Washington Budget Credit Downgrade: Moody’s Sounds the Alarm
Moody's revised Washington's financial outlook from stable to negative.
Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.
Prefer audio? Listen to the podcast version:
The Washington budget credit downgrade warning is here: for the first time, a major credit agency has revised the state’s financial outlook from stable to negative. Moody’s hasn’t cut Washington’s triple-A bond rating yet, but it flagged how lawmakers have been balancing the budget as unsustainable — the fiscal equivalent of a dashboard warning light coming on.
Key Takeaways
- Moody’s revised Washington’s outlook from stable to negative — a formal warning, not yet an actual rating cut.
- Last session’s Democrat-controlled legislature grew the budget to nearly $80 billion despite a shortfall of more than $2 billion.
- Lawmakers pulled roughly $880 million from reserves to fund the budget.
- Reserves sit around 8% now and are projected to dip below 2% by 2028.
What does the Washington budget credit downgrade warning actually mean?
A credit rating works like a personal credit score: it determines whether lenders will loan you money, how much, and at what interest rate. The state issues bonds to fund infrastructure, and its rating sets the interest it pays back. When that rating drops, borrowing gets more expensive.
State Treasurer Mike Pellicciotti put it plainly: it’s like your car engine warning light just came on, and you have to fix it. Moody’s didn’t ding the rating itself. It signaled the state is one step from losing its top-tier status.
Why is Moody’s concerned?
The core issue is what’s called a structurally imbalanced budget — a budget where more is being spent than is coming in, with the gap filled by dipping into reserves. Washington’s legislature balances the budget every year on paper, but it has increasingly leaned on the rainy day fund to cover recurring operations instead of matching recurring spending with recurring revenue.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
The problem, as Pellicciotti explained, is that when you take money out of savings you have to replenish it immediately — and the rating agency says lawmakers are waiting too long in the budget cycle to put it back.
The state issues bonds to borrow money for infrastructure, and its credit rating determines what it pays on the interest to pay that money back.
The millionaire tax gamble baked into the numbers
Part of what unsettled Moody’s is that Democrats are counting on the so-called millionaire’s income tax to balance the budget starting in fiscal year 2029. That revenue is being treated as a sure thing three years out — except the tax is already being challenged in court.
If that challenge succeeds or the tax is overturned, the projected revenue vanishes and the budget destabilizes. Credit agencies don’t like leaning on money that might never arrive. It’s like writing a budget around a real estate commission from a deal that hasn’t closed. Our breakdown of Washington’s 9.9% rate walks through why this bet is so shaky.
Is losing a AAA rating really that bad?
On its own, no — only 18 or 19 states hold a triple-A bond rating, and most states get by without one. The problem is the direction of travel. Going from top-tier down means higher interest costs on everything the state borrows for.
A downgrade would add to an already-existing budget deficit, make borrowing more expensive, and ripple into schools, infrastructure, and every project the state finances. That’s how a warning becomes a financial spiral.
Republicans and Democrats read the same report differently
Republican budget leader Rep. Travis Couture said Moody’s confirmed what his side has argued for months: the math in Olympia doesn’t add up. He accused the majority of doubling spending over the last decade and pushing an $80 billion budget that spends more than the state collects even with record tax revenue.
The governor’s likely defense is that reserves were tapped to offset an $800 million cut to Medicaid funding, and that the money was put back. But that override only works while the rainy day fund lasts — and it’s projected to shrink fast. This is the same trajectory we traced when taxpayers began leaving the state after a $9.4 billion tax hike.
How other states are going the opposite way
Oklahoma is reportedly putting roughly $3 billion into a savings fund and betting the interest can offset — and eventually eliminate — its 4.5% income tax. Whether that math pencils is its own debate, but the direction is toward living off investment income rather than spending down savings.
Washington is heading the other way: layering on programs and reaching for more progressive revenue like a millionaire’s tax rather than reining in spending. Reserves near 8% today are projected below 2% by 2028. As we noted in the state’s ongoing budget crisis, that’s not where any household wants to be on savings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Moody’s actually downgrade Washington’s credit rating?
No. Moody’s revised the outlook from stable to negative, which is a formal warning that a downgrade could come. The triple-A bond rating remains intact for now.
Why does the millionaire tax matter to the rating?
Democrats are relying on income-tax revenue to balance the budget in fiscal year 2029, but that tax is being challenged in court. Moody’s flagged the uncertainty because the state is counting on money that may not materialize.
