Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

Portland

Portland Police Mask Ban: Toothless Against Federal ICE

Portland's City Council banned law enforcement face masks 8-4.

Share:

Portland Police Mask Ban: Toothless Against Federal ICE

Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.

The Portland police mask ban is a law that can’t reach the people it was aimed at. By an 8-4 vote, the Portland City Council passed an ordinance barring local and federal law enforcement from wearing face coverings to hide their identity. The problem: the supremacy clause means the city has zero authority over federal ICE agents, and the police union already said it won’t force federal officers to unmask.

Key Takeaways

  • The Portland City Council passed the mask ban by an 8-4 vote.
  • The police union president said the city cannot require officers to break federal law by unmasking federal agents.
  • Similar bans in other deep-blue jurisdictions, including a California law, were defeated in the Ninth Circuit.
  • Democratic Mayor Keith Wilson urged the council to reject the ordinance.

What did Portland’s City Council actually pass?

An ordinance banning local and federal law enforcement from wearing face coverings to conceal their identity, along with visible-ID requirements. The Portland police mask ban passed 8-4 after months of public input. Councilor Samir Canal, who sponsored it, said Portlanders have a right to know who’s policing them.

The bill carves out exceptions for undercover operations and health and safety risks. It also instructs local officers to verify the identity of other law enforcement officers and to document those encounters.

Why can’t the mask ban touch federal ICE agents?

Because of the supremacy clause. Federal law enforcement operates under federal authority, and a city ordinance cannot regulate federal operations through local code. Asked directly whether Portland police could demand federal agents remove masks, the police union president said no: “City Council cannot require us to break federal law.”

Free weekly email

The Friday Reasonable Brief

A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.

Subscription Form

We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.

A crisp way to state it: the ordinance has legal force over exactly no one, because impersonating a police officer is already illegal and federal agents are beyond the city’s reach.

Federal law trumps literally trumps local nonsense. It’s called the supremacy clause.

Is this just virtue signaling?

That’s the central charge here. The provisions on federal law enforcement lack teeth, and even supporters concede they likely won’t change ICE’s tactics. Councilor Purle Guinea admitted it probably won’t alter ICE’s behavior but argued the council should respond to residents’ fears in whatever way it can.

ICE agents wear masks, the argument goes, because far-left agitators dox anyone they disagree with. Even Portland’s own police chief, Bob Day, said the provisions would only make officers’ jobs more onerous, adding tasks to an already substantial workload. It fits a pattern seen in stories about police refusing to support federal enforcement.

Have similar laws survived in court?

No. Efforts to impose comparable bans in other deep-blue jurisdictions have been defeated in court. A California law mandating that federal agents wear identification was struck down at the Ninth Circuit.

That history is why the mayor’s office reportedly views this as going nowhere. Democratic Mayor Keith Wilson urged the council to reject the ordinance, and the mayor’s office can initiate a lawsuit under the new legislation, further underscoring how contested it is. It echoes concerns raised about federal troops in Portland.

Why is Portland doing this instead of fighting crime?

Because the priority here is symbolism over enforcement. The critique is blunt: while crime goes unabated, businesses leave, downtown is a mess and homelessness spreads, the council spends its energy on a mask ban it can’t enforce.

Portland is already described as short hundreds of police officers, with local law enforcement lacking time for all but the most critical and violent crimes. Layering documentation duties on top of that, the argument goes, is a burden with no upside, part of the same pattern as diverting police money to park toilets.

What is the real purpose of the ordinance?

To let the council tell residents it’s making a difference. Supporters say the ban will help verify identities and deter law-enforcement impersonators, and they cite examples like a man arrested after allegedly convincing a 7-Eleven clerk he was law enforcement.

But impersonating an officer is already illegal, so the practical addition is minimal. The framing here is that the ordinance creates unrealistic expectations, leaving Portlanders to wonder why ICE still wears masks when the law has no power to compel otherwise.

