Washington Millionaire Tax Emails Reveal a Bigger Plan
Emails obtained by the Center Square suggest Washington lawmakers designed the "millionaire tax" to force a court fight and open the door to taxing everyone.
Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.
Prefer audio? Listen to the podcast version:
The Washington millionaire tax is facing new questions after emails obtained by the Center Square suggest lawmakers designed it not just to tax high earners, but to provoke a lawsuit and overturn the state’s 1933 ban on progressive income taxes. If that succeeds, the door opens to taxing everyone.
Key Takeaways
- Governor Bob Ferguson signed Senate Bill 6346, imposing a 9.9% tax on income above $1 million, effective 2028 with payments starting 2029.
- An August 2025 email from Senator Jamie Pedersen says he wants to “force the Washington Supreme Court to reconsider its case law that considers income to be property.”
- The emails show the Attorney General’s office helped curate the bill’s language; the AG’s office calls that role routine.
- Former AG Rob McKenna and former Supreme Court Justice Phil Talmadge — a former Democratic senator — are leading a lawsuit to strike it down.
The legal target is a single precedent. Since the 1933 Culliton decision, Washington courts have treated income as property, which is why a graduated income tax has been off the table for nearly a century.
What do the leaked Washington millionaire tax emails reveal?
They reveal intent. According to investigative reporter T.J. Martinell with the Center Square, who received the unredacted records, Senator Pedersen wrote that he expected the bill to be challenged in court and that he wanted to force the state Supreme Court to reconsider its ruling that income is property.
In Martinell’s words, lawmakers “are explicitly stating in these emails that this is the purpose of the tax.” The bill, he argues, was tailored not to avoid legal scrutiny but to invite it — engineering a test case rather than simply raising revenue.
Free weekly email
The Friday Reasonable Brief
A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.
We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.
Why would lawmakers want a lawsuit?
Because the lawsuit is the point. The 1933 precedent is the wall standing between Washington and a broad-based income tax. Overturn it in court, and the floodgates open — the state could then tax income however it wants, at whatever threshold it chooses.
A millionaire tax is the politically easy way in. Pitch it as only affecting the wealthy, get it challenged, win the constitutional fight, and the same legal reasoning applies to everyone. It is a slippery slope by design, not by accident.
This tax right now, technically, it just applies to millionaires. If the bill does what it’s intended, everyone in the state could be subject to paying an income tax.
What role did the Attorney General’s office play?
The records show the AG’s office provided detailed guidance on the bill’s language — including advice on avoiding a marriage penalty and keeping the legal focus squarely on the Culliton precedent. The office also noted the absence of an emergency clause, which would otherwise block voters from challenging the law by referendum.
A spokesperson for Attorney General Nick Brown called the Center Square’s narrative “nonsense,” saying the office is required by law to represent the legislature and answer questions from lawmakers of all parties. Critics counter that helping design legislation to overturn constitutional precedent is a different thing than routine legal advice.
Is this driving businesses out of Washington?
It already is. The same week these emails surfaced, Starbucks announced a major expansion to Nashville — a shift projected to cost Washington up to $750 million in revenue over two decades. Tax flight is not a future risk; it is happening now, and it will not stop with millionaires.
This fits a broader pattern of policy driving capital out, the same story we covered in Seattle’s accelerating tech layoffs and in the data showing Washington losing a taxpayer every 30 minutes.
Why did lawmakers reject a threshold amendment?
This is the tell. Before the bill passed the state House in March, Democratic legislators rejected an amendment that would have made it significantly harder to lower the $1 million threshold and expand the tax to more Washingtonians. If the tax were truly only for millionaires, locking in that threshold would be easy.
Refusing to do so raised eyebrows at the time. In light of the emails, it looks less like an oversight and more like a signal of what was always intended. Washington already sits at 45th for tax competitiveness, a decline we detailed when the state’s ranking crashed to 45th place.
What happens next?
A legal fight is officially underway. The Citizen Action Defense Fund has filed suit to strike the tax down, led by Rob McKenna and joined by Phil Talmadge. The case will likely be tied up in court for a long time.
But the bottom line, by this account, is that Washington is getting an income tax one way or another. If this version is struck down, another attempt follows. This is the 1.0 version of whatever it takes to clear the 1933 precedent — and the state already taxes nearly everything else.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the rate and threshold of the Washington millionaire tax?
