Portland Homelessness Crisis: $724 Million Spent, 61% Population Increase Proves Housing First Policy Failure
Content Warning: This article discusses drug addiction, mental health crises, and homelessness with frank language and imagery that may be disturbing to some readers.
After spending $724 million on homelessness just last year in 2024, the Portland metro area’s homeless population has grown by 61% over the last 2 years. Up 61% after spending just last year $724 million. What is going on? You are watching Housing First failure in real time.
The Staggering Numbers Behind Portland’s Homelessness Crisis
Nearly 2,600 of the homeless people who were surveyed reported that they were living with serious mental illnesses. I mean, you know, it’s shocking every time we read this stuff, right? You’re like, “Okay, yeah, we know that. All right. Okay, we know that. Hey, another headline just identifying exactly what we already know.”
If this was a private business, it would have folded, right? Just like that. The whole goal of the homeless services complex is supposed to be to get people off the streets, get people out of their tents, get people off smoking the dope. And yet you’ve got headlines like this confirming none of it ever progresses in a forward manner.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
The latest point-in-time count (PIT count) – that’s the count that all the federal dollars are based off of, conducted by Portland State University’s homeless research and action collaborative – shows that there were 12,037 homeless individuals in the tri-county area on January 22nd.
That is a massive homeless population. Now consider that it’s probably under-reported by at least 50%. So you’ve probably got 25,000 homeless individuals, something like that. During Portland City Council’s homeless and housing committee meeting, county estimates showed about 48% of the homeless population was entirely unsheltered.
The Housing First Policy Disaster Unfolding
When homelessness goes up by 61%, that’s when you know the drugs are good in Portland. So half of that population is unsheltered, meaning they are just running around taking drugs, stealing from the community, selling those EBT cards, selling those SNAP cards for cash to get the next hit of fentanyl.
You’ve got half of the 12,000 people just running around willy-nilly, sometimes with clothes on, sometimes not. There was a video the other day, just downtown Portland, with a woman maybe in her 30s, whacked out of her mind on drugs, without a stitch of clothing on her. And it’s winter – not exactly nude sunbathing weather here in the Pacific Northwest.
The Housing First model is fundamentally flawed because:
- It doesn’t address addiction issues
- Mental health treatment is an afterthought
- Getting housing isn’t contingent upon sobriety
- No requirements for taking medication or seeking help
- Creates dependency without addressing root causes
What the Homeless Industrial Complex Won’t Tell You
Most of the folks on Portland streets have not had anybody come and talk to them. You hear that all the time in interviews: “When’s the last time somebody came and asked how you were? I’ve never had anybody come and ask me how I am.” And you’re like, “Okay, so where’s the $724 million going?” Good question, right?
The homeless industrial complex isn’t really designed to work. It’s not really designed to get people the help that they need. It’s designed to just exist and everybody takes a little piece of the pie – all the workers, all the outreach workers. But the vast majority of folks on Portland streets haven’t had anybody do actual outreach to them.
Andrea Suarez, with over 40,000 hours of logged volunteer time and 500 cleanups, explains the reality: “I’ve seen cockroaches inch long by the hundreds if not thousands in some of these [housing] units and people simply move out. And that’s where I meet them. I’m like, what? You have a home but you’re not in it.”
The Fatal Flaw in Progressive Homeless Policy
Housing First defenders would say, “Well, if you get the homeless off the streets into housing, then they can relax, get their head together, get to a spot where they want to get sober.” But when Housing First started, fentanyl didn’t exist as the drug we know today. Meth in the scope we’re seeing now didn’t exist. Meth and fentanyl together did not exist when Housing First became an ideology.
Does Housing First give people the ability to breathe a little bit? Yes. But then you’ve got to take that step further and get them sober or get them the mental health treatment they need. Otherwise, you just got a bunch of addicts running around doing dope indoors.
Housing First dictates that getting a room isn’t contingent upon:
- Sobriety
- Taking prescribed medications
- Seeking mental health treatment
- Participating in addiction services
- Any behavioral requirements whatsoever
Portland City Council’s Backwards Response
Portland City Council, which is majority Democratic Socialists of America, can’t work their way out of a wet paper bag. Homelessness has gone up by 61% in two years, and what does the city council propose? City Councilor Angelita Morillo has proposed cutting $4.3 million from the Impact Reduction Program – the city team in charge of cleaning homeless camps.
Let’s cut $4 million from cleanup because that’s really going in the right direction. Pure insanity. Spend $750 million, but then eliminate the programs that actually physically address the street-level crisis. She wants to redirect that money to “immigrant and refugee support.” Hard no. You need to clean up those homeless encampments first.
Meanwhile, Mayor Keith Wilson is trying to stem businesses and residents from leaving the city by implementing camp sweeps. Is it perfect? No. But it’s doing something, and eliminating cleanup would be catastrophically wrong.
The Treatment Gap That’s Killing People
These people do not have the ability to think for themselves because they’re whacked out on fentanyl, meth, horse tranquilizers – whatever it might be. The ultimate goal should be getting these people squared away through:
- Comprehensive addiction treatment programs
- Long-term mental health care services
- Mandatory treatment for those unable to make decisions
- Rebuilt mental health infrastructure
- Accountability in housing programs
We don’t have enough treatment centers, mental health facilities, or addiction services because it’s too expensive. We got rid of all the mental institutions, and now we’re paying the price. Until somebody builds the treatment infrastructure, this is a no-win situation.
Why “Build It and They Will Come” Backfired
You’ve already built the homeless industrial complex structure, and word has gotten out – everybody knows Portland’s where it’s at. You want to be a drug addict and homeless? They’ll give you your own apartment, you can have a tent, and you can run around doing drugs all day. That’s what people are doing.
Progressive ideology doesn’t actually help people – it hurts people. Having people naked and doing drugs on the streets isn’t compassionate; it’s enabling deadly behavior. You don’t see this level of street chaos in developing countries, yet here we are in Portland with “clothing optional” drug psychosis on public sidewalks.
What Cities Must Do Instead
The best hope for cities like Seattle, Portland, LA, and San Francisco is to maintain pressure through strategic enforcement while building real treatment capacity:
- Continue camp sweeps to send the message that unlimited street camping isn’t acceptable
- Invest in treatment centers instead of just housing without support
- Require treatment participation for housing assistance
- Rebuild mental health infrastructure that was destroyed decades ago
- Stop the whack-a-mole game by addressing root causes
Some cities will push back and play the displacement game, while others loaded with Democratic Socialist council members will continue funding policies that demonstrably fail. Portland’s 61% increase in homelessness despite three-quarters of a billion dollars in spending is the perfect case study in progressive policy failure.
What’s your take on Housing First policies in your city? Have you witnessed similar failures in homeless services spending? Share your experiences and observations – the data suggests we need completely different approaches to actually help people escape the streets.
Up next

Portland Real Estate Crash: Hotel Sells 93% Below 2016 Price
Watch next


Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.