Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

California

Paramount Warner Merger: Newsom Pressures Bonta to Settle

California's governor wants his own attorney general to stand down on a $111 billion merger.

Share:

Paramount Warner Merger: Newsom Pressures Bonta to Settle

Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.

Prefer audio? Listen to the podcast version:

Gavin Newsom is leaning on his own attorney general to stand down. The Paramount Warner merger lawsuit is not really about consumers or competition, it is about what thousands of Hollywood job losses would look like on the eve of a 2028 presidential run.

Key Takeaways

  • Rob Bonta is leading 12 Democrat-led states suing to block Paramount Skydance’s $111 billion acquisition of Warner Bros. Discovery.
  • Bonta asked a judge to halt the merger for 14 days pending a preliminary injunction, and he got it.
  • The Wall Street Journal reports Newsom’s office has encouraged Bonta’s office to find a resolution out of court.
  • If the deal does not close by September 30, Paramount owes Warner shareholders roughly $650 million per quarter.

What Newsom Is Asking Bonta to Do

Settle. That is the ask. Newsom’s office has reportedly encouraged the attorney general’s office, which has independent authority to file suits, to find a resolution out of court and end the lawsuit.

A ticking fee is a penalty a buyer owes the seller’s shareholders for every period a signed deal stays unclosed. Paramount’s runs about $650 million for every quarter the deal is not done past September 30, which is why every week of litigation costs real money and why the pressure to settle is not abstract.

Newsom’s stated worry, per the Wall Street Journal, is that if Paramount is stymied by Bonta’s lawsuit, Warner Bros. will shed thousands of jobs or shut down altogether. A massive loss of jobs just before the 2028 election would look very bad for a governor angling for the Democratic nomination. Notice what is absent from that reasoning: any mention of consumers at all.

Free weekly email

The Friday Reasonable Brief

A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.

Subscription Form

We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.

Why Is the Paramount Warner Merger Being Blocked?

Because Bonta built an antitrust case and eleven other states signed on. California, Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon and Washington are all in on the suit. It is the biggest single move to halt the merger, with smaller suits from the Writers Guild of America and others running alongside it.

Bonta’s position is that there is no debate here, that the merger will snuff out competition, drive up prices, diminish content quality and produce fewer movies and shows each year. He went into court, made his case, asked the judge to halt the merger for 14 days while a preliminary injunction is considered, and secured it. Paramount then agreed to temporarily pause the merger while the lawsuit works its way through.

There is no debate here. This merger will snuff out competition.

Three Marvel superhero film actors joined the opposition, arguing the merger means fewer films, canceled productions and a tendency to avoid taking on risky projects. Paramount took issue with Bonta’s comments, arguing some of the concessions he cited are irrelevant to the multi-state lawsuit.

The Rest of the World Already Said Yes

This is the part that undercuts the whole case. Both the United States Department of Justice and Europe green-lit this deal. Britain cleared it too, with regulators saying the deal does not raise competition concerns in the UK and that the evidence shows Paramount will continue to face sufficient competition in the various areas it operates in after the merger.

So the DOJ passed. Europe passed. Britain passed. And a coalition of blue-state attorneys general has decided it knows better than all of them. When that many regulators clear a transaction and every holdout comes from the same political column, the antitrust argument starts looking less like law and more like a press strategy.

Ellison’s Argument: Hollywood Already Changed

Paramount Skydance chief executive David Ellison broke his silence in a New York Times op-ed, and his argument is that the opposition relies on a vision of Hollywood that no longer exists.

His numbers are the interesting part. A merged Paramount and Warner would account for less than 20% of television watch time, dropping to around 13% once you account for YouTube. That is the real competitive landscape: Netflix, Amazon and Apple, tech giants whose resources dwarf his. He also pointed to commitments to expand traditional production, promising 30 theatrical films and 170 television series.

Whether or not you buy Ellison’s framing, the underlying shift is real. Hollywood has changed dramatically and much of the work moved away from California because it is cheaper and makes more sense somewhere else. Half the time a film goes straight to a streaming platform and never sees a theater. Newsom himself has been touting a film and TV tax credit he says is projected to generate $6.6 billion in California production spending, which is a quiet admission that the work left and now has to be bought back.

