Skip to content
Sign in Join Reasonable+

California

Work From Home Fee: Bay Area Landlord Wants $200 a Month

A Walnut Creek ADU asked $3,250 a month plus $200 if you work from home.

Share:

Work From Home Fee: Bay Area Landlord Wants $200 a Month

Watch the full episode in the player above — everything in this article comes straight from the episode.

A Walnut Creek landlord attached a $200-a-month work from home fee to a newly built 535-square-foot cottage already asking $3,250, and the backlash was loud enough that the listing came off the market. The fee sounds indefensible on first read. The utility math behind it is not, and that is the uncomfortable part of this story.

Key Takeaways

  • The Northgate-neighborhood ADU listed at $3,250 a month with utilities, Wi-Fi, and designated parking included, plus $200 more if the tenant worked from home.
  • Zillow data puts average Bay Area rent around $3,650 a month, roughly 81% higher than the national average.
  • Realtor.com puts Walnut Creek’s median rent at $2,900, so the surcharge lands this unit about $550 above the typical local rent.
  • Derek Barnes of the East Bay Rental Housing Association called the charge not necessarily unacceptable, and said fees like it are unlikely to spread.

What is a work from home fee?

A work from home fee is a monthly surcharge a landlord adds to rent when the tenant works remotely from the unit, on the theory that a full-time occupant burns more of the utilities the landlord is already covering. That is the entire idea. Whether it holds up depends completely on who is paying the utility bill.

In this case, the landlord is. The listing bundles water, sewer, garbage, electricity, and Wi-Fi from the main house into the rent, along with designated parking and a private patio. The cottage itself is a newly built, furnished one-bedroom, one-bathroom accessory dwelling unit with a sunlit living space, hardwood floors, and a recently updated kitchen with custom cabinetry and stainless steel appliances, within walking distance of Shadow Brook Winery, top-rated restaurants, and boutique shopping.

Landlords already charge for behavior, and nobody blinks. Run a daycare out of the unit, that is extra. Bring a big dog that is going to chew up the floors, that is extra. Park a bunch of extra cars, that is probably extra too. What makes this one land differently is that working from home is not an unusual use of a home anymore. It is how a large share of the workforce lives.

Free weekly email

The Friday Reasonable Brief

A short stack of receipts, every Friday. Free.

Subscription Form

We never sell your email. Unsubscribe anytime.

Why did the Walnut Creek listing get pulled?

Because renters noticed, and then a television station noticed. “That’s crazy,” area renter Samantha Wandimu told ABC affiliate KGO-TV. Another renter, Cody Hall, called the fee ridiculous. Christopher Williams, who works remotely from Chicago, said he had never heard of anything like it.

ABC7 went out to the property and called the person listing the unit. Nobody answered the door and nobody called back. Shortly after the story ran, the rental came off the market entirely.

I look at a lot of real estate listings. A lot of rental listings. A lot of listings in general. I have never seen a $200 monthly charge attached to whether the tenant happens to be at a desk in the living room. That is why this became a news story instead of a line item.

Does the utility argument actually hold up?

Partly. Go line by line and it gets thinner than the landlord would like.

  • Water and sewer: real. Someone home all day eats more meals there and flushes more. On a 535-square-foot unit, still small.
  • Electricity: real. Lights on, computer on, heat or air running through the middle of the day instead of sitting at 60 degrees.
  • Garbage: negligible. One extra lunch and some snacks does not fill another can.
  • Wi-Fi: this one should not be on the list at all. The listing offers Wi-Fi off the main dwelling, and no remote worker should be running a job over the landlord’s router.

Barnes, who runs the East Bay Rental Housing Association, made the fairest point in the whole segment. When a tenant never sees the bill, the tenant never manages the usage.

You’re not likely to be aware of your usage of these precious resources if you don’t see a bill.

He is right. But it cuts both ways, and the landlord did not think that part through. Charge a flat $200 up front and you have just told the tenant the meter is prepaid. Now the extra-long hot shower is free. Now the garbage from somewhere else goes in your can, because they are paying for it. That is not a fix. That is a different incentive problem wearing the same jacket.

The real problem is the meter, not the tenant

Strip out the outrage and this is a submetering story. Accessory dwelling units frequently do not get their own unit number, their own electric meter, or their own water account. They hang off the main house. When a landlord physically cannot separate the tenant’s consumption from their own, there are two options: eat the variance, or price it into the rent.