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the vote on the Portland mask ban?

The City Council passed the ordinance by a vote of 8-4, barring local and federal law enforcement from wearing face coverings to hide their identity.

Can Portland force ICE agents to remove masks?

No. The police union president said the city cannot require officers to break federal law, and the supremacy clause places federal operations beyond city regulation.

Did Portland’s mayor support the ordinance?

No. Democratic Mayor Keith Wilson urged the council to reject it, and the ordinance is widely viewed, even by supporters, as unable to change ICE’s practices.

When a city passes a law it openly admits can’t be enforced against its target, is that leadership or theater? Let me know how you see it in the comments.

Full Episode Transcript

Read the full transcript of this episode

The city of Portland now considering a move to prohibit facial coverings and require badge visibility for city, state, and even federal law enforcement. >> Yeah. This follows nationwide criticism against ICE for shielding their identity across the country and here in Portland. >> Well, Portland City Council has voted to adopt an ordinance prohibiting law enforcement officers from wearing masks. >> Yeah. I mean, I’m prepared to compromise on a lot of of the the details here, but the values are the core piece here, which is the idea that Portlanders have a right to know who’s policing them when you deserve to know who’s operating in our city and and also to know whether or not the person claiming law enforcement authority actually is.

As for the rest, you know, the federal government can choose to [clears throat] ignore state law. They can choose to ignore local law. That doesn’t mean that we should just give up and stop doing our jobs to create law. I asked the president of the police union, “If this passes, would Portland police officers be able to demand federal agents to remove their masks?” >> No. City Council cannot require us to break federal law. Um, and federal law enforcements are are their work is governed by the federal government. >> How the ordinance does not apply to federal officers? >> I fail to see the purpose of banning federal officers from concealing their identity.

if you also forbid the police from enforcing the mask ban on federal officers. >> You ever wonder why Portland has so many issues and laws basically just don’t get enforced? It’s because of ridiculous ridiculous stuff that the city council does like what we’re going to talk about today. Portland City Council is banning face masks in an attempt to have federal law enforcement in an attempt to have ICE not wear face masks. They have zero control over that. And it’s already illegal to to be an imposttor of a police officer. So what are we even doing? We’re just doing massive virtue signaling in Portland, Oregon.

Nothing new. So, while crime goes unabated, you got businesses leaving left and right. Downtown’s a mess. Homelessness everywhere. Portland’s banning face masks that have no relevance to anything. Let’s get into it. Here we go. It’s so bad. I mean, it it’s so bad. How do these people not realize how bad they look? You guys down in Portland, Portland City Council, you are mentally handicapped. If you think this is going to have any impact on anything, because here’s how much impact it’s going to have on anything. Zero. A big fat zero. By a vote of we’re reading from Jackson Meyer, Seattle Red. By a vote of 8 to four, the Portland City Council passed an ordinance last week barring local and federal law enforcement from wearing face coverings to hide their identity.

They don’t like the fact that ICE comes in with face masks. ICE comes in with face masks because the lunatics on the far left constantly docks anybody they don’t agree with. It’s freedom of speech until you’re saying something the far left doesn’t like and then they become violent. Seems so many incidents of of of the far left of of Antifa trantifa assaulting assaulting reporters just there covering the story. Hey, what are you doing? Right after months of public input, I hit listen to this virtue signal. This is just this is verbal diarrhea is what this is. Sorry if you’re eating or drinking or just listening to me.

After months of public input and collaboration with community public safety leaders and attorneys, I’m pleased that a majority of council listened to Portlanders and passed reasonable legislation designed to withstand legal legal scrutiny, deter law enforcement impersonation, but protect our communities and strengthen public trust, said councelor Samir Canal, who sponsored the bill. There are a lot of limitations on our actions in response to the federal government and the unaccountable culture enabling impostors which they’ve created. What in the actual f are you talking about, Samir, you you sound mentally handicapped.