What happens to Washington’s reserves?
Reserves are currently around 8% and are expected to dip below 2% by 2028, largely because the legislature has been using the rainy day fund to cover recurring operations.
If the millionaire tax gets struck down and the reserves run dry, what should Olympia cut first — and do you think lawmakers actually will? Tell us where you’d draw the line.
Full Episode Transcript
Read the full transcript of this episode
It is the first time a major credit agency has revised Washington’s financial outlook from a stable one to a negative. Moody’s report taking issue with how lawmakers are balancing the state budget. If we lose a triple A bond rating, it would raise the cost of borrowing money, and it would create a financial spiral impacting everything from school bonds, taxes, raising the budget deficit, and to our infrastructure projects. State Treasurer Mike Pellicciotti sat down with me earlier to discuss that outlook. >> do think it’s significant. So, when you talk about a credit rating, it’s kind of like folks have an individual credit score.
It helps determine whether or not people loan you money, how much money they’re willing to loan you, and what interest rate you have to pay it back. Well, the state issues what are called bonds, which is essentially the way we borrow money to do infrastructure projects. And our credit rating determines what we pay on the interest to pay that money back. >> But where are we now if you could com- compare us on the spectrum? Are we at that cliff? >> Well, I would say it’s almost like your car engine warning light has just gone out. You got to fix it, right? And so, what Moody’s just indicated, as you said, was a negative outlook, which is that they have some concerns with how the legislature has been budgeting in recent years.
Things they focus on is what’s called a structurally imbalanced budget, which means that in recent years the legislature has relied on things called reserves, which is kind of like the rainy day fund, money setting aside to essentially balance the budget. Every year the legislature balances the budget, but it’s structurally imbalanced, meaning more expenses are being paid than revenue coming in, and they’re using reserves to fill that gap. But the problem is when you take money out of your savings, you have to immediately replenish And what the And what the credit rating agency is saying is they’re waiting too long in their budget cycle to put that money back.
That money needs to be put back into the budget. >> So, what do they have to do next year or so that way the state doesn’t break down? >> Well, it’s Something needs to be fixed, which means that you can’t keep spending more money than you’re bringing in. You can’t rely on reserves. You can’t rely on your savings to fill that gap. Well, one of the things that I’ve always said related to that is any new tax should be getting rid of our regressive tax system. Um, that is a decision the legislature made in terms of bringing forward that proposal. What I can tell you is what Moody’s is saying right now, which is that the legislature is relying on that to balance the budget in fiscal year 2029, meaning for in essentially 3 years it has to balance.
So, we’re in a situation where if that doesn’t pass or is overturned in some way, that could create an instability in the budget. And that was one of the concerns that Moody’s actually highlighted. >> So, as you just heard, the Democrats are relying on the so-called millionaires tax, is what I’m talking about when I mention the income tax there, to balance the budget in the future with money coming in starting in 2029. But, that is only if legal challenges against the income tax fail. Republican budget leader representative Travis Couture reacting to Moody’s report saying in part, “Moody’s has confirmed what we have been saying for months.
The math in Olympia does not add up. You cannot spend record amounts of taxpayer money, raid pension funds, and fail to deliver on the basics without consequences. For years, the majority has treated the state budget like a blank check, doubling spending over the last decade. They pushed through an 80 billion budget that spends more than the state brings in, even with record tax collections.” >> So, Moody’s, credit rating agency, they have downgraded Washington State’s financial outlook to negative. This isn’t looking good, boys. This isn’t looking good. They haven’t dinged the actual credit rating yet, but they’re basically saying, “We’re one step away.
You guys keep up this these shenanigans, these financial shenanigans, taking too much from your reserves, spending too much, not generating enough revenue, not living within your budget, we’re going to downgrade you.” Let’s get into it. Here we go. I mean, who knew? Actions have consequences, right? You do a bunch of just untethered, unbridled spending, and then the piper comes calling. Hey, yeah, about your credit rating. You know, I mean, it’s like when you max out all your credit cards, you go out and buy three new cars on loans, and you max out a massive mortgage on a house. Guess what? Your credit rating is not going to go up.