Pricing it in is the honest move, and it should be invisible. Set the rent where it needs to be and stop itemizing. The moment you break out a $200 line labeled by the tenant’s employment arrangement, you have invited a fight you did not need, and in this case a camera crew on the sidewalk.

The cleanest answer of all is the boring one: have the tenant cover their own utilities. That is a no-brainer in almost any other configuration. It is exactly what an ADU without separate meters makes hard.

What going remote actually costs, from the other side

Back in 2011 I shut down my office space. A group of appraisers and real estate brokers, all of us virtual. People asked how you run a business without an office. Dropbox, email, telephone, a ton of video conferencing. It worked then, and the pandemic settled the argument for everyone else.

One of the first conversations I had was with my office manager, a former Boeing employee who has been with me for years. She pointed out that she could no longer set the heat to 60 and walk out the door, and that she would be on the internet all day. Both fair. I covered her internet, because that is a legitimate business expense.

That is the same math the Walnut Creek landlord is running, just pointed in the opposite direction. Employers absorbed the cost of moving work into the home. This landlord is trying to bill the worker for it.

Will work from home fees spread?

Barnes does not think so, and his reasoning is structural. Single-family landlords have more room to attach unusual fees than large apartment operators do, because bigger buildings run into more rent regulation. In a heavily regulated market, you cannot simply bolt a new charge onto a lease and hope it sticks.

My read is narrower. It is fair game, which is not the same thing as right or fair. Landlords can charge for all kinds of things, and in a market where costs only move one direction, somebody was always going to try this. That West Coast pressure keeps surfacing in the numbers, from Portland’s dead-last investment ranking to Denver’s 90%-off skyscraper sales. Operators are hunting for revenue wherever they can find it.

The Bay Area version of the squeeze shows up at street level too, including Goodwill shuttering its Oakland store after a remodel. Costs climb, somebody has to carry them, and the whole fight is over who.

What this really says about Bay Area rent

Average Bay Area rent sits around $3,650 a month, roughly 81% higher than the national average. Walnut Creek’s median rent is $2,900. This cottage, with the surcharge, asks about $550 over the typical rent for the area, for 535 square feet. That is the context in which one more fee becomes a story instead of a footnote.

It also produces the most predictable outcome imaginable. Ask a prospective tenant whether they work from home and watch them suddenly discover they go to the office every day. Then the landlord is standing at the window with binoculars trying to decide whether to ding somebody $200 this month. Nobody wants to run a rental that way, and no tenant wants to live under it.

The unit is genuinely nice. New construction, furnished, private patio, walkable location, an ADU rather than a studio wedged into a stack of other studios. Price it accordingly and nobody writes a story about you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much was the Walnut Creek rental asking?

$3,250 a month for a furnished 535-square-foot one-bedroom, one-bathroom ADU, with utilities, Wi-Fi, and designated parking included, plus $200 a month if the tenant worked from home.

Is a work from home fee legal?

The coverage did not settle that. What Derek Barnes of the East Bay Rental Housing Association did say is that single-family landlords generally have more flexibility on extra fees than larger apartment buildings, which run into more rent regulation.

Did anyone from the listing ever respond?

No. ABC7 stopped by the property and called the person listing the unit and received no response. The rental was later taken off the market.

I have never run across this in the Seattle area, and I would genuinely like to know how widespread it is. Have you seen a work from home fee on a listing where you live, or had a landlord float one at renewal? Tell me in the comments, because I cannot tell yet whether this was one landlord overreaching or the first crack in something bigger.

Full Episode Transcript

Read the full transcript of this episode

an additional work-from-home fee. What are your thoughts on that? >> Work-from-home fee? >> Yeah. No, I’ve never heard of that. >> I mean, that’s crazy. >> An additional $200 a month if you’re working from home. What are your thoughts on that? >> That sounds ridiculous. >> The 535-sq-ft cottage is furnished, and it also has a private patio and parking. But, more money if you work from home, Carolina. >> A newly built ADU in Walnut Creek is listed for 3250 a month. It has a private patio, designated parking, and includes utilities and Wi-Fi. But, it also states if you’re working from home, it’s an additional $200 a month.

>> One California rental company is is turning heads after charging an extra $200 a month for renters working from home. >> That’s uh expensive, to say the least, cuz I think the rent prices out here were already expensive. >> He’s right. Zillow data shows the average Bay Area rent is about 3650 a month, roughly 81% higher than the national average. So, another $200 is raising eyebrows. >> It’s It’s almost like a utility cost recovery or environmental conservation fee. >> Derek Barnes, with the East Bay Rental Housing Association, says if utilities are included, remote workers can drive up those costs, and the landlord appears to be disclosing that up front.