You sound like you’ve got a screw loose. You sound like you don’t understand how it works. But what we can do, we must do. All right. So, let me make this clear. You’ve installed a law that your local law enforcement has to has to deal with. Portland Police Bureau, right? You got just yet another Mickey Mouse deal that nobody’s going to enforce, but you’re going to layer that on top of all the cops responsibilities. Okay, I get that. And you’re already shy how many hundreds of cops? So this is just one more BS detail that is completely unnecessary at the local level. And then on the federal level, you have zero impact because federal law trumps literally trumps.

Do you like that word there, Samir? Trump’s local nonsense. Yeah, it’s called the supremacy clause. I don’t know. Maybe look it up. Maybe look it up. And Oh, hey. Yeah. Now, this is virtue signaling at its finest, right? Unaccountable culture enabling imposters. Nope. You know what? Federal federal officers, ICE going in and and deporting criminal illegal aliens, that’s what we signed up for and that’s what we’re getting. And if you don’t like that, you should probably leave. You should probably leave and go to another country because this is what we’re doing. Yep. The bill carves out exemptions.

Exceptions for undercover operations and scenarios that pose a health and safety risk. Ah, who cares? Who cares? Federal agents conceal their identities to prevent themselves from being doxed by radical agitators. 100%. 100%. Legislation meant to virtue signal. Provisions regarding federal law enforcement lack teeth. No, no, no, no. They have no teeth at all whatsoever. Just ab so crazy. Supremacy clause. Governments do not have authority over them. Democrat mayor of Portland Keith Wilson urged the council to reject the ordinance. This is why nothing is getting done in Portland, because they’re sitting around having a circle jerk about federal law enforcement not wearing masks, which they have zero control over, right?

You might as well be outlawing something in Iraq or Iran. And why don’t you guys outlaw that and see how that goes? Just, hey, none of this in Iraq. We’re not allowing it. You’ve got no jurisdiction over it. You got no jurisdiction over the feds. You got nothing. Efforts to impose a deep ban, a ban by other deep blue jurisdictions been defeated in court. California law, ninth circuit, no go. Mandated federal agents to wear identification. As for local law enforcement, police says this law is nothing more than a virtue signal. Bob Day said these provisions will only make their jobs more ownorous.

So in in cities in in in all of these sanctuary cities where it’s so so important for them to virtue signal, you know, their ideology, which is police are bad, ICE is bad because ICE is deporting their uh voter base and they don’t like that. It’s kind of like Doge was highlighting the fraud that typically was found in Democrat states, counties, and cities. So they they oh my gosh, this Doge thing is awful. It’s horrible. To the point where they got so upset with Elon Musk that they were inscribing swastikas onto onto Tesla cars. What was that all about? Well, that’s the same thing here. This is just this is just a a little bit less.

This is just this is mentally mentally challenged thought is what this is. It’s going to require us this is Bob Day police chief develop a policy train to that point documentation bunch of other nonsense additional tasks and they may seem small or insignificant but they add to a workload that’s already substantial. Don’t need it. Totally unnecessary. It completely misses the mark. I mean, this whole thing about the imposters that that it’s created imposters. Well, if they’re not federal officers, they can’t really they can’t really detain you and take you into a federal facility, can they? No.

And anybody else, hey, that’s already a thing. It’s illegal to to be an imposttor of a police officer, to pose as a police officer. That’s all that’s that’s already on the books, right? city ordinance won’t give local police the authority to unmask ICE, but its supporters say it will help verify and prevent law enforcement impersonators. Yeah, that’s just nonsense. Here they are up here’s the here’s ICE up on the U Portland facility. Now, if if you followed the whole Portland thing, Portland’s out of wildly out of control. Its leadership can’t work its way out of a wet paper bag by any means whatsoever.