Senate Bill 6346 imposes a 9.9% tax on federal adjusted gross income above $1 million for individuals or households, with the law effective in 2028 and payments due starting 2029.
What is the 1933 precedent at the center of this?
The Culliton decision, under which Washington courts have treated income as property since 1933, which is why the state has not had a graduated income tax.
Who is challenging the tax in court?
The Citizen Action Defense Fund filed the lawsuit, led by former Attorney General Rob McKenna and joined by former State Supreme Court Justice Phil Talmadge.
If a “millionaire tax” is really a first step toward taxing everyone, should voters get a direct say before the precedent falls? Share your take below.
Full Episode Transcript
Read the full transcript of this episode
The so-called millionaires tax is facing new questions after emails obtained by the Center Square suggest some lawmakers anticipated a legal challenge that could reach the state Supreme Court. The emails obtained through a public records request also show communication with the Attorney General’s office during the bill’s drafting. In 1930, Washington voters were handed this pamphlet. The state was in a tax crisis. The 14th Amendment promised to shift the burden from farmers, but there was a catch. It defined income as property. Every Supreme Court ever since has always ruled that It’s been the law of the land since 1933.
You can’t tax income at a progressive rate. >> Uh this morning, Governor Bob Ferguson signed Senate Bill 6346, the so-called millionaires tax. It will impose a 9.9% tax on income above $1 million a year for individuals or households. It does not tax the value of assets like homes or property. The law doesn’t take effect until 2028 with payments due starting in 2029. >> An August 2025 email from State Senator Jamie Pedersen, obtained by the Center Square, shows him discussing expected legal challenges to the proposal. In the email, Pedersen writes he would like to quote, “Force the Washington Supreme Court to reconsider its case law that considers income to be property.” They’re not being uh subtle or being nuanced.
They’re explicitly stating in these emails that this is the purpose of the tax. According to investigative reporter T.J. Martinell with the Center Square, who received the unredacted emails in a records request, he says emails show the Attorney General’s office helped curate the language advising Pedersen. Fox 13 reached out to the Attorney General’s office, which says that role is routine, saying, quote, “We’re required by law to represent the legislature. They get to ask us questions and we respond. There’s nothing unusual about any of that. It’s what attorneys in the offices of attorneys generals do.” This was not meant to be a millionaires tax.
This was meant to overturn a uh a century-old Supreme Court ruling. The AG’s office says providing legal advice to lawmakers is a standard part of its responsibilities. The emails also include discussion about an emergency clause, which can limit the ability to challenge a law through a referendum. Martinelli argues the broader goal of the policy could extend beyond taxing high earners. This tax right now, technically, it just applies to millionaires. If the bill does what it’s intended, everyone in the state could be subject to paying an income tax. State officials, however, maintain the tax is aimed at generating revenue from the wealthiest residents.
>> A major legal fight is officially underway over Washington’s new income tax. The Citizen Action Defense Fund filed a lawsuit today seeking to strike down the so-called millionaires tax. Former Washington AG Rob McKenna is leading the lawsuit and has now been joined by former State Supreme Court Justice Phil Talmadge, who was also a Democrat senator. Shocker that there’s some leaked emails indicating that Washington State’s millionaire tax is just a basically a ruse to get a lawsuit going to make it a tax on not just millionaires, but everybody. Yeah, big shocker there, right? We knew we knew this was the intent, but now we’ve literally got email back and forth that Center Square came up with indicating Jimmy Peterson, one of Washington State’s legislators, and the Attorney General’s office have basically been going back and forth, “How can we get this thing through?
What do we need to do to position this so that we can tax the F out of everybody?” Let’s get into it. Here we go. Leaked emails reveal Washington lawmakers and the Attorney General’s office intentionally intentionally designed a millionaires tax to provoke a lawsuit and overturn the state’s 1933 ban on progressive income taxes. They they’ve just been working this and we knew it. You’re like, this is just a ploy and now we know the exact mechanisms and the research that they did and their strategy going back and forth on how to make this an income tax on everyone. Oh, let’s just pitch it as a millionaire’s tax.
