biffed it. They couldn’t make it go of it. Just no go. Sad. But, you know what? This is what happens when you’re running a business in an area that doesn’t take public safety you know, allow shoplifting to happen because on top of that, even grocery stores in areas stores and restaurants in areas that don’t have these factors, shoplifting and safety issues, they’re having a tough time making it go of it because everything has gotten so expensive.
All their costs have gone through the roof. So, you add that to, you know, extensive shoplifting and extensive safety issues. It’s not hard to call which stores close. The ones bleeding out, those get closed. This will become a food desert. Finding grocery stores in this neighborhood is already hard as it is. Okay. I I think there’s enough people that recognize, “Hey, you can’t rob the store blind and expect it to stay open.” There’s enough people that recognize that. But, what do you do? This has been a way of life for for criminals, especially drug criminals, to basically get a little bit of money to get their next fix.
So, what are you going to do? Yeah. Interesting, right? We keep going here. Tips and hot links, seven Save-A-Lots closed. Cuz the big story was, will the government step in? And the answer was, no, the government will not step in. And they didn’t. They just They just let them let them go. Let them go. And I think that’s I think that’s what happens with our mom-and-pop store. Hey, we had a good run. We tried real hard. We had some cheap stuff. We made eggs cheap. We made, you know, loaf of white bread, which has virtually zero nutritional value. We made that cheaper. But, at the end of the day, >> [laughter] >> the stars were aligned against us, and orange man bad, he did it.
He closed the store down. And it essentially it’s because they they it didn’t have a business model that made sense, because there’s no incentive to run the store efficiently and make a profit. So, unless you’re doing that, I don’t see the point. Cuz this whole subsidy thing, you’re making people think cuz without that incentive to keep things as dialed in as humanly possible, there’s no way a store that runs on super tiny margins, which all grocery stores do, a few percent, can make it and have it make sense, and, you know, be a poster child for the taxpayers. Hey, we’re using your money responsibly.
Instead, it’s going to be, well, we only lost $45 million in quarter three, but that’s good because we lost $55 million in quarter two. Things are looking up. Right? And they just continually bleed out money. Until taxpayers get upset enough and they’re like, “Shut that bastard down, because this is stupid. This is a stupid use of our money.” And that’s when we go to as critics rail plan is destined for failure, because it’s never worked elsewhere. Why would it work in New York City? It won’t. It won’t. And I’ll podcast it when it shuts down. Oh, it’s going to be great. It’s going to be a glorious day, right?
Glorious day. Make sure you subscribe to that notification bell. I’ll see you in the next episode. Thank you for joining. Catch up then. Bye for now. >> [music] [music]
Up next

Mamdani Grocery Stores Lawsuit: Immigrant Grocers Sue NYC
Watch next
Washington State
NYC Bond Downgrade Fears Rise as Mamdani Spending Grows

New York City
Manhattan Rent Record High Follows the NYC Rent Freeze

Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.