Oklahoma Senior Property Tax Cut vs. Newsom Tax Hikes
Red states are racing to wipe out property taxes for seniors while blue states hunt for more revenue.
Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.
The Oklahoma senior property tax fight comes down to one thing: red states with money in the bank are cutting taxes on retirees, while blue states drowning in spending keep reaching deeper into homeowners’ pockets. Oklahoma’s plan would zero out property taxes for anyone over 65 who owns their home free and clear.
Key Takeaways
- Oklahoma’s HJR 1081 would strip the income test from the state’s senior property-tax freeze, opening it to any homeowner 65 or older who holds clear title.
- At least three states are moving on this: North Dakota voters will weigh a full repeal, and Florida introduced a resolution to end non-school property taxes on homesteads.
- The delta between Bellevue, Washington and Oklahoma City runs about 140%, with Bellevue’s median home near $1.8 million.
- California’s Attorney General Javier Becerra wants to end a long-standing tax break, with Gavin Newsom backing him up.
What is the Oklahoma senior property tax plan?
Oklahoma’s House advanced HJR 1081 to expand property-tax relief for seniors by removing the income requirement from the existing freeze program. Under current law, seniors have to meet an income threshold to qualify for a freeze on their property tax. This bill strips that test entirely.
The practical effect is simple: a retiree sitting on a fully paid-off house owes no property tax, regardless of pension income, investment returns, or other earnings. The benefit opens to any homeowner age 65 or older who holds clear title to their home.
A senior property-tax exemption is a rule that removes the recurring tax bill on an owner-occupied home for qualifying older residents, turning a home into a cost you own outright rather than one you keep renting from the county.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
Why would this drive retirees to Oklahoma?
Because you remove the cost, and people follow the savings. When you can eliminate your largest recurring housing cost simply by living somewhere, that state becomes a more attractive destination for asset-rich retirees from higher-tax states.
Oklahoma’s median housing cost sits around $260,000 — the kind of number that looks mind-blowing next to a Bellevue median near $1.8 million. On top of that, Oklahoma is working to eliminate its roughly 4.5% income tax, funded by years of fiscally conservative budgeting that let the state park a few hundred million into a fund that generates comparable revenue.
The comparison is stark, and it echoes the split laid out in Texas versus Washington tax policy. Remove the tax, and a retiree can keep a cheap home base in Oklahoma and travel wherever they want.
What are the trade-offs of living in Oklahoma?
The savings are real, but so are the headaches. You pay cash for the house, but you had better carry property insurance, because high winds can tear a roof off every few years.
Then there is the ground itself. Oklahoma’s red clay expands and contracts so much that foundations crack — one home in a nice Oklahoma City neighborhood had a crack running straight down the brick. That is a slab-jack problem, sometimes a demolition problem. These are the real costs that come with the cheap sticker price.
Remove the cost, ditch those pesky taxes, and people follow the savings.
Oklahoma is not acting alone
Several states are moving at once, each with a different mechanism. South Dakota’s proposed 2026 constitutional amendment would repeal the state’s property-tax scheme entirely and replace it with a retail transaction tax — a wholesale swap of one revenue stream for another, applied to all property owners.
Florida’s joint resolution would eliminate non-school property taxes on homesteads while preserving the portion dedicated to public schools. North Dakota voters will weigh a constitutional amendment to repeal their entire property-tax system. Oklahoma targets a specific demographic, South Dakota goes wholesale, and Florida carves out school funding.
Why can red states afford this and blue states can’t?
They can float these proposals because they have the money to do it. They don’t carry the massive budget deficits that a state like Washington does — and Washington’s problem isn’t revenue, it’s a spending problem. Whatever it collects, it needs more.
Blue states are on the opposite track. California is losing millionaires and leaning on progressive revenue, taxing the wealthy and businesses. Illinois and Chicago keep piling on because their downtown cores are worth a fraction of what they once were, so they still have to fund generous welfare programs off their own constituents — the same dynamic behind the Chicago property tax increase.
Where does California fit in?
California is already where Washington is headed. The far-left Attorney General Javier Becerra wants to get rid of a long-standing tax break, and Gavin Newsom is backing him up. If he succeeds and the rest of these taxes pass, there is very little incentive for hard-working Californians to stay.
California still runs on the raw power of a massive economy — millions of people and businesses keeping it going. But it carries high poverty, high inflation, the highest gas prices, and high utility costs. Newsom, meanwhile, keeps surfacing as a 2028 name, the same figure at the center of California’s Palisades fire fallout.
What could go wrong with wiping out property taxes?
The revenue consequences are uncertain, and none of these plans came with a detailed replacement model. Oklahoma’s local governments rely heavily on property taxes to fund county operations and public safety. Exempting a growing share of owner-occupied housing could compress the base and shift the burden onto businesses, rentals, and younger homeowners.