Once we weasel our way in >> [snorts] >> Senator Jamie Pedersen explicitly stated the goal is to force the Supreme Court to stop defining income as property. Potentially clearing the path for a broad-based state income tax. Then the floodgates are open. Then they can just tax they can tax however they want to. I mean, we knew this was coming. We knew something along these lines was being designed. We didn’t just quite know how. Now we’ve got the emails to to back it up. State officials defend the coordination as standard legal practice. While critics warn the the move bypasses voter precedent and could trigger tax flight from the state’s wealthiest residents.
Isn’t that happening already? Isn’t that just absolutely happening already? I mean, yesterday I talked about Starbucks and their shift, investment Nashville, Tennessee. 250,000 square feet of new office space. 2,000 employees there. Fox article today. And I’m going to be podcasting that. Washington state will lose like $750 million in revenue over the next XYZ number of years due to Starbucks moving there instead of continuing on in Washington state. And it’s because of stuff like this. Tax flight from the state’s wealthiest residents. It’s not just going to be the state’s wealthiest residents.
It’s going to be anybody that can leave that wants a better quality of life that doesn’t want to be taxed out the absolute, you know, what, and just wants a better option. Just wants a better option. Internal records obtained through public disclosure requests by investigative reporter T.J. Martinell with The Washington Square claim Did I say Washington Square before? Maybe I I missed that. I can’t remember. Claim Washington state lawmakers and the Attorney General’s office coordinated coordinated. Hey, we’re going to make this millionaire tax specifically designed to provoke a legal challenge.
Martineller’s report suggests the primary legislative intent is to force the Supreme Court to go back on the 1933 Culliton decision. In August of 2025, email to live legislative council Jamie Pedersen, Seattle, bill’s prime sponsor, outlined his objectives for the proposed 9.9% tax on federal adjusted gross income exceeding a million. I expect the bill will get challenged in court. And so they are working back back and forth. Well, we know it’s going to get challenged in court. What does that look like? What is our best strategy to get this bad boy through? I would like to force the Supreme Court to consider its case law that considers income to be property.
Why are they doing all this? Why are Why are they doing all this? Why is this on purpose? Why is this happening? These guys know this is going to drive out the wealthy from Washington state. These guys know this is going to drive out business. And yet we’re seeing this in all kinds of states across the United States. California’s got a billionaire tax. Illinois, Chicago considering a millionaire tax. Oh, we got to figure out how to tax these people somehow to pay their fair share, right? And then when they leave, like in in the case of New York City, Kathy Hochul, governor, “Hey, all you folks, all the wealthy New Yorkers that moved to Florida, we’d like you to come back, please.
Pretty please?” Why are they doing this? That’s the question, right? What’s the end goal here? Cuz this is this is so coordinated. This is so wildly coordinated. This is not just per chance. This is not just Washington State getting together and going, “You know what? We just can’t quite seem to meet our budget needs, and so let’s just do a millionaire tax.” No, this is this is on purpose to drive people out, and they don’t care. They don’t care. The economics of this are so blatantly obvious. People will leave, businesses will leave, corporations will leave, the wealthy will leave. It’s on purpose.
I mean, there’s there’s no way around it. Cuz you thinking this is a good idea? Um we need a more progressive tax structure. All right, well, when all your poor people are left, and they’re not generating any revenue, you can’t balance the damn budget. Good luck with that. Yeah. Martinel told to Fox 13 that the record show the bill was tail tailored not to avoid legal scrutiny, but to invite it. “They’re not being subtle or being nuanced,” Martinel said. “They’re explicitly stating in these emails that this is the purpose of the tax, to make sure it only runs up to legal problems on an issue they want the Supreme Court to address.” So, how do we streamline this bill to make sure that it doesn’t go this direction or this direction, cuz those wouldn’t be advantageous to get this through.
It goes this way to the Supreme Court. Record show, Attorney General’s office provided detailed guidance on the bill’s language. Some included on avoiding a marriage penalty. Keep the legal focus solely on the Colton precedent. Attorney General’s office also noted the absence of an emergency clause which would have prevented voters from challenging the law through a referendum. So effectively warning that the voters might have a say. They don’t want it to go to that because then they’re they’re host cuz the voters will say no. Meanwhile, we’ve got a lawsuit. We do have a lawsuit going through.
We’ll see what happens with that. This thing’s going to be tied up 10 ways from Sunday in in court, right? There’s the state officials defending the policy, of course. Of course. >> [snorts] >> Including Governor Bob Ferguson. He argued tax is a tool to balance the state’s tax code. How about you do some cuts there, big Bob? What about cutting down the budget instead of spending hundreds of millions of dollars on ridiculous stuff we don’t need or want. State officials maintain the tax is designed to ensure the wealthiest residents. Um which ones are going to be left after you put this bad boy in effect?
