Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

New York City

NYC Socialist Mayor Mandani Sparks Bodega Owner Revolt: ‘We’re Becoming Communist State’

Share:

nyc socialist mayor mandani sparks bodega owner revolt we re becoming communist state

Content Warning: This post contains strong political opinions and criticism of progressive policies.

So here we are folks. New York City just elected themselves a Democratic Socialist, and the bodega owners who got name-dropped in his victory speech? Yeah, they’re not exactly throwing a parade. In fact, one of them dropped this absolute gem: “We are on the way to becoming a communist state. The government seizes the means of production, right? What could possibly go wrong?”

And honestly? The memes practically write themselves at this point.

The Socialist Agenda That Has Small Business Owners Running Scared

Let’s break down what NYC’s new socialist mayor Zoran Mandani is actually proposing, because this stuff reads like a progressive’s fever dream:

Free weekly email

The Friday Reasonable Brief

A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.

Subscription Form

We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.

  • $30 minimum wage by 2030 (nearly doubling from $16.50)
  • City-run grocery stores (because government-operated businesses always work out great, right?)
  • Rent freeze (what could possibly go wrong?)
  • Free city buses (taxpayers love footing the bill)
  • Free childcare (again, who’s paying for this exactly?)

Now, I’m not saying Andrew Cuomo was the be-all and end-all, especially with those 21 women accusing him of various inappropriate behavior. But seriously, this was the alternative New Yorkers went with?

Bodega Owners React to Communist-Style Economic Policies

While Mandani’s socialist platform might have gotten applause (okay, maybe golf claps) during his acceptance speech when he name-checked Yemen bodega owners, the actual store owners are less than thrilled about being part of his “multi-ethnic working-class coalition.”

“That’s not a good thing,” one shop owner told the Daily Wire when asked about the state-run grocery store plan. And why would it be? We’ve literally seen this movie before.

These NYC business owners are rightfully frustrated. They’re paying property taxes, rent, dealing with rising costs across the board, and now they’re supposed to compete with government-operated stores that don’t have those same expenses? Make that make sense.

The $30 Minimum Wage Plan: Seattle’s Expensive Lesson

Here’s where things get really interesting. Mandani’s “30 by 30” plan wants to jump the NYC minimum wage from $16.50 to $30 per hour by 2030. Currently, the city raises it by 50 cents annually. Under this plan, it would jump by $3.50 each year.

We’ve seen this play out in Seattle, folks. When you make DoorDash and Uber Eats the most expensive delivery services in the United States, guess what happens to demand? It shrinks. People don’t want to pay those prices.

“Think of how many places family-owned that will have difficulty making payroll because you’ve doubled your payroll overnight,” said one flower shop owner. “Half of the mom and pop shops will go out of business.”

And honestly? That gives me more podcast material, because I’ll be covering every single store closure due to this progressive economic ideology.

Government Grocery Stores: A Recipe for Taxpayer Disaster

Let’s talk about those city-operated grocery stores. Mandani wants to launch five stores, one in each borough, as part of his platform to lower costs. Dr. Anne Rathbone Bradley, economics professor and VP of academic affairs at the Fund for American Studies, had some thoughts:

“Sounds very good on paper, free always does,” she explained. “The problem is believing that the economy is an engineering project, that we put smart, well-intentioned people in charge of that project.”

Here’s the kicker – we’ve already seen how this ends. Similar programs in Kansas City, Missouri, and Florida collapsed despite millions in taxpayer funding. The Kansas City store closed its doors in August after struggling with empty shelves and crime.

But hey, let’s give it another whirl, right? What’s the worst that could happen?

The Great NYC Exodus: Why People Are Fleeing Progressive Policies

Here’s what’s really happening: New York residents are moving out in droves. They’re heading to Texas, Florida, the Carolinas – basically anywhere that’s cheaper and doesn’t implement these failed socialist policies.

You know why? Because these policies don’t work. They never have, they never will. But every 20 years or so, somebody decides to dust off the old socialist playbook and convince people “this time will be different.”

Texas Governor Greg Abbott was half-joking, half-serious when he said he wanted to put a 100% tariff on people from New York City coming to Texas. His point? “You’ve been voting for crappy policy makers who have made New York City crappy. Don’t come to Texas and make crappy decisions here too.”

The Billionaire Backlash and Business Reality

Even NYC billionaire John Catsimatidis is raging over Mandani’s win. The owner of Red Apple Group (which operates multiple grocery chains, media, real estate, and fossil fuel businesses) doesn’t mince words about what this means for the city.

“New York can’t afford to lose more people and that’s exactly what will happen,” he said. People will move out because they won’t be able to afford it and their quality of life will tank.

He’s particularly concerned about Mandani’s plans to cut the police force and his judicial appointments. Because nothing says “safe business environment” like fewer cops and progressive judges, right?

What This Means for Your Wallet and NYC’s Future

So what’s realistic here? Let’s break it down:

Rent freeze: Maybe doable politically, but economically? This will devastate landlords and reduce housing supply even further.

Free buses: Where’s the money coming from when the city already has massive budget deficits? The $2.90 bus fare makes up about 40% of transit authority revenue.

$30 minimum wage: This will force prices to rise across the board and push more businesses out of the city.

The reality is simple: when you keep raising taxes and pushing progressive ideology on businesses, those businesses do one thing – they leave. They move to places where they can actually operate profitably and hire people.

That’s how economics works, folks. Businesses hire people, people have jobs, people can afford stuff. Take away the incentive for businesses to operate, and the whole system collapses.

The Cycle Continues: Failed Policies, Predictable Results

Look, I realize more and more that this is just a cycle. Every generation or so, someone dusts off these socialist economic policies and convinces people they’re the solution to expensive living costs and inequality.

Then reality hits. The policies fail. Businesses close. People move away. Tax revenue drops. Services get cut. And we’re back to square one, except now with more debt and fewer opportunities.

The sad part? It’s the people in the city who made these decisions. They had a choice and they chose this path. Now they’ll pay for it – literally.

I don’t think Mandani will be able to get the majority of his proposals through. They’ll get held up ten ways from Sunday. But honestly? I hope I’m wrong, because the more of this ridiculous progressive ideology he pushes through, the more podcast material I’ll have.

What do you think about NYC’s sharp left turn? Have you seen similar policies fail in your city? Drop your thoughts in the comments below – I read every single one and love hearing your real-world experiences with these economic experiments.

Make sure you’re subscribed and hit that notification bell, because this is just the beginning of what’s going to be a very entertaining few years in New York City politics.

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

Reasonable+ members-only story

“I’m Muslim” Saved Him From Russian Woman’s NYC Syringe Attack On Jews

Read next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.