Supporters are betting that population growth — steady and consistent in Oklahoma — keeps the money flowing. The common thread is a political bet that voters reward lawmakers who cut property taxes, even when the revenue math is unsettled.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Oklahoma plan help seniors who still owe on their homes?
The bill is built around homeowners who hold clear title, so a retiree with a paid-off house gets the full benefit. It is hard to say how a senior still carrying a mortgage would be treated.
Which states currently have the lowest property taxes?
Measured as a percentage of income, the lowest are Alabama, Tennessee, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Louisiana. The highest are Maine, Vermont, New Jersey, New Hampshire, and New York.
Will any of these repeal measures actually pass?
At least one looks likely to get through. Whether they advance depends on how voters weigh immediate relief against the long-term trade-offs to local budgets.
If your state zeroed out property taxes on paid-off homes for seniors, would you stay put or start shopping for a cheaper home base? Tell me where you land in the comments.
Full Episode Transcript
Read the full transcript of this episode
Governor Ron DeSantis detailed a phased approach today to eliminate property taxes on primary homes within the state, a move that would make Florida the very first state to get rid of the taxes while also having no state income tax. >> While the legislature may make decisions about future property assessment limitations, it’s important to remember the current plans available that are saving Oklahoma county residents more than 600 million in lower property taxes every year, Stein said. >> Um, highest property taxes are in Maine, Vermont, [music] New Jersey, New Hampshire, and New York.
While the lowest property taxes as a percentage of income would be Alabama, Tennessee, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Louisiana. >> an ideologue. I’m open argument on both sides, but I’ll tell you I I brought this up in town halls large and small, and I had more Democrats, particularly seniors, screaming saying, “I love you. I love everything, but I barely can make my, you know, I’ve been never I I guys say you can’t do this. Understand my I’m on fixed income.” >> D. That puts her in a group excluded from the state’s new inflation relief program. >> I feel very cheated and let down and I >> 40 years, but now the far left Attorney General Javier Becerra wants to get rid of it, and Gavin Newsom is backing him up.
If he’s successful and the rest of these taxes pass, there’s very little incentive for hard-working Californians to remain in the state. >> [music] >> Because the city that you currently live in is no longer conducive to retiree income, retiree budgeting. This is a good This is an interesting one. States are racing to wipe out homeowner property taxes, and Oklahoma’s plan would end them for anyone over 65 who own If you have no debt on your home, they’re going to basically say, “Poof.” “No taxes for you.” Does that make sense? Let’s get into it. Here we go. When I read this, I immediately thought of well, that’s going to drive some people to retire in Oklahoma.
Because now you’ve got yet another incentive. Oklahoma’s working on eliminating their what 4 and 1/2% income tax cuz they’ve got enough money that they’ve driven in from being fiscally conservative where they can put a few hundred million into a fund and base essentially generate the amount of money that we’re getting from taxing all the residents of Oklahoma City with And here, this one is interesting because anyone over 65 who owns a home outright. And you know what? A home outright in Oklahoma. Median housing cost is like two 260? Something like that. I mean, it is it’s it’s mind-blowing. You got to live there, though.
But budgetary concerns are yours and you might be thinking, well, you continually see Oklahoma coming up on, you know, not the primary places people as of its affordability and it’s one of the factors I’m going there. Older homeowners in Oklahoma who have paid off their mortgages could soon a proposal the state house advanced earlier this year. Measure is one of at least three active efforts across the country to sharply reduce or abolish property taxes. North Dakota voters will weigh a constitutional amendment repeal their entire property tax system. Florida introduced a joint resolution targeting non-school property taxes on homesteads.
Boom, gone. Together, these proposals signal a growing willingness among state lawmakers to dismantle a tax that has funded local governments for more than a century. And you know why they can do that? Why they can throw out these proposals? Because they have the money to do it. They don’t have massive budget deficits like my state, Washington. It It’s got it every little entity that is out there has a massive massive budget deficit. And it’s not because they don’t have, you know, billions of dollars of revenue. Lord knows they do. We just got a massive spending problem here in Washington state.
So, whatever they’re getting, they need more. They need more. And you know, once you’ve enacted a millionaire tax and you’ve enacted a tax on everybody, and then you’re taxing everybody 10 ways from Sunday, one thing you have left at the end of the day is taxing the absolute bejesus out of people’s primary res- That’s where Washington state is headed. California is already there. And now you’re looking at you’re looking at the polar opposite of that, which is, “Hey, you own your house free and clear. We’re not going to No No taxes for you.” Now, what about a senior citizen that, you know, doesn’t own their home free and clear?
Do they get taxed a percentage of what they owe? It’s hard to say. Oklahoma House advanced HJR 1081 to expand property relief tax relief for seniors by removing the income requirement from the existing property tax freeze program. Under current law, seniors must meet an income threshold to qualify for a freeze on the property tax. This bill would strip that test entirely, opening the benefit to any homeowner age 65 or older holds clear title to their home. Practical effect, a retiree sitting on a fully paid off house with no property tax obligation, regardless of pension income, investment returns, or other earnings.
No property taxes. Oh. Cuz you’ve got an insurance. They cash for a house in Oklahoma, you’re going to want to have some property insurance cuz that that little tornado might touch down. No, it’s more like high wind and it’ll tear your roof off. Yeah, every few years put a new roof on your house. That kind of stuff, weather stuff, right? Just absolutely brutal on your home. Oklahoma, that’s one of those trade-offs, right? You pay cash, but hey, hey, you got to pay a bunch. But if you didn’t have that other pesky component of tax, you know, that that that’s going to drive a bunch of people there, no matter what.
It just is. If this thing goes through, shift could reshape where retirees choose to settle. Yeah, it’s not exactly Florida, but it’s cheap, right? It’s cheap. You you save it in taxes, you go to Florida a couple times a year, go hang out at the Uh with if seniors with value higher value homes can eliminate their largest reoccurring housing cost simply by living in Oklahoma, the state becomes a more attractive destination for asset-rich retirees from higher tax states. Not saying that’s going to happen, but people will consider it. Oh yeah, what about Oklahoma? You don’t have to pay any taxes.
Bring in clear house, no taxes. County deed offices and homestead exemption filings would be the first place to spot that movement, likely within two or three years of any change taking effect. Sorry. >> What? >> Remove the cost, ditch those pesky taxes, and people follow the savings. Mhm. Makes a lot of sense, doesn’t it? If you’re a retiree, may maybe you don’t even you know, maybe you’ve just got the house in Oklahoma, and you know, you use that as home base, and you go wherever you want cuz you’re not paying any taxes. I mean, that is that’s a big savings. If you’re on fixed income, that is a big savings.
It It’s It’s one of many you would have there. Um I ran the numbers, sorry about the Mickey Mousing around with the screen there. I ran the numbers and my delta between living here in Bellevue, Washington and moving to Oklahoma City it’s it’s like 140% when you consider the cost of housing being here mass massive massive differential between median housing price in Oklahoma Oklahoma City versus Bellevue, Washington. Bellevue, Washington median housing price of 1.8 mil. You know what I mean? And then you get down to bare bones and no taxes. People are going to go, “Well, we’ll figure out a way to make this work.” Supporters frame the change as a way to help residents stay in their homes as they age, especially as fixed incomes lag behind rising insurance premiums.
Yeah, no kidding. And maintenance costs. You know, the slab foundations in Oklahoma, tricky. That You get that dirt clay. You get that dirt rock going on, right? It’s red. It’s red soil. Red clay. And it moves. And it expands and contracts so greatly that your foundations You got a foundation problem? Yeah. You got a problem. Don’t see that as much here in the Pacific Northwest and a lot of other markets. Different different soil base, right? But if you got a foundation problem there, I looked at a home in really nice neighborhood in Oklahoma City. And he had a crack down the brick that was, you know, that big.
Just right there. Right there. So, you got to get out there slab jack. Now, you probably demo that home, but there’s a lot of homes that, you know, have had problems. People put them back together. They figure it out. Because the proposal focuses on tax bills rather than housing prices, it does not directly address affordability pressures for younger buyers or long-term renters. You know what? It doesn’t need to because it’s already affordable there. It’s already wildly affordable there. They don’t even realize how affordable it is. Come come up to You’ll see some absolute stuff that makes no sense at all.
None whatsoever. Going to pay what for what for what? Oklahoma’s not acting alone. South Dakota Attorney General issued a final ballot explanation for a proposed 2026 initiated constitutional amendment that would repeal the state’s property tax scheme of the call it scheme and replace it with a retail transaction tax. Unlike Oklahoma’s age-targeted approach, South Dakota’s proposal would apply to all property owners, effectively swapping one revenue stream for another. Ballot language makes clear that the amendment would eliminate property taxes statewide, not merely freeze or cap them. Meanwhile, what Losing millionaires.
They’re going to have to raise tax. You’ve got this real pendulum swinging hard cuz it’s become so expensive to live in the Pacific Northwest and the East Coast and, you know, basically the coasts in general. Right? Florida Right resolution. Elimination of non-school property tax for homesteads. Measure would preserve the portion of property taxes dedicated to public schools while getting rid of the remainder for owner-occupied homes. The distinction matters. Florida would still collect school-related levies, but county municipal taxes on homesteads would dis- Voters approved the constitutional change.
Again, they can do that. They have got population growth. Got incoming tax dollars. These other states, Illinois? No. All right. Piling on the taxes because they have to tax the constituents cuz all the buildings in their downtown cores are no longer worth a fraction of what they once were. So, you still got to run all their generous welfare programs, right? Like hundreds of millions of dollars to the criminal illegal It’s going to come from their own constituents. Meanwhile, meanwhile, you got these states, Republican-run states, doing a little different song and dance. So, each state, different mechanism.
Oklahoma targets specific demographics. South Dakota, wholesale replacement. Florida carves out school funding. We still got to pay for that and everything else for homesteaders. Common thread is a political bet that voters will reward lawmakers who cut or end property taxes, even when the revenue consequences are uncertain. So, one of the things with the income tax in Oklahoma was the fact that you are replacing You put a put a put Say you put a billion dollars, couple hundred million, whatever it is, 5% return out of that. Well, not really knowing what those investment returns are actually going to look like, you know what your revenue stream, your tax stream is going to look like from taxing your constituents 1 1/2% of their gross income, right?
You You know roughly what that’ll look like. You know what that income stream would look like. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you know, it’s You can kind of dial that in, but it’s not as much a sure thing as taxing your constituents. Oh, there there’s a little bit of that, and that’s that’s what we’re basically saying here. Now, the new three proposals come with a published fiscal impact analysis or detailed revenue replacement model. Oklahoma local governments rely heavily on property taxes to fund county operations, public safety, and other basic services. Exempting a growing share of owner-occupied housing from tax rolls could compress the base and shift more of the burden onto businesses, rental properties, and younger homeowners.
Unless lawmakers backfill the loss with state aid or new revenue sources. Yeah, how you going to make up the difference? Well, they are betting on the fact that more people are going to move there, population growth, keep funding it, and they’ve got a solid not a huge population growth consistent. It’s consistent. So, they’re not worried about people moving out because where they going to go that’s cheaper? Where they going to go? If affordability is your thing, then Arkansas? Maybe. Alabama? Maybe. Georgia? Maybe. Ohio? Maybe. Florida’s homestead focused exemption would leave school millages intact, but could punch sizable holes in county municipal budgets.
They’ll work out all the details, and none of these things are in stone, right? What’s interesting is that these are being considered in red states. Meanwhile, the blue states would need more progressive tax revenue, meaning they’re going to tax wealthy people and businesses. Renewed push to pare back property taxes reflects deeper anxieties about housing costs and inflation caused by rising assessments, but see little growth in retirement income. Yeah, and if you didn’t have to pay for property taxes, ooh. Hey. It’s Whether these measures advance will depend on how voters weigh immediate relief against long-term trade-offs.
I bet you one of them gets through. Don’t you think? Let’s see how this does. Supporters in all three states are likely to emphasize stability for homeowners and protection against being taxed out long-held properties. That’s what you’re you’re looking at doing, keeping in the old people in their homes, right? Keeping the old people. And that’s me in 7 years. 8 years. Old. Opponents will focus on the potential erosion of local control and the risk that shifting away from property taxes could destabilize public systems, public safety, and infrastructure funding. Oh. It’s just a lot of words, isn’t it?
And then I think you’re going to have study after study on the other one. I you know, when you look at what the red states have done, when you look at what Texas has done, when you look at what Florida has done, as far as putting all the right you know, incentives for people to come into those and your population your population change is dramatic. And that’s why you’ve got such revenue streams coming in that the big blue states do not. California’s just got a massive massive economy. That’s what it’s got going for it. It’s got literally, you know, millions and millions and millions of people running millions of businesses and it’s just got that that that power stroke that just keeps going.
And you’re beating that one down with the billionaires’ tax and with all the other taxes and the over regulation. But at the end of the day, California still keeps keeps going. For now. Not well. High levels of poverty, levels of inflation, highest gas prices, high utility costs. I mean, the list just keeps going on. But hey, you know, vote for Gavin Newsom cuz he’s he’s definitely running in 2028. We just keep hearing little bits and pieces about Gavin Newsom versus Kamala Harris. And how do we get those two? That’s just terrible. Terrible. But Oklahoma, Florida, what have we got? South Dakota?
Yeah, South Dakota’s our other option. A little bit redder. Might be an option. Love to have you subscribe, hit that notification bell. I’ll see you in the next >> [music] >> Hey, hey, hey. Hey, hey. >> [music] >> Hey, hey. Hey, hey. Hey, hey.
Up next

Starbucks Seattle Layoffs: WARN Notice Cuts 135 Jobs
Watch next
Crime and public safety
Minneapolis Property Tax Hike: Frey’s 11.3% Budget Plan


Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.