>> ABC7 Eyewitness News here. Is anybody home? >> We stopped by. >> Cameron Bob here with ABC7 Eyewitness News. >> And called the person listing the unit. We did not receive a response. >> [music] >> Bay Area landlord tries to charge tenants an extra $200 per month work-from-home fee. Does it make any sense at all? Extra wear and tear on the house? More utility costs? What’s the dealio? Let’s get into it. Here we go. Got to be honest, after after I read through read through this article, I still wasn’t sure why the landlord was charging, but inherently some of it makes sense.

Let’s Let’s Let’s check out the details. Walnut Creek, California, that is um East Bay. Nice area. Nice area of California. Rental has been taken off the market after it received serious backlash for demanding an extra $200 a month from any renter who works from home. I look at a lot of real estate listings. I look at a lot of rental listings. I look at a lot of listings in general. I have not seen a $200 monthly rent proposed. Hey, you got to pay this if you’re working from home. Things like people who are tenants that want to do a daycare. All right, that’s extra. You got a big dog that’s going to scratch up the floors.

Okay, that’s extra. You got a bunch of extra cars. All right, that’s probably going to be extra. Bay Area rental immediately baffled renters throughout the area when they noticed the unusual fee in addition to the $3,250 monthly rent. Now, when you hear that, you think that’s not that bad. California, 3250 a month, that’s not terrible. Well, it’s a 500-and-something square foot unit. It’s tiny. It’s tiny. “If working from home, an additional $200 monthly”, the listing states. “That’s crazy”, area renter Samantha Wandimu told local ABC affiliate KGO-TV. Is it though? You got somebody at home banging all the kitchen cabinets all day long?

I’m exaggerating, but opening up doors way more than normal than if somebody who’s 9:00 to 5:00 goes to the office. Somebody’s using the plumbing a ton more. Somebody’s maybe using the heat, using the electricity. Now, [snorts] what I had uh in 2011, I shut down my office space, had a bunch of appraisers, bunch of real estate brokers, and we went we went virtual. We all worked from home. People said, “Well, Sean, how can you run a business if if you don’t have an office?” Well, it’s pretty simple, actually. You You have things like back then we used Dropbox. We used uh what was it? But, yeah, a bunch of technology that allowed us to still communicate, email, telephone, video conferencing, used a ton of that, and you can you can get by no problem.

You don’t have to be in an office. Clearly, the pandemic yet, you know, just solidified all that. One of the conversations I had with my office manager, she’s a former Boeing employee, and uh she’s been with me for for years and years. She’s like, “Well, I’m going to be paying more for heat cuz I’m not going to be able to, you know, walk away from my unit and have the heat be on 60 all day. I’m going to be at home using up some more utilities.” And I was like, “Okay. Yep, that makes sense.” Yep, I needed to cover her internet cuz she’s on the internet all day. So, that’s a fair expense. So, there’s there is some give and take, but this one’s going the other direction.

If you work from home, we’re charging you. We’re charging you. Another renter, Cody Hall, called the additional fuel fee ridiculous. Well, if you don’t know specifically what it’s trying to cover. There are more expenses when people are in a home more often. What I would say is people running up and down the stairs, people you know, just general wear and tear. If somebody’s there all day long, granted, the argument’s going to be made, “Yeah, but if they’re working from home, they’re not doing that. They’re just sitting in front of a chair at the computer.” All right. Yeah, some some give and take, right?

Works remote, so some guy, Christopher Williams, works remotely in Chicago, said that he had never heard of that. I hadn’t, either. That’s why we’re talking about it. Dubbed the cottage the located in Walnut Creek’s Northgate neighborhood, the dwelling boasts itself as a newly built furnished one bedroom, one bathroom accessory dwelling unit. Okay, so it’s an ADU. It’s not the main unit, it’s an ADU. So this is important because we’re trying to work out who pays for the utilities. Okay? So it’s not a condo, but it’s very small. All right. Dub, the cottage, 300 535 square foot home includes utilities, Wi-Fi, parking, and a private patio.

Okay. So they’re saying the landlord is saying, “Hey, we’re covering all this. You’re going to be there a bunch more, you’re going to be using up more of these utilities. Let’s run through that.” Water, sewer, garbage. Okay? You’re going to be using up more water cuz you’re going to be, you know, basically doing three meals a day at home or something like that. You know, you’re going to be flushing the toilet more. Electricity? Yeah, you’re going to use more electricity cuz the lights are going to be on. Wi-Fi’s going to be on, computer’s going to be on, but is it that much more? That’s that’s what we’re trying to work out.

