Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

Taxes

Washington Millionaires Tax Faces a Constitutional Court Fight

Washington's new 9.9% tax on income over $1 million is headed to court.

Share:

Washington Millionaires Tax Faces a Constitutional Court Fight

Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.

Prefer audio? Listen to the podcast version:

The Washington millionaires tax — a 9.9% levy on household income above $1 million — is headed straight for a constitutional court fight over whether income counts as property. Both chambers passed it, the governor is eager to sign, and opponents are already preparing to challenge a tax voters have rejected ten separate times.

Key Takeaways

  • The bill imposes a 9.9% tax on household income above $1 million, starting in 2029.
  • Senate Bill 6346 passed 51 to 46, with some Democratic no votes.
  • Washington voters have rejected a state income tax ten times.
  • The fight centers on Culliton v. Chase, a 1933 ruling that income is property.

What is the Washington millionaires tax?

It’s a 9.9% tax on the portion of household income above $1 million, taking effect in 2029. The measure passed the legislature and is on its way to the governor’s desk. Supporters describe it as a tax on the top 1% of earners; the governor says it applies to less than half of 1% of Washingtonians while making life “more affordable for millions.”

An income tax is a levy on what people earn. Washington has never had a traditional one — which is exactly why this bill is expected to end up in court.

Why will the millionaires tax be challenged in court?

Because opponents say it’s an income tax that violates the state constitution. If passed, one critic said, the bill “will not survive even the most cursory constitutional challenge.” A legal action — potentially reaching the Washington Supreme Court — is considered all but guaranteed.

Free weekly email

The Friday Reasonable Brief

A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.

Subscription Form

We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.

This is not a tax on millionaires. This is a tax on all of us. It’s just a matter of when.

What does Culliton v. Chase have to do with it?

Everything. In 1933, the Washington State Supreme Court overturned a graduated income tax in Culliton v. Chase, ruling that income is property — which means a graduated tax on it is unconstitutional. Many assume Culliton is still good law, requiring a constitutional amendment before any income tax beyond a flat 1% levy.

But supporters argue a modern court might take a “clean slate” approach, noting Culliton relied on an earlier state case the court arguably misread and on U.S. Supreme Court cases since reversed. If the court reconsiders, the tax could be upheld.

Why not just send it to the voters?

Former Attorney General Rob McKenna argued that if lawmakers want an income tax, they should send a constitutional amendment to voters — the honest route. Six times the legislature has referred such amendments, and voters said no each time.

Instead, lawmakers are passing the tax outright, apparently hoping the Supreme Court will effectively amend the constitution by deciding income isn’t property. Under current rules, an income tax would have to be uniform, capped at 1%, and applied to everyone — not graduated at 9.9% on top earners.

Who really pays when the wealthy leave?

The middle and lower classes. When you tax millionaires and businesses, many leave — as Starbucks has started shifting operations to Tennessee and founder Howard Schultz relocated to Florida just after the bill advanced. The people who can’t afford to move are left holding a bigger share of a shrinking tax base.

The pattern is regressive, like Washington’s Climate Commitment Act pushing gas prices to among the nation’s highest. And it feeds the same dynamic hollowing out the region’s business core.

Is an income tax inevitable in Washington?

The argument here is yes. Democrats have run the state for 40 years and are already planning budgets around revenue they don’t yet have. With little appetite for cuts, raising taxes is the only lever they’ll pull — a millionaires tax today, and an income tax on everyone down the road.

That’s the trajectory Chicago has already walked, where “progressive revenue” eventually meant loading up ordinary homeowners once the wealthy had gone.

Frequently Asked Questions

When does the Washington millionaires tax take effect?

The 9.9% tax on household income above $1 million is set to begin in 2029.

How many times have Washington voters rejected an income tax?

Ten times, including six proposals that were constitutional amendments referred to voters by the legislature.

What is the core legal question?

Whether income counts as “property” under the state constitution — the issue decided in the 1933 Culliton v. Chase ruling that opponents say makes the tax unconstitutional.

Should a tax voters have rejected ten times become law through the courts instead of the ballot? Share your view in the comments.