They can’t even tell what direction is north. You know what I mean? They they’re just they’re they’re so mentally challenged with how to operate their city that [laughter] that that they’re afraid of ICE agents that have masks on because they don’t want to get doxed. If they truly understood that, this this wouldn’t be but they need to virtue signal. Look at us. Oh, we’re standing up for our community. Well, if your community’s got a bunch of criminal illegals in it, I’m all for ICE tossing them out. That’s what they do. It also sparked concerns about accountability and transparency within the broader community.

Whatever. Whatever. Just what’s changing? In addition to prohibiting all police from wearing facial coverings and require them to have visible identification, also instructs police officers to verify the identity of other law enforcement officers. You’ve got the blind leading the blind here, right? Because these cops aren’t going to do that. They’re just not going to do that. They already don’t have time for the most for anything but the most critical and violent crimes happening. So why do you want to throw this Mickey Mouse piece of dog dung out there? Because we’re so virtue signaling. Terrible.

New ordinance also requires local to police to document these encounters. Good luck with that. They don’t go after real crime because they don’t have enough cops. Plus, even if they did, your local justice department would just turn them loose on the streets because justice reform. Ah, we believe in it. Oh, this is great. Diversion for everybody. It’s going to be awesome. [snorts] There will be exceptions. Okay. New legislation. Mayor’s office can initiate a lawsuit. All this is is them flailing about. Portland City Council absolutely flailing about like a a a fish dying because it’s gasping for air.

It’s out of the water. Its gills aren’t working. And Portland City Council is that dying fish because ICE comes in and just hey, you’re illegal. Out you go. Oh, and they can’t stand that because they can’t control it. And their population base is just being decimated because you had four years of Biden and a wide open southern border, a wide open all borders. You brought in 20 million criminal illegals into the country and now some of those are being deported. Huh. Weird. Weird. Fentanel deaths are down. Crime is down. H there a cause and effect here? something like that. Ma said the ordinance will help prevent law enforcement impersonators, [laughter] whatever.

Or a man arrested earlier this year after allegedly convincing a 7-Eleven clerk that he was law enforcement. That’s that’s just a thing. So So this is one of those local issues where they’re referencing a man who killed former Minnesota House Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband in their home last June. But it’s not like that guy that that man would have gone scot-free had this law not been on the books. I mean just you’re it’s a total reach. It’s a virtue signal and it’s a total total reach. But like the state law, the new city policy has innate limitations. No, it’s totally limited. Change would empower police to unmask ICE by enforcing the ban on facial coverings.

Creating unrealistic expectations from the public. Yeah. because nothing is going to happen. And Portland people, because they live in Portland and they support a lot of these just a absolute nut job ideologies, they’re going to go, “Well, why aren’t why isn’t ICE taking off their mask?” Well, because this this law has zero teeth. Total paper tiger. Zero teeth. I don’t think it’s fair or right to mislead people into thinking this is going to do more than what it actually does, which is nothing. And that’s why Portland has major issues but does never address them because they’re too busy doing nonsense like this.

Just absolute nonsense. I mean, who even came up with this idea? [laughter] You know, the original concept, I’m sure the the dude here that we’re talking about, Samir, is that his name? Um, he wasn’t the genius that came up with the Hey, let’s outlaw face masks on federal law enforcement. Let’s make them I will never teach my children to blindly trust the demands of an adult unwilling to show their face. Yeah, but when something bad happens to you, you know what? You’re going to call 911 and you want a cop there with a mask on or not? You don’t care. I’m in danger. Public safety is being jeopardized here.

Send me a cop. Do you care if he has a mask? No. Just send one. a big one. I cannot and will not teach my children or the communities I organize with to trust adults wielding authority from behind a mask. What a bunch of nonsense. Just pure nonsense. Chill pastors testified about members of their congregation who no longer show up to church because they fear being detained by ICE. Well, are they criminal illegals? Maybe they should be. Maybe you shouldn’t have criminals in your church. I don’t know. You know what I mean? You got borders for a reason. There’s borders for a reason. Agents [snorts] cite privacy and safety concerns as the impetus for concealing their identities.