Wi-Fi, okay, that’s Wi-Fi from the main So what they’re saying is hey, you can use our Wi-Fi from the main main dwelling. Yeah, I wouldn’t be using somebody else’s Wi-Fi, you know what I mean? Especially if I’m working from home, hard no go. So that one, that’s out of there. Parking, okay, but parking is typically included or not included in in a deal, right? Outside of this $200 charge and a private patio. Okay, that’s just a feature. It is what it is. The abode features a sunlit living space, hardwood floors, and a recently updated kitchen custom cabinetry and stainless steel appliances. Cottage is within walking distance of the local Shadow Brook Winery, top-rated restaurants, and boutique shopping.

All right. Okay, but you know, extra 200 for working from home for that? It’s a good location. That should all be built in to the the base price. Yet, even with the elegance, comfort, and prime location, the extra working from home why working from home fee seems to be a deal breaker for prospective tenants. Okay, but more of the unit’s utilities are going to be used. You work from home. You run a daycare from home. House gets hammered, right? It’s going to be more. You’re going to have a bigger damage deposit. But, this is interesting because people have just thought, “Well, you you work from home.

It’s no different than you know, if if you work from an office.” Uh-uh-uh, the landlord says, “California, we’re going to squeeze you. We’re going to squeeze you for every drop we can get.” “Rent is already so expensive.” “Yes,” William said. And for this house, that’s absolutely true. According to realtor.com, the median rent in Walnut Creek is 2,900. Possibility of paying an extra 200 a month brings the dwelling’s rent 550 over the typical rent for the area. Okay, so it’s expensive. It’s expensive, but it’s nice. It’s new. It’s an ADU. You’re not in a you’re not in a 550 square foot one bedroom or studio condo in a wedged in with a whole bunch of other people.

It’s it’s somehow attached to a home. It doesn’t really talk about that. It doesn’t say it’s a detached ADU, a dadu. So, it’s an attached, you know, accessory dwelling unit of or not necessarily attached, but an accessory or a dwelling unit. Just it’s additional, right? While the fee is quite unusual, the CEO of East Bay Rental Housing Association, Derek Barnes, believes that the extra cost is not necessarily unacceptable. Double That’s almost a triple negative, isn’t there? Not necessarily unacceptable. Double negative. Okay, and that’s kind of my thought. If it were normal for a marketplace, and is this going to be normal for a marketplace?

That is my thought, and that is today’s discussion. Will this become the norm? You got to pay a little extra if you’re working from home, cuz you’re going to consume more utilities, more wear and tear and tear on the dwelling, arguably. Arguably. I would also say some of the pros are you’ve got a set of eyeballs on that unit. Nobody’s going to break in during the day, right? While you’re sitting at work, that’s not just happening. Um Yeah, so you’ve got a whole bunch of of different stuff going on. This landlord is kind of thinking, well, I’m covering all those expenses, and those are a lot of expenses.

All the utilities, normally a tenant would pay for their own electricity, right? A few hundred bucks a month on a on a decent-sized home. Yeah, you’re going to pay for your own internet, going to pay for, you know, you’re going to have your own Wi-Fi system, okay? That’s just a structured cost. You got to do the internet or do whatever it is to to get you what you need for your uh TV or internet setup. You’re going to have to have internet, especially if you’re working from home. Um you know, water, you’re going to use more water. You’re going to use more water. Sewer? You’re going to flush the toilet a few more times, inherently more expensive, but you get charged based on that.

Uh Yeah, I mean, it’s part of the package, right? And then garbage, are you going to have more way more garbage? You’re going to have some more garbage, but on a 530-something unit, I think the difference is negligible. Cuz you’re you know, you’re going to probably going to eat breakfast at home. I’m just spitballing here, and you’re probably going to still going to eat dinner at home if you’re you know like the most normal people. So, you add one more meal in there, lunch and some snacks. Is that a tremendous more amount of garbage? No, probably not. Probably not. So, to me it comes down to wear and tear on the unit.

And is there going to be more? Somebody working from home, hey, at least they’re employed. They’re going to pay your rent, right? That’s something you got to consider there. “You’re not likely, you know, to be aware of your usage of these precious resources if you don’t see a bill.” Barnes said. Okay, I think that part is fair. If you don’t know, you’re just going to spend it. But then, here’s the flip side to that. If you know you’re already paying for them with an additional 200, do you take an extra long hot shower just to get your money’s worth? Do you Do you take some garbage from from wherever and put it in the garbage at home cuz, you know, you’re covering it?