Full Episode Transcript

Read the full transcript of this episode

It’s going to be tragic for for our economy and for our businesses. >> Senate Bill 6346 as amended by the house is declared passed. The state income tax will give our business nowhere to escape, unfortunately. And so, they’re going to start most likely moving out of state. >> The bill imposes a 9.9% tax on household income above $1 million starting in 2029. >> The bill passed with 51 votes in favor and 46 against. >> We’ve already seen Starbucks start moving to Tennessee. Microsoft has closed some of their Seattle offices. Amazon has shut down expansion in Washington. Starbucks founder Howard Schultz announced he and his family have moved to Florida just one day after the millionaires tax passed the house.

Schultz says the move is part of his retirement, but some Republicans argue this timing is no coincidence. The bill is headed to the governor’s desk and he said, “Quote, the millionaires tax will apply to less than 1/2 of 1% of Washingtonians, but make life more affordable for millions. I look forward to signing it.” Washington doesn’t currently have a traditional income tax, but that changes once this is signed. Opponents say this is a job killer that will drive businesses and hurt the state as a whole. It’s very concerning for for my business perspective. Court fight, possible voter initiative loom.

Washington state income tax passed. Governor’s going to sign it. We’re We’re in it now. We’re in it now. So, what’s that going to look like? Well, it’s going to It’s going to be legally challenged, for sure. The problem is is I think it’ll get through because even though Washington voters have 10 different times said, “No, no, no.” Washington state has such a supermajority with Democrats, and I think they can get it through the Washington court system. But still a little reading. Olympia lawmakers heard sharp testimony Tuesday as supporters and critics squared off over proposed millionaire tax.

Measure Opponents got unconstitutional and likely to spark an immediate court challenge that could reach the Washington Supreme Court. It will. It’ll go there, for sure. Supporters describe the proposal as a tax on the wealthy. Uh it’s it’s it’s only the top 1% of earners. But what’s interesting is that they are not limiting that to just that population of earners. It’s It’s going to It’s going to It’s going to be applied to everybody. It It just will. It Opponents argue it amounts to an income tax that violates the state constitution. And that’s why it’ll be taken to court. If passed, this bill will not survive even the most cursory constitutional challenge, let alone the robust ones it is sure to face from groups like ours, said Sam Spiegelman.

Critics say legal actions would follow quickly if the measure is approved. Measure has been approved in both the Senate and the House, Washington state. Governor is just more than happy to sign it. Oh, he’s He’s excited. He’s He’s He’s just Oh, he’s excited. This is progressive. You know, this stuff is on purpose, isn’t it? And these people do this knowing full well what’s going to happen. Because they’ve got themselves in a pickle. Only Democrats have been ruling Washington for 40 years. So, any of the major fiscal problems we have are because of Democrat and specifically progressive policy. And so, now you’ve got a situation where you’ve got unbridled spending, billions and billions and billions of dollars of new taxes, and you don’t have the revenue stream coming in.

So, Democrats, you know, as the beginning of this year, they did their Christmas retreat or whatever. And they just basically stated, “Well, we got to come up with something to create more income because, good lord, we know we’ve spent it and then some.” And the political machine just keeps going to the point where you just need more and more taxes. And then as that happens, as you tax the millionaires, you push out all the businesses, push out the wealthy people. Who are you left with? You’re left with the middle class and the lower class, lower socioeconomic class. Those are the people who can’t afford to move out.

And they’re they’re going to they’re going to pay the most. It’s going to be extremely regressive, just like our gasoline tax. Super expensive to buy gas in Washington state. And it’s because of this Climate Commitment Act, which doesn’t really benefit the climate at all. But hey, let’s go ahead and just kid ourselves that that’s really important. Former Attorney General Rob McKenna also urged lawmakers to pursue a different approach during Tuesday’s public hearing before the Washington House Finance Committee. We’re going kind of going back and forth in time here because we know how it ended up, and yet some of these articles I mean and they’re just basically stating the obvious.

If this legislator wants an income tax, it should send a constitutional amendment to the voters. 100% agreed. But you’ve got enough control by progressive Democrats to get this through, to make this go. It’s going to go through. How about this whole notion here? How about this just absolute nonsense? Millionaires tax aimed at helping working families. It’s not going to do that. It’s going to hurt working families because they’re going to shoulder more of the taxation burden down the road as all the wealthy people leave. And I’m not saying I’m wealthy, but I am leaving. See you later, Washington.