And I don’t blame them at all because people on the left that are against law enforcement doing their job at the federal level. They are insane. in the states, counties and cities that they operate in, sanctuary cities and states, they’re allowed to just carry out their extreme violence and their hate crimes because oh, it’s in the name of going against law enforcement. Since when do we go against law enforcement? And we’ve had president after president after president that have all talked about we need more secure borders. We need better border security. And then we had Biden come along. He just ah get rid of all that.

Open up the borders. We need some We need some replacements in our sanctuary cities for all of the population that’s leaving and going to Texas and Florida and the Carolas and Nevada and Idaho because they’re all leaving to go there because they’re better cities, counties, and states. The right to know legislation found an unexpected champion in councelor Purle Guinea who conceded that although it likely won’t change the policing tactics of ICE, the council should respond to the tangible risks and fears of Portlanders in whatever way it can. Okay. All right. Okay. So, you’re gonna throw this out there and and tell Portland instead of doing something about criminal activity, instead of doing something about getting homeless people off the hooch and into treatment, this is what you’re doing.

Hey, federal law officers, no more masks. And you know what they say? Nothing. Because you have zero relevance to their bearing. Zero. Zero. zero [laughter] hurdles to passage. Yeah, you think federal officers operate under federal authority and under the supremacy clause, the city cannot regulate federal operations through city code. H but we’re just going to go ahead and do this anyway because they want to they want to be able to sit down with Portlanders and say, “Hey, we’re really making a difference.” You It’s kind of like the ideology of no kings. You know what I mean? Just no kings.

We don’t want a king. Well, we had an election. So, does that still make him a king? And do you think if he was an actual king, you being out there with some horses assign? Do do you think he’d allow that if he was really a king? Got to work it through, people. But, you know, the same people that are out there doing no kings are the same people coming up with this just absolutely uneffective just no bearing on anything type of legislation. This is where your taxpayers dollars are going at the city council level. Portland, I hope you hope hope you you’re enjoying that. I hope this makes you feel better cuz when when the feds come knocking on a criminal legal door in Portland, you know how much your mask mandate has impact on the scenario?

Yeah, it doesn’t at all cuz it’s nonsense. Just virtue signaling at its finest. So, even the mayor’s office is like, “Yeah, boys and girls, this ain’t going anywhere.” Portland’s winning strategy against federal overreach has relied on close coordination with community leaders and advocates, clearly lawful policies and actions, and a path to victory in federal court. What are you talking about? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the feds keep deporting criminal illegals and Portland keeps fighting to keep them in their community. Why do you want criminals in your your your city so badly? Is it so important to have criminal illegals remain in your city trying to respond to the community demand that people know who’s policing them?

Um, if if you have to ask that, you don’t really understand how this game is played cuz the feds don’t care. They’re just going to come in and do what they want. If you’re not a criminal illegal, they’re probably not going to deport you. You’re not a criminal. They’re not going to have much to do with you. You’ve broken the law. If you’re here illegally, if you have a deportation order, out you go. Simple. Not in Portland. You got to go down this this long and windy and basically unfruitful road because bottom line is this has this has no bearing on anything. But this is what this is what Portland is doing.

[laughter] Just law enforcement mask ban on who? On on who? Who are you banning? Because that’s who your law impacts. Nobody. So, the whole thing’s just a sham. Just an absolute sham. But you got a bunch of far-left Democrats, progressives who are like, “Ah, we’re really making a difference.” Meanwhile, over the weekend, they’re out there with their no king signs, right? No kings. Whackadoodle. Whackadoodle do. And we’re going to continue covering these topics because this is insanity.

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

Portland Fentanyl Arrests: 80% Here Illegally, Feds Say

Portland Fentanyl Arrests: 80% Here Illegally, Feds Say

Watch next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.