Is the Consumer Really Losing Choice Here?

That is the claim in the lawsuit, and it is the weakest part of it. The complaint says consumers will get fewer movies and shows each year and pay more for the privilege. Then look at what is actually on offer. There is a mountain of content on YouTube. There is Netflix, Amazon Prime, Apple. The subscriptions stack up until you cannot find the one game you want to watch without hunting through four apps.

Fewer films is being described as a catastrophe. From where I sit, there is so much out there already that you cannot tell which of it is any good, and I find myself going back to reruns. If consolidation means a few fewer forgettable movies get made, that is not obviously a loss for the viewer. The people with a genuine stake are the ones who work on films and could be let go as the companies consolidate, and that is a real concern. It is just not an antitrust concern.

Does an Attorney General Work for the Governor?

No, and that is the problem sitting underneath this whole story. California’s attorney general has independent authority to file suits. He is elected to do that job, not to clear it with the governor’s political operation.

Which is why the box is so tight. If Bonta folds because Sacramento told him to, what does he tell the other eleven attorneys general who signed on with him? They joined a coalition, not a campaign. Backing out because a governor’s 2028 math changed is not an argument anyone can put in a filing.

It fits a pattern that keeps showing up around Newsom’s 2028 ambitions: positions that shift the moment they threaten the national run.

What This Says About California’s Economy

Notice what Newsom is actually conceding. He is not arguing the merger is good for consumers or that Bonta’s case is legally weak. He is arguing California cannot absorb the job losses. That is a governor admitting his state’s economy is too fragile to take a hit from a single corporate transaction.

Hollywood moved away from California because it got cheaper and easier to work somewhere else, and the entertainment business itself moved onto platforms that did not exist twenty years ago. The tax credit is the patch. The lawsuit is the politics. Underneath both sits the same condition driving California’s job losses and the wider business exodus from the state. High costs, heavy regulation, and companies running the numbers and deciding they work better elsewhere.

Do I think Bonta backs down? Not really. He has eleven other states standing behind him and a 12-day trial ahead, and folding on a governor’s orders would be the end of him. But it is going to be interesting to watch what arguments survive contact with a courtroom.

Frequently Asked Questions

How big is the Paramount Warner Bros. deal?

Roughly $111 billion for Paramount Skydance to acquire Warner Bros. Discovery. British regulators cleared it under a reported $110 billion figure.

Which states are suing to block the merger?

California, Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon and Washington, twelve in all, led by California’s Rob Bonta.

What happens if the merger does not close by September 30?

Paramount would owe Warner Bros. shareholders a ticking fee amounting to about $650 million for every quarter the deal remains unfinished.

So does Bonta hold the line, or does he find a way to settle and give his governor the headline he wants? Tell me how you think this one ends in the comments.

Full Episode Transcript

Read the full transcript of this episode

Block the merger. [singing] [applause] >> We know that this deal sucks. >> And the same here in this Paramount Warner Brothers merger where we went into court. We made our case. We have a a clean, concise, straightforward, and powerful case. And we asked the judge to halt their merger for 14 days while they consider a preliminary injunction. And we secured it. And so it’s working the way we hoped it would work. It’s working the way it should work. We’ve >> 12 Democratic le states have sued to block Paramount Sky Dances 111 billion dollar acquisition of Warner Brothers Discovery.

>> People who are employed at movie theaters and all the things that relate to that because this is going to definitely reduce the number of films made. No matter what they say, they’re going to reduce the number of films. They’re going to let people go as they consolidate. the people who work on films are going to be out of business. >> So, we’re here because we want to welcome A.G. Bonta to the courthouse to do the job he was elected to do. Governor Gavin Newsome recently touted his film and TV tax credit, which he says is helping bring Hollywood home. He said it’s [music] projected to generate $6.6 billion in California production spending.