Good luck with that. Enjoy. In an interview after the hearing, McKenna said Washington voters have rejected a state income tax 10 times. 10 times. Hey, let’s try it again cuz we’ll get it through one of these times. But six of those proposals were constitutional amendments referred to voters by the legislature. KOMO News asked McKenna whether an income tax has been politically untouchable and what is different now. They apparently are going to pass it without bothering to amend the constitution, he said. Presumably, they’re hoping the state Supreme Court will effectively amend the constitution by deciding that income is not part of property.

I don’t think they will. Appendix B, income tax constitutional issues. Okay, this just looks like super boring legalese, right? But it’s not. It’s important stuff. We’re just going to read this one paragraph here. 1933, that’s what you continuously hear. 1933, Washington State Supreme Court overturned a graduated state income tax that had been proposed by initiative and approved by more than 70% of the voters. Culliton versus Chase, 1933. Culliton versus Chase. Many of people assume that Culliton is still good law and that Washington courts would reach a similar decision today. If that’s true, constitutional amendment would be necessary before the state would impose any income tax other than a flat tax on gross income at a rate of no more than 1%.

However, there’s ample reason to believe that a modern income tax, the one that just got passed and is going to be signed by the governor, established by the legislature or by the voters, would now be upheld. Basic reason is that Culliton was based on an earlier Washington case which the state Supreme Court clearly misread it. Ooh, okay. So, what they’re saying is people have gone back, looked at the case, and went, “Well, we tried it today. This bad boy get through.” More importantly, the earlier case was based on a line of United States Supreme Court cases that have subsequently been reversed.

Oh, ouch. Our court would likely take a clean slate approach to the income tax today, and guess what? It would pass. It would pass, for sure. So, you know what? Whether it’s this one or another one down the road, the Democrats don’t have any other options but to continue to find places to raise those taxes because lord knows they are not capable of cutting, making cuts, of trimming things down. That’s just not really possible because they are so convinced that everything that they’re spending money on is critical to the people. And yet the people are funding all this. And the people that can afford it most are leaving.

They’re leaving in droves. You know what? Democrats don’t care cuz Democrats ultimately don’t really care about their constituents. They talk about, “Oh, this is going to make it more affordable for Washington state citizens.” No, it’s not. It’s not. It’s going to have the reverse impact. Fewer people, less tax revenue coming through. It’s not that hard to figure out unless you’re a Democrat, unless you’re a progressive, unless you’re mentally incapacitated in order to think logically. You just can’t do it. Oh, yeah, it’s going to be great. It’s going to make things cheaper. No, it’s not. It’s not.

It’s like Katie Wilson getting elected as socialist in Seattle and saying she’s going to have a positive impact on affordability. What are you going to do to make anything affordable without absolute subsidies from the taxpayers? You’re not. You’re not. You’ve already baked in the cost of everything in Washington state. You baked in the cost of expensive gas, third highest in the country. You baked in the cost of housing. You baked in the cost of child care. Child care’s some of the most expensive here. And it’s just one thing after another. McKenna said such a move would amount to a test case.

He argued that under Washington’s constitution, income is considered property based on a broad definition adopted in the ’30s and repeatedly upheld by the state Supreme Court. He also said voters have consistently rejected constitutional amendments that would exclude income from the definition of property. Okay, so you know, we’re going back on a really, really old court case, but that’s our that’s our basis for what we’re thinking. Now, has the Washington State Supreme Court, have they gone in different directions? Yeah. They’ve had the homeless case that they they tried. Um I forget what that one was called, but they came up with, oh yeah, okay, yeah, it’s not cruel and unusual punishment, go ahead and sweep those encampments.

Well, okay. All right, let’s do it, boys. Let’s get after it. And you know what? Nobody really wants to sweep the encampments cuz they know it’s not effective, but it’s better than doing nothing. I think the whole homeless industrial complex is just a complete scam in which they get taxpayers’ dollars because the federal pit count, the point-in-time count, they get more money for the more homeless they have. So, they just dole out all this money to these NGOs and homeless industrial complex just kind of keeps getting bigger and they get more money and gets bigger. There’s zero incentive, zero incentive to actually solve the homeless crisis.