For the first time, major credit agency has revised Oh, now we’ve got a great new word. Revised, right? I have concerned. We need to revise Washington’s financial outlook from stable to negative. That’s an interesting one. I mean, they’re just basically calling it, right? Signaling a risk for Washington state to lose its triple-A bond rating. That’s tippy-top. And it’s it’s like your credit score. You know, when you go to get insurance based on your your credit score, how much you’re going to pay. When you got a triple-A bond rating, that’s the you know, that’s the risk factor of Washington state paying back, you know, any of the bonds that it issues.
It’s got a triple-A rating. It’s got tippy-top now. But, because of the way that it’s handled its finances last couple of years, Moody’s saying, “This ain’t looking good. This is not looking good.” The revision by Moody’s serves as a formal warning to lawmakers that they’re balancing the budget in an unsustainable way. Can’t keep doing this, cuz you’re monkeying with the whole deal, right? You’re you’re borrowing from here to pay here, and it’s not sustainable. Now, what Washington state legislators, and I’m sure the governor The governor basically said, “Oh, we got triple-A credit rating. We’re working hard to keep that.” Well, yeah, but Moody’s just said, “Mhm, mhm, you keep going that direction, going to downgrade you, right?” There’s what, 19 states that have 18 states, 19 states that have triple-A bond rating.
Okay? Washington’s one of them. So, it’s not a huge deal to not have a AAA bond rating cuz a lot of states don’t. Most of them don’t, in fact. But, when you’ve had that and you go the other way, then you start to incur more interest costs. It’s more expensive. You got to pay back more. When your credit goes down, you’re going to be obligated to pay more because you’re not going to be able to get that top-tier credit rating, right? Well, Washington’s top-tier credit rating remains intact for now. The outlook suggests the state is at a fiscal crossroads. What way are we going to go? And this this plays into we’re going down the road of just layering on massive amounts of spending and we’re going to do these hairbrained millionaire tax.
We’re going to do a bunch of stuff that does not have longevity because at the end of the day, millionaires are going to leave. People with money are going to leave and it’s going to leave a massive tax burden to the poor people left behind that could move. How’s that going to happen? Well, at the start, you’re either going to get all that money out of folks or you basically eliminate all the wealthy people who are your competition. So, you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you you Right?
I mean you just you just kind of push out and I had somebody explain that to me. Cuz I would I was questioning, “Hey, what’s the end goal here? What’s the end goal here?” And the end goal is Washington state, the Democrats win because they either get the revenue they’re looking for or they get rid of all the people that they disagree with politically. Typically wealthy people or conservative, right? All the people Democrat party who you know, want to live off the dole. Want to live off the government, expand government, it’ll save you. Yeah, good luck with that. All those folks will be gone. Washington state can just absolutely follow itself into the toilet bowl, right?
And then I read in Fox 13 on Monday state treasurer Mike Pelleciotti compared the revision to a dashboard’s warning in your car. The red engine light has gone off, okay? I would say it’s like your car engine warning light has gone up. Pelleciotti noted that a credit rating functions kind of like folks have an individual credit score, we talked about that. Our credit rating determines what we pay, and that’s what the state pays. So, if they get downgraded, things become more expensive. And the reason Washington would be getting downgraded is because of fiscal irresponsibility. They’ve got too much in the way of obligations, they’ve committed to to too many programs that we simply don’t need.
Simply don’t need, and we’re not living within a budget. Actions have consequences. Moody’s says, “Hey, you guys are on the cusp. You guys are on that cliff. You’re about ready to go over.” Cuz you’ve got a structurally imbalanced budget. In recent years, the legislature has increasingly relied on the state’s rainy day fund and other reserves to cover daily operations rather than matching recurring spending with recurring revenue. So, that’s the imbalance, right? Okay, so we’re going to go hit our savings when in fact we don’t have the revenue to cover the spending that we’re doing. But we want to keep all the programs intact because this is a Democrat supermajority state, tax and spend, tax and spend, tax and spend.
That’s what we do. That’s what Democrats do cuz they love to spend the taxpayers’ money. And and Democrats think that all of this spending is going towards just great, great stuff. And then they slowly see, you know, the benefits of their tax dollar. Hey, the roads aren’t getting fixed. There’s graffiti everywhere. Our parks aren’t being maintained all that well. Infrastructure is kind of failing. Huh, weird. We seen that in LA? Absolutely. And it’s to the point where it’s out of control. And so this is this is that warning light blinking going, you guys keep going down that road, it’s not going to be good.