Do you flush the toilet two or three times each shot? Mhm, maybe. Maybe. Bottom line here is that rent is already really expensive, especially in California. Most parts of California. A lot of parts of California. It’s expensive, and so people are like, “One more bill? I don’t believe it.” I don’t believe it. But if you break it down, hey, have the tenant Have the tenant cover the utilities. And that to me is kind of a no-brainer. But, you know, ADUs are sometimes not necessarily assigned their own unit number. I don’t know how it is in Walnut Creek, but you might have some of that. This is part of the main dwelling.

It’s not on its own separate meter. Doesn’t have its own separate yada yada for all the utilities. So, you can’t really do it that way. Therefore, we’re going to stick you with a extra a month fee. Work from home fees are not likely to become widespread, according to Barnes. Single-family [snorts] landlords may have more flexibility to charge extra fees than larger apartment buildings due to location and rent regulations. Well, they had me there until due to location, and I’m like, what’s that got to do with anything? You know, rent regulations, yeah. Bigger the project, more regulations.

You’re in a state where rent is regulated, yeah, you’re not going to be able to throw these in. But, for for for most units, I think the $200 work-from-home fee is is fair game. Not saying it’s right, not saying it’s fair. I’m just saying, “Hey, you can charge for all kinds of stuff. You can. Things are already expensive. Why wouldn’t they get even more expensive?” >> [snorts] >> For the time being, renters are hoping that work-from-home fees don’t begin to spread. Here’s how this one ends. “If my landlord suggests that I don’t If my landlord suggests that work-from-home fees, I I actually don’t work from home.

Yeah. Uh yeah, yeah. No, no, I I I mean, I misspoke. I I don’t work from home. I, you know, I go to the office every day.” And you have to be the landlord out there with binoculars going, “Did he leave for work? Oh, he didn’t? I’m going to ding him 200 bucks.” Now, to me, it’s a it’s a matter of things are already so unaffordable. The tenants are are going, “This is This is nuts. This is crazy.” In this situation, I think it’s I I I I I think you could handle it differently and not have the tenant get worked up over the work-from-home fees. I think people just think you can slide a fee in, and hey, they’ll take it.

They’ll accept this. Cuz what are they going to do? Not rent it? That is an option. You don’t have to take it. But it sounds like there was enough feedback where hey, what are you doing here? And it made a news story, right? So, I have not seen this before. May- maybe I just maybe in the Seattle area this isn’t a thing. Is this a thing in the area where you live? Let me know in the comments. I’m I’m actually really curious. Is this going to be a new development? Is this something new that, you know, we got to contend with? Are you working from home? I’m going to need to have a notarized statement whether you work from home or not.

I’m typically okay with people working from home because I think there’s a certain stability to that that hey, you’re working. Yeah, you’re not going to be partying like a rock star cuz you got to get up and you got to work the next day, right? I’m working from home. That to me indicates something. Now, if you’re working from home as a drug dealer, yeah. No, right? Yeah, I’m working from home. Yeah, by the gram. Crazy stuff. All right. Yeah, let me know. Let me know if you guys have seen this before in your markets, I’d love to know. $200 monthly fee for somebody who works from home. Yeah, this is this is this is not going to go well for a lot of landlords who proposed this cuz people are going to they’re going to push back.

Like, what? I can’t just work from home anymore? 200 bucks? Work anywhere you want. Did for me on this one. Thanks so much for joining. Love to have you subscribe. Hit that notification bell. We’ll catch up in the next episode. Bye for now. >> [music]

Join the conversation

Keep it factual. No insults. House rules

Commenting is free

Create a free ReasonableTV account to comment and reply. All it takes is your email and a password.

Create a free account

Reasonable+ members also get members-only discussions and Ask Sean.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Up next

Millennium Tower Rent Record: $10,000 for a Tilting SF Tower

Millennium Tower Rent Record: $10,000 for a Tilting SF Tower

Watch next

Topics in this story

See more stories on each topic, and what people are saying about them.

Your host

Sean Reynolds

Sean hosts ReasonableTV: independent, receipts-first news on Seattle, Portland, California and the companies that shape them. The daily show reaches 189,000 YouTube subscribers.

Reasonable+

The stories too hot for the algorithm.

$3.33 a month, billed $39.99 a year (2 months free) — or $3.99 month to month.

Start your 14-day free trial

Your daily show stays free. Cancel anytime during the trial and you pay nothing.