Who’s going to want to stay around for this? Oh, yeah. Tax me. Oh, I like it. I like it. Wealthiest residents pay their fair share to fund essential services. Aren’t we already funding essential services? No, just more? Just, you know, way more now? Is is that what we’re doing? Such as K-12 school meals. We don’t have that currently? Kids in K-12 aren’t getting meals? Oh, they are. Oh, so this is just more money and support for small businesses. See how they zing that in there at the end? Oh. Oh. This is going to be a godsend for small businesses who are already being absolutely choked by the state’s B&O tax, right?
That takes it off the gross. Not off your profit. Addressing the collaboration between the legislature and legal counsel, a spokesperson for Nick Brown, he’s the state attorney general, and the Center Square’s misleading narrative is nonsense and provided Fox 13 with the following statement. We’re required by law to represent the legislature. They ask They get to ask us questions and we respond. There’s nothing unusual about any of that. It’s what attorneys in the office of attorney generals do. Every Washington attorney general has represented the legislature, answered questions from legislators of all parties, and given advice when requested.
That some political actors want to make more of it doesn’t change the facts. Uh-huh. Okay. All right. Yeah. Whatever there, dude. Yeah. Big picture. Despite the state’s assertion the tax is targeted only at higher earners, critics and some taxpayers expressed concern concern that overturning the 1933 precedent would clear the way for a broad-based income tax. And that is exactly what this is all about. It’s about an income tax for everybody. Ugh. Great. Love it. Oh, just want to pay my fair share. Now, I won’t give a rat’s ass cuz I’ll be gone. Uh This this This whole thing is just it’s absurd.
It’s It’s absurd. And you know what? It’s coordinated absurd. This is all planned. This is not just “Ah, we need to come up with some revenue.” If the bill does what it’s intended, everyone in the state could be subject to paying an income tax. Absolutely 100%. Um you know what? I’m going to skip over to an article from Future 42. Great group that um has a lot of good stuff. They are a nonprofit. Take a look at their website, future42.org. I’m going to skip down to Just before the income tax bill passed the state house in March, this past March, Democrat legislators rejected an amendment that would have made it significantly harder to lower the income threshold from a million to whatever.
And expand the tax to more Washingtonians. That decision raised eyebrows at the time. Hey, if you’re saying this is only for millionaires, why are you making it so difficult to to not be able to lower that threshold to include everybody. Why if if it’s just for millionaires, let’s throw that threshold in there and we’re all good. Only millionaires, right? That’s what you’re telling us. Only millionaires. Oh, oh, oh, it’s it’s it’s not just Oh, I got it. Okay. That was the raising of eyebrow. Hmm, what’s going on here? But in light of these recently discovered emails, there was a clear signal of what was always intended.
This is This is the way it’s gone. Here’s a couple of good paragraphs. The solicitor general is not a legislator or advisor. He’s the state’s top appellate lawyer, responsible for representing Washington in court and defending state law, including the Constitution before judges. His role is to argue cases, not help lawmakers design legislation to overturn constitutional precedent. That’s what makes this coordination so troubling. Lawmakers have their own legal resources, including non-partisan staff attorneys tasked with advising on legislation that they rely on during the legislation session to craft bills.
The fact that Senator Pedersen appears to have bypassed those channels and instead worked directly with the Attorney General’s office raises further questions about the intent behind these conversations. Hey, you know what? We’re not going to We’re not going to use our own in-house counsel. We need to We need to send this right to the tippy-top. Let’s go right to the Attorney General’s office. Let’s get the ruling from them. Let’s have them help out on this. So, I I that is a this is a well-crafted bill that had intent far beyond millionaires. And if Washingtonians don’t understand that and don’t see what’s coming, then you know, you get to stay behind and and and pay your fair share of taxes, which are going to be more because there’s going to be fewer and fewer people that have an IQ over 70 that want to stay in Washington state.