Going to have to ding you. The last legislative session, Democrat controlled legislature, increased the budget to nearly 80 billion dollars. They have just been on a massive, massive spending spree to fund two years despite a more than two billion dollar shortfall. Now, I made a comment earlier and what the governor’s going to say is that, hey, the the the Trump administration, they cut 800 million from our Medicare. Or Medicaid. All right? Yeah, they did. And you are basically overriding that by borrowing from your rainy day fund, when in fact that rainy day fund will end. So fiscal responsibility would say you need to match up that revenue with spending.
That is just never going to happen. Never going to happen. So, you know, the the day of reckoning will come. Will Washington pull it out? They’re doing they’re they’re doing tricks right now. They’re basically just doing financial tricks, right? To to get to a balanced budget. Oh, it’s balanced. Yeah, and that’s why it’s so important to have something like the millionaires tax. Now that millionaires tax is being counted on in 2029 to drive in revenue, right? What if that doesn’t happen? What if that doesn’t happen? What what if what if in court it gets challenged, which it sure It’s It already is, right?
It’s being challenged right now as we speak. What if the outcome of that is, “Hey, Democrats, you got to go back to the drawing board and come up with this again.” That could happen. Then then what happens with Washington’s ability to cover its bills? You can only go to your reserves so many times, and then you don’t have any more. And then and then you got to figure out, all right, what are we going to do now? We could cut some programs. Oh, no, let’s not do that. We could live within our budget. Oh, no. We can’t have that. We need to have the whatever whatever program, right? I mean, that’s that’s what we’re talking about.
Just massive amounts of spending on ridiculous stuff. How much do we spend on criminal illegal aliens? Right? Watching a hearing in uh Chicago, the mayor, Let’s Go Brandon Johnson. Mhm, a woman pulls up and it was an old hearing, I think from 2024. She just lays into Brandon Johnson, “Hey, how about you spend you you How about you put that money towards people who are already citizens paying your taxes? What about that?” Brandon Johnson’s just red. Can’t really work out what’s going on. Lawmakers also pulled approximately 880 million from reserves to fund the budget. This is both publicly and privately, he said, characterized the strategy as definitely risky.
Actions have consequences. Here we are. Problem is, when you take money out of your savings, you have to immediately replenish it. We heard him say that. And when the credit rating agency is saying that they’re waiting too long in their budget cycle to put that money back, that money needs to be put back into the budget. So, governor’s going to say, “We did put it back. We didn’t wait that long.” You know, so it’s a matter of semantics, but the bottom line is is that what Washington state is doing is viewed as risky. And Moody’s is calling that out and just saying, “Hey, this is where we’re at.
This is what you guys sit at.” Hello COD says the reason why Democrats pulled from the reserves was to compensate for Trump’s reduction in Medicaid funding. Okay. You can’t rely on your savings to fill that gap. Negative outlook also reflects uncertainty surrounding the latest millionaire tax. Moody’s took the income tax into consideration because Democrats were relying on revenue from the income tax to balance the future budget in future years because they are spending too much and they need to come up with a system that provides revenue now, today. So, they are basically throwing the millionaire tax against the wall see if it sticks.
And if it does stick, well, then they’ve got some money there. But, credit agencies don’t like to look at that kind of stuff that’s iffy and go, “Oh, yeah, they can count on that.” Knowing full well they may not be able to count on that at all. So, Moody’s took the income tax into consideration. But, it’s an unknown. It’s an unknown. Is that money going to come in? It’s It’s like counting on a real estate transaction that may or may not close. Yeah, I need to, you know, fill the budget with this commission coming in. But, we don’t know if that’s going to close, Sean. Yeah, I’ll just do it anyway.
It’ll probably close. What happens if it doesn’t? Oh, then we deal with it then. What if our credit rating gets dropped? Oh, if you don’t pay your bills, that’s what’s happening, right? That is what happens. The money from the tax is slated to come in 2029, the millionaire tax, but legal challenges, the income tax could turn into an unstable source. Or how about this? Just not a source at all. I believe the millionaire tax will go through one way or the other because this is Washington state and why wouldn’t it? We’re in a situation where if that doesn’t pass or is overturned in some way, that can create an instability in the budget.