What’s your reaction to that? >> Paramount took issues with Bont’s comments, arguing that some of the concessions are irrelevant to the multi-state lawsuit. It remains to be seen whether Paramount and Warner Brothers can survive the slew of lawsuits and close the merger by September 30th. If they can’t, Paramount will have to pay Warner Brothers shareholders a ticking fee that would amount to about $650 million for every quarter the deal isn’t done. >> [music] >> Governor Gavin Newsome of California pressures his own attorney general Rob Bont to drop the lawsuit to stop the Paramount Warner Brothers merger.

got a 111 billion dollar merger going on in Hollywood because he’s afraid it would cause job losses in California in Hollywood and that would impact his ability to run for the president of the United States of America. Oh, let’s get into it. Here we go. I mean, nothing says nothing says I don’t care about Californians. I don’t care about worldwide consumers. I don’t care about consumers anywhere. But if this impacts my ability to become president of the United States, I’m out. Hey, hey, Rob, you you got you got to you got to solve this thing out of court. We can’t have this impacting my ability as [laughter] as as Brill Cream to become not, you know, elevate past governor of the state of California into the president of the United States.

That is literally all Gavin Newsome is worried about, right? He’s just worried about that. It’s so self- serving. It’s wild. The report says California’s Democrat Governor Gavin Newsome is worried over job loss in his state if the lawsuit filed by his own attorney general is successful at stopping the proposed merger between Paramount and Warner Brothers. And he has urged Rob Bont to settle out of court and end his lawsuit. How do you how how do you how do you settle? Do you take a do you take a lump sum payment? All right, let this bad boy continue. We’re going to take a lump sum payment. I mean, if this goes through and and I view this merger as just the inevitable of how Hollywood has gone, how entertainment has gone, how movies being made in California has gone away from California, they’ve gone to everywhere else because it’s more it’s cheaper and makes more sense.

And also, Hollywood doesn’t necessarily make the content anymore. You got a ton of content on YouTube. You got a ton of content here, there, and everywhere. Netflix, you know what I mean? Um, you’ve got Amazon with Prime. You know, this this is a merger somebody’s trying to make money on. All right. And Rob Bont, he he’s like, “Oh, no. It’s going to hurt the consumer. You’re what? You’re not going to get any more crappy movies? You’re going to get fewer crappy movies. I think that’s a win. You’re not going to have enough writers out there left anymore.” Uh, well, they’ll figure it out. Besides, AI is going to be writing all your movie scripts here soon, and they don’t about anything.

So, there’s that, right? Radical left-wing attorney Rob Bont. It’s the reason I’m reading this article. We’re reading from Breitbart, by the way. Radical left-wing attorney general Rob Bont leading a coalition of 12 deep blue states. Shocker that Washington, my state, is in there, right? in trying to stop the proposed merger, claiming the 111 billion dollar plan is detrimental to the entertainment industry and the freedom of choice of consumers. You know what? If these consumers want to consume the garbage that’s out there, that’s on them. I I I can barely find a movie anywhere I look now that I’m interested in watching.

You know what I mean? I I I find myself watching reruns of Clint Eastwood. It’s weird. >> [snorts] >> A new report by the Wall Street Journal says that Governor Nuome, who’s angling to run for Democrat nomination in 2028, is worried that if Paramount is stymied by Bont’s lawsuit, Warner Brothers will shed thousands of jobs or even completely shut down altogether. That’s that’s the crux of this. Warner Brothers is in play. Paramount buys them up. They merge. Yeah. And if that doesn’t happen, Nuome is like, “Oh, that’s not going to look good for me. That’s not going to that’s not going to be good for me.” The massive loss of jobs just before the 2028 election would look very bad for Newsome.

You know, as hard as Nuome tries, I don’t think he’s got a chance. I think AOC is the candidate. And I think that would be tremendous. I I I really do. I don’t even think I don’t think Colamla 0 for two Harris soon to be commla 0 for3 Harris is is going to be in there but you know what if she was let’s see her lose again consequently Newsome has reportedly asked Bont to change his track on the lawsuit journal reported Wall Street Journal reported Newsome’s office has encouraged Attorney General Rob Bont’s office which has independent authority to file suits to find a resolution out of report. What exactly would that be?