It’s going to be a lot of people who won’t be able to move because they can’t financially afford to. And unfortunately, this taxation is going to be very regressive. And it’s going to tax everybody and you know, whatever. The this this is the way this thing’s going. The implications are significant. Rather than simply proposing a new tax, lawmakers coordinating with the state’s top legal officials to engineer a test case designed to overturn constitutional protections. I mean, if if I were them and this was my goal, that’s exactly what I would do. I’m no attorney, but you don’t need to be a genius to figure out, “Oh, okay.
The main thing getting in the way of us is this 1933 ruling. How can we get rid of that? How can we get rid of that precedent? Just get that bad boy out of the way and then just let us roll. Well, we’re going to do this, this, this, and this.” And that’s what these emails basically said, “This crosses a fundamental line.” Citizen Action Defense Fund Executive Director Jackson Maynard put it in the Center Square story, “The Attorney General’s role is to defend the Constitution, not help the legislature find ways to violate it.” Oh. Violate. Such a strong word. No, it’s absolutely what’s going on.
And you know what? It this the lack of transparency is is so so typical. It’s so common. Because if they came right out and said this stuff, people would go, “What? You’re going to do what? You’re just basically telling us to bend over and we’ll take it and we’ll like it? Oh, okay. All right. Okay.” No, they they go about this kind of slimy hidden way, but it’s the way they have to because if their true intent, which we know now, if their true intent was out there, people people get upset. And you know what? People on the right have gotten upset. And and some Democrats have got upset as well, but not nearly enough.
Bottom line, Washington state is going to get an income tax one way or the other. That’s just what’s going to happen. One way or the other, if this thing gets shut down in the court system, something’s coming, right? This This is what that is. This is This is the the 1.0 version. This is the initial version of whatever it takes to get rid of that precedent and for Washington state to come up with its income tax because Lord knows we’ve got taxes on everything else. We’re just missing that magic income tax, right? We’re just missing that magic income tax. So, you know, some of the highest gas taxes, some insane business taxes.
B&O tax in Washington state, you’re like, “What?” Oh, yeah, that’s a chunk. I pay a ton in B&O taxes. Ton in B&O taxes. They’re painful cuz they come right off the top, right off your gross. Doesn’t matter what your expenses were, it doesn’t matter what your profit is. It’s like, “Oh, that’s a lot of money.” And it’s a lot of money. So, you’ve got businesses, Starbucks, you know, being the prime example, just out, “We’re going to go invest more heavily in Nashville, Tennessee because they have less taxes, it’s more affordable, and they are a more business-friendly environment. This is exactly the kind of taxation that people will leave Washington and Seattle.
Seattle’s the case study, right? What happens if you place a hefty employee tax on big business that’s got employees making over 125k a year? What happens? What happened to Starbucks yesterday? Oh, yeah. 100 million investment, 225 250,000 square feet of office space, and 2,000 employees. What they’re doing in Nashville. Didn’t take a genius to figure this out. Washington state leaders, they know it’s coming, and yet they still just oh, how can we get this through? They’re just hell-bent on taxing the absolute f out of whatever they can. Got to Got to squeeze blood from that turnip, right? Oh, let’s make it happen.
Let’s Let’s Let’s make this happen. So, this is this is no shocker, and yet the fact that emails come up, it’s kind of like yeah, that sounds about right. This totally sounds about right cuz this is how this goes. And with all the news stories that I read, this this is a coordinated effort across the board. This is the entire West Coast. This is This is every big blue city. So, you’ve literally got blue versus red going on. I mean, we’re in it. You are in it one way or the other. You’re in it with your pocketbook. You’re in it with your vote. Some wild wild stuff. I wish they’d just come right out and say, “Here Here’s the game you’re all playing that you don’t know you’re playing.” You know what I mean?
All right, what are the rule Oh, there are no rules. Okay. >> [snorts] >> Yeah, that makes sense. Oh, what’s the end goal here? Just tell us. Just tell us what it is. Love to know. In the meantime, podcast. Days, weeks, months, decades, decades upon decades. I mean, that’s kind of where we sit. Crazy. Thanks so much for being here. Love to have you subscribe. Hit that notification bell. I’ll see you in the next episode. Bye for now. >> [music] [music]
Up next

Washington Business Tax Exodus: Columbia Bank’s $8M Move
Watch next


Topics in this story
See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.
Your host
Sean Reynolds
Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.
Reasonable+
The stories too hot for the algorithm.
$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.
Start your 14-day free trialYour daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.
Join the conversation
Keep it factual. No insults. House rules
No comments yet. Start the conversation.