They talk about it. Talk about it 10 ways from Sunday, but in reality, what incentive do they have to actually solve people getting off the streets? None. They got none. So, we end up with billions of dollars being spent on permanent supportive housing. It’s just uh the whole thing. The whole thing is just one big progressive, ah, look at us go. We’re progressive. This is great. This is so we’ve got liberal politics working here. This is the greatest thing ever. It just drives a state into the ground. Washington used to be a great state to run business. Really did. Really did. Damn near impossible now.

So, you know, who’s going to want to do that? No, just some somebody that’s just bound and determined to you know, be here in Washington. Ah, I can make it. All these other people are just dumb. We can make it go. We can we we can we can overcome the tax structure problems. No, because that is literally, literally not conducive to doing business. So, Mechanic goes on to say, any income tax we’d have today would have to follow the rules for property taxes. Means it has to be uniform, not progressive, and it can means it has to be everybody. It can’t be higher than 1%. Six times the legislature has found two-thirds majorities in the House and Senate sent a constitutional amendment to the voters to say income is not part of property.

No. No. Legal battle appears likely if the measure advances. That’s got That’s what’s going to happen. I mean, it’s just absolutely guaranteed to happen. But you know what the the bottom line here is an income tax is going to happen in Washington state. It’s just going to. It has to. Because these Democrats, they’re literally already planning the budget based on some of these numbers. Because they don’t have enough money coming in to make it go of it. Opponents say they’re preparing to challenge the tax in court if it’s approved. At least one group has indicated it would seek to repeal the measure through a citizen initiative putting the issue before voters.

I don’t think there’s any voters that are just so gung-ho, oh yeah. I’m a millionaire and I want to be taxed. I mean, you you’ve you’ve randomly got these people that just pop up and you’re like, you are such a puppet. You don’t even know what you’re saying. You’re just saying a bunch of ridiculous gibberish. And you’re expecting other people around you to go, yeah, uh-huh, yeah, okay. No. People What people are doing with people are saying, well, that’s pretty much last straw here. We’ve already we’ve paid and paid and paid and paid and there’s no upside to running a business here. So, why don’t we just look at someplace else and it’ll be way better.

And that’s what people are doing, especially people with money, especially millionaires. They’re not going to pay these taxes. They’re going to work out a way where they spend 6 months and a day out of state doing something else, right? Running a business from somewhere else. It’s so easy to run so many businesses now remotely. You don’t have to physically be there. You know what I mean? And your headquarters, well, move it. Like Starbucks, right? Starbucks just did that. Yeah, going to move some of our facility to Tennessee. And yet Washington state leadership is so dumb that um they think that people are just going to stay in place and just take it.

Just absolutely take it. And that’s not That’s not how this game is played. And unfortunately, they will be the ones that lose when they realize, oh, yeah. Uh, interesting. Yeah. Don’t quite have enough taxpayers to generate that tax revenue and as a result, we’re going to have to tax whoever is left, last man standing. Tax them a lot. Where have we seen that? How about Chicago? How’s that working in Chicago? That progressive revenue. Is that taxing just the rich? No. No. Taxing everyday taxpayers on homes that they got to just absolutely load them up with taxes cuz that’s the only other place they haven’t taxed yet.

Millionaire income tax today? Income tax on everybody else down the road. And for those of us who don’t want to wait around and find out how long that’s going to take, we just kind of jet out. Go to someplace that has lower taxes or whatever it is that makes you happy. It’s not what’s going on here in Washington state. What’s happening here in Washington state is happening super rapidly and all in the wrong direction. And I’ve lived here 57 years. And I’ve run a business for 30 something of those years. Couple of businesses. Yeah. Just not conducive to doing business and and any which way you look at it, just the whole optics of Washington state now are terrible.

You got billionaires leaving. You got millionaires leaving. You got business owners leaving. You got businesses leaving. And all because of policy that’s totally unnecessary, because of spending that’s totally unnecessary, because of fiscal mismanagement and inability to actually follow a budget that makes sense. But to the majority of Democrats, it’s what we’re doing. It’s what we’re doing. It’s why I’m leaving. Thanks so much for being here. Love to have you subscribe, hit the notification bell. I’ll see you in the next episode. Bye for now. >> [music]

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

Washington Millionaires Tax Survives After I-645 Vote

Washington Millionaires Tax Survives After I-645 Vote

Watch next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.