And then one minute they’re going from, “Oh, this is an antirust. The American public isn’t going to get their crappy movies to,” all right, we’re each going to get five bucks and make this go away. Something like that, right? Ridiculous. In his lawsuit, Bontto asserts there is no debate here. This merger will snuff out competition. Well, competition’s already being snuffed out, and a lot of it’s because of the policies of California. They’re going elsewhere, but we’re talking globally. Merger will snuff out competition. I say good. There’s so much competition out there. It’s crappy. The the the mo movies are just terrible.

They’re crappy. I’m just old man rant right now, right? It’ll drive up prices. What isn’t going up? Diminish content quality. What quality? There’s no quality. Unless you put Sydney Sweeney in there and then it’s just fire and produce fewer movies and shows each year. All right. Don’t we already have so many that we can’t really distinguish if any of them are good? So, California, Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, and Washington are all in on this lawsuit. Bont suit the biggest move to halt the merger. There’s other some smaller suits.

Writers guild of America despite the lawsuits. Both the US, United States Department of Justice and Europe green lit this bad boy. They’re like mostly passes. Don’t care. You know what I mean? You’re just like, fine. Still, Paramount agreed to temporarily pause the merger while Bons’s lawsuit makes its way through the courts. Three Marvel superhero film actors also recently. Okay. Do not care. I don’t know who they are. And if I hear Marvel superheroes, I just check out. I check out. I just The whole superheroes, that whole thing has just gotten so weird. Hollywood has gotten so weird. All the people in Hollywood are absolutely effed in the head.

There there’s a few that aren’t, but they’re such outcasts that they don’t even count anymore. You know what I mean? When’s the last time you saw James Woods in anything? Yeah. Not happening. Actors claim that the merger will result in fewer films. Okay. Cancel productions. All right. And a tendency to avoid taking on risky projects. They insist the decision over approving the deal. Since Since when has Rob Bont in the state of California been concerned about the risk on risky projects? Oh no. Oh my god. That’s a risky film to make. Maybe we Oh, we need to we need to intervene on behalf of the public and behalf of citizens of California.

Nah, it’s it’s just it’s it’s putting your nose in a deal that’s going to get you a lot of publicity. And if you win, oh, look at me. I’m Rob Bont. I am now running for in California. They insist that the decision over approving a deal will pro prove one of the most important decisions any culture secretary has taken for UK film, television, and media in a generation. H I haven’t really covered this one cuz honestly I don’t really care. Maybe I should care more. I don’t think so. You know, all this stuff is just swirling around us. It’s like, oh, what what network? I have I have so many subscriptions and I really need to get basic cable because when there’s a bunch of sports on, I can’t seem to work out how to find it.

You know what I mean? It’s like I I just want to watch this one game. I’m not a huge sports guy, but when there’s something on, I want to watch it. So, I find myself watching more UFC events than anything because I can always figure out where they are. Okay, it’s on Paramount Plus. All right, we’ll go there. That’s not that hard to find. So Paramount Warner Brothers staffers in limbo and denial as merger deal drags on. So we got a deal here where South Park is being screwed up because of this merger. Oh no, what’s going to happen? I do love a good South Park episode. I think South Park here we go.

Here we go. I think that is one of the funniest shows on television ever. They make fun of everybody relentlessly, mercilessly, and because it’s comedy, I I think it’s I mean, it it’s funny. It is funny. I don’t care what you say. I did I grew up on a lot of cartoons. Love cartoons. As an adult, not so much, but South Park. Oh, yeah. South Park. Uh, it’s good. It’s good. Here is Here is uh What happened here? No thanks. Yeah. Britain clears 110 billion dollar Paramount Warner Brothers merger. So you got one in the bag and then you’ve also got United States Department of Justice that basically said it’s a go boys.

It’s a go boys. We have cleared this deal as it does not raise competition concerns in the UK. The evidence shows that after the merger, Paramount will continue to face sufficient competition in the various areas it operates in. After this merger, I think they still only account for like 13% of the content being made. So, I don’t care. You know what I mean? Just all right, whatever. If I was if I was involved in Hollywood, I would just be pins and needles on this bad boy, right? Because it it it indicates kind of the direction things are going. But um you know what what is what is the financial situation of Warner Brothers?