Got instability. It’s not too late and lawmakers can fix the financial outlook, he said. He encouraged lawmakers to prioritize the financial health of the state next year’s legislative session. You mean tax and spend? Tax and spend? Keep it going? That what we’re doing? That is what we’re doing. Here’s what would happen if if Moody’s does downgrade or any of the credit agencies does downgrade Washington state. You know, from triple A down to a whatever. Next level down. The bond rating were downgraded could lead to a financial spiral with huge impacts. Because you’ve already got a budget deficit, right?
And you’re not able to cover it. And so now it’s going to be even more expensive to pay all your bills because the the the your credit rating means it’s more expensive. Now, you’ve got even greater distance in the amount of money that you need. You need even more money to cover that interest rate carry. So, downgrading of the of the credit would add to the budget deficit and lead to debates on raising more taxes, would make it more expensive to borrow money, which in turn would impact everything from infrastructure projects to schools. Anything that the state has a financial interest in would be impacted because whether it’s their ability to borrow or it’s their ability to to pay the the the outstanding bills or it’s you know, we got to shut a bunch of programs down.
Everything’s in play, right? So, this is kind of that first launch by Moody’s of not everything is all that well in Washington state. We’re not saying it’s bad yet, but we’re one step away from going there, which is Washington state, you needed to reel in your spending, live within your budget, but we are not going to do that. Instead, we’re going to go after even more progressive revenue, which is a millionaire’s tax. You know, in California, they’re doing the billionaire’s tax. Washington here, we’re doing the millionaire’s tax. They’re going to tax everybody who has money out and you’re going to you’re going to have a wealth tax.
You’re going to have all kinds of taxes by the end of the day. Washington is just going to be loaded up with taxes because they need those taxes to cover their obligations, which are vast and they’re massive. What about what’s happening in Oklahoma, where I’m moving to? They’re They’re They’re basically putting like $3 billion into a savings fund that generates interest and they are stating that with that interest, they can get rid of their 4 and 1/2% income tax. They’re going the other way. Whether or not you want to take a consistent, “Hey, we’re going to tax each of the residents of Oklahoma 4 and 1/2%.” Whether you, you know, disband that and go after what you think you can get on the return by having 3 billion in savings, does that offset the guaranteed taxes?
Because if you tax residents, you’re going to get that money, right? But there’s that unknown of what kind of return you’re going to get on your big investment of your savings. Don’t know. And And that’s where folks in Oklahoma are like, “Okay, this sounds great, but will it happen?” But Does Doesn’t matter which side you’re on. That’s the direction you want to go. We’re living off income from our savings. We’re not downgrading our credit rating because we’re spending so much or we’re not borrowing and not paying back when we should be. It’s It’s It’s a matter of fiscal responsibility and Washington state versus even a Texas or a Florida or a an Oklahoma.
The The spending patterns are wildly different and so much of this has happened in just the last couple of years. Washington state is just just absolutely gone down this crazy train road because you’ve got you’ve got all these programs that the Democrats need to have. Absolutely must have, right? Whereas they don’t have most of those programs in in other states where they’ve got a balanced budget. They don’t have a just a bunch of they’re not sanctuary cities. They’re not sanctuary states. They’re not handing out freebies left and right. They’re they’re investing. They’re saving. They’re they’re pulling down investment dollars from from interest.
They’re getting rid of taxes. Washington state going the exact opposite away. Currently the state is around 8% financial reserves expected to dip below 2% by 2028. Oh, that’s comforting. That is comforting. I mean, that’s that’s where you want to be. Hey, how much you got in in savings? 2%. So, this is just kind of one more in one more story in the overall picture of what’s happening here in Washington state. And in my opinion, things are not going in the right direction by any means. Cuz you’re just you’re pushing out all the people with money who drive in businesses. They drive in jobs, you know, wealth creation.
You’re pushing all those people out. And you know what? All right, okay. It’s just like Moody’s saying, “Hey, outlook’s negative.” Actions have consequences. And here here we’ve got the same exact thing. You’re going to have to pay the piper at some point in time for the kind of spending and for the kind of not not living within a in a budgetary means like some other states are doing. And and eventually that’ll catch up with you cuz very simple. Credit agencies aren’t going to go, “Oh, they they spent it on some really good stuff. Really good stuff there. Not going to happen. Credit your credit rating is going to get dinged.
And when that happens, I’ll record it for you. Thanks so much for being here. Love to have you subscribe. Hit that notification bell. I’ll see you in the next one. Bye for now.
Up next

Washington Business Tax Exodus: Columbia Bank’s $8M Move
Watch next


Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.