Weren’t they the ones that had Woody Woodpecker? Times have changed. All right, here we go. David Ellison Paramount chief exe merger. Now, David Ellison put in place he put in place um I’m scrolling through here. The CBS uh individual who has kind of rocked uh CBS and I’m drawing a blank on that name, but you know what I’m talking about. I thought it was in this article. Um Barry Weiss. Barry Weiss and 60 Minutes. They rock 60 Minutes. Oh, you can’t play that episode. we need to, you know, you you’ve got some real you’ve got some real censorship taking place, but it’s because you’ve got a new owner and the new owner is like, “All right, we need to play this direction instead of this direction.” And you know, all the major networks and 60 Minutes has been such a propaganda, you know, driven type just dril.

It used to be you’d watch 60 Minutes. I did in high school, they’d bring in the they’d bring in the TV with the VCR. You’d watch an episode of 60 Minutes. Now the kids just have it, you know, on their phone sitting in class and now we’re concerned about not having phones in the class. Paramount Sky Dance Chief Executive David Ellison broken his silence and the $ 110 billion opposition to the mega merger relies on a vision of Hollywood that no longer exists. He wrote in an op-ed for the New York Times, “Hollywood has changed dramatically and it’s moved away from California and because of all the streaming stuff, half the time it goes straight to streaming platform, right?

doesn’t even hit the movie theaters anymore. I can’t tell you the last time. When is the last time? Oh, I saw the Led Zeppelin movie. I saw the Led Zeppelin movie. Um, that was a long two hours. I love Led Zeppelin. I I love, you know, classic rock history. I love the early age of heavy metal. If you want to consider Led Zeppelin heavy metal, I don’t. I consider it classic rock. But I did watch that movie. Was it fascinating? Yes, it was. I had a hard time sitting through 2 hours of it, though. I have a hard time sitting through two hours of anything now with with Yeah, I’ve done like 15 minutes.

I got the general gist of this one. I’m on to the next. I’m going to go look for a news story that I could, you know, broadcast to you like we’re doing right here. I’m more interested in that than all right, this is what they’re doing. And you got an hour and 15 minutes more. Public intervention comes as Warner Brothers and Paramount intense legal battle. Here we go. Allison pointed out that a merged Paramount Warner would account for less than 20% of television watch time, dropping to around 13 when accounting for YouTube. Man, YouTube is taking over. YouTube is taking over. So, as it competes against tech giants like Netflix, Amazon, and Apple, which I have subscriptions to all of those, whose resources dwarf ours.

Okay. All right. So, he also highlighted commitments to expand traditional production. Don’t care. 30 theatrical films and 170 television television series. Do we need 170 television series? The whole the whole thing is just like, what are we doing? There’s so much crap out there that you can’t you just you can’t you can’t you can’t keep up because it’s all it’s all just [sighs] so will Rob Bont back down? We’ll see, right? No, he’s not going to back down. This uh this lawsuit supposed to go on. I mean, what’s he going to tell the other state? Sorry, guys. My my governor told me got to do something else.

Now, the attorney generals are supposed to be able to work independently from the governor’s office, right? not be able supposed to, you know, take them the beat down. Gavin says, “You have to stop. You have to stop and get an outofc court settlement. Come to terms of agreement, Rob.” Something like that. Is that going to happen? I don’t think so. Because the other 11 states would be like, “Hey, wait a minute. What? I I thought we were all in on this together. I I thought we were brother, you know, comrades in arms. Stopping the patriarchy, stopping the proletariat. I don’t even know.” Right. All right.

That’s it for me on this one. Thanks so much for being here. We’ll continue doing this one cuz moving forward, this is going to get interesting. That 12-day trial. I mean, if you’re a business or Hollywood guy, that’s it. It’s it’s going to be interesting because the arguments they’re going to come up with are what? Talking about what? All I care about is South Park. Thanks so much for being here. We’ll catch up with you in the next episode. Bye for now.

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

Paramount CNN Merger Settlement Opens Door to Layoffs

Paramount CNN Merger Settlement Opens Door to Layoffs